A torque meter for a helical gear planetary gear box is simple.
Use an annular hydraulic cylinder to measure the helical
gear thrust. Last four jpg's.
Straight cut gears present another problem. Solution: machine a
very course
pitch
acme thread on the outer portion of the quasi stationary ring gear
and measure
the reaction torque with an annular hydraulic cylinder. Exactly the
way they
do
it in a PT6 that has straight cut planetary gears.
All we need is engine torque. With it we can calculate engine HP.
If one wants
it electronically use a pressure sensor instead of a cheap pressure
gauge on
the instrument panel with a annular hyd cylinder measuring the torque.
Mistral ought to incorporate this in their straight cut planetary
gear box.
It would be a big plus for buying their expensive PSRU.
The challenge is come up with a SIMPLER PRACTICAL system cheaper than
this approach that will survive in a hot gear box environment.
My thanks to Doug for stimulating me with his private emails on
this subject
:)
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
Paul,
Maybe I can stimulate or exasperate you some more:) Mistral and
the Bell 47
gears box both have their ring gears securely bolted in place.
There is no
quasi movement about them. Bell presses them in as well as bolts
them on.
Large torque is expected on a helicopter obviously.
>I absolutely agree that if the rubber torsional absorber could be
there
then the problem is elegantly solved. This was the first method I
eliminated
years ago. The second method was with strain gauge to measure the
force
between the engine flex plate and the sun gear drive plate. Sea
and Land's
and others company units have done this but you need to have some
electronics on board the plate affecting balance no doubt as well as a
wireless connection to get the data off the spinning plate. Now
this is
possible but not simple or inexpensive. $5,000. Ditto special
torque sensors
sandwiched between the prop and the output of the PSRU. These
devices move
just enough to just a strain gauge to stretch and change
resistance. Here
also a slip ring or wireless method is needed to access the
information.
Paul You did mention the following and I would like to share it with
everyone.
"It won't work having one sensor on the front of the engine and one
sensor
on the prop flange. Too much slop in all the parts."
>Yes I suspected that, thank you for confirming it. Lots of little
torque
reversals happening so an accurate measurement is not possible no
doubt.
"You still need a short length of shaft from the source of the torque
to the load not bathed in 225 degree F oil. You don't have it."
Actually I do if you consider 75mm long enough. There is a 1.25"
hardened
steel splined shaft running from the psru sun gear mount plate (hot
wet box)
to the sleeved collar attached to the torque dampener on the
counter balance
in the dry bell housing. The Aluminum starter gear wheel and turbo
compound
grooved pulley will be splined cut and slipped on.
In summary as I understand what you are saying, torque has to be
measured
between the engine output = source of torque, and the PSRU/prop input=
source of main load. So one way to do it is to measure the twist
on the
shaft between those two sources right?
Doug in Japan
I'll say!!! I am advocating unbolting them!!!!!!
Last question. You are not going to do it with a CD in 200 F hot air.
If you insist on doing it electronically one way is to use two
polished
flats on the shaft with laser shinning on them. As the shaft twist
the angle
of the mirror causes the beam to be reflected off at a different
angle. You can buy a CCD that in essence is a bunch of closely
spaced photo cells to measure this angle.
http://www.taosinc.com/
The laser and the linear optical sensor can be seven inches away
out side
the bell housing in cool air. A computer can read the optical
sensor in a
micro second.
7000 RPM is only 166 revs per second. Or one rev every .006 seconds.
One micro second is .000001 seconds therefore any old computer can
execute
6000 instruction every rev!!!! That is a very slow computer. 1975 era.
Single chip computers now-a-days are at least 10 times faster so
they can execute
60,000!!! instructions in one rev of the engine at 7000 RPM.
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor
Hi Paul,
I'm guessing here, but shouldn't there be some sort of measurable
reaction
torque on the motor mount in the area of the rubber Barry isolators?
If an oil filled annular ring, like Matt found off the shelf, were
incorporated into the mount then that oil pressure change could be
calibrated to an engine HP as you suggested using the long torque
bar attached to the prop flange. The most important design criteria
would be making it fail safe somehow. Not an easy undertaking but
probably doable if Doug Fir wanted to peruse it.......I have helical
gears : )
Dave M
Right on Dave.
Here is another way. I put the linear bearings in to reduce the
friction
as much as possible.
http://www.rotaryeng.net/dyno-mot-mount.jpg
--
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
No you just have to measure g-load and have a little chip subtract that.
John Gibbons
Why? Do we need to know what the HP is in a turn?
> Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
Frankly Paul why do we need to know the HP anyway, it just seems like
more
weight and complexity. I just think that if you are going to have an
instrument indicating something then it should be accurate and
reliable for
reading at any time (don't forget turbulence). If we want goofy we have
magnetic compasses. To me this subject seems to be occupying valuble
minds
that could be more useful working on other thing rotary.
John Gibbons
It would be nice if we knew HP. It would settle once and for all if
intake manifold
A was better than manifold B. I am also getting tired of spending big
bucks on dyno time. It would also get a better handle on props and BSFC.
Both mechanical devices mentioned so far weigh next to nothing.
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
One local fellow did something similar to the suggested CCD solution with
a pair of optocouplers for a custom redrive damper project.
Here is an old project page:
http://www.eaa245.dhs.org/Presentations/EA81Torsion/Torsion/index.html
The optocouplers measured ring gear teeth and a custom toothed wheel
at the prop after the redrive and damper.
The intent was to measure torsional resonance/damping by the position/twist.
This particular damper had quite a bit more travel than Tracy's redrive.
I'm not sure if these devices can read a more closely spaced pattern of
alternating black/white bands for greater granularity.
Cheers
Cary
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.