Subject: What do you think about this psru?
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 7/30/2007, 8:51 PM
To: AARotary Engine



> All,
>
> http://www.geareddrives.com/Buds_philosophy.htm
> Has a nice write up in the last Contact mag. I like the features of his
> psru----cs, separate lube, clutch arrangement as he did it, offset > shaft.
>
> He says "*Build the PSRU so that anyone would be feel good about taking
> their grandchildren on a cross country flight.* Safety being our first
> consideration, we do not advocate the use of belts, chains or planetary
> gears in something as important as a propeller drive. Belts break,
> chains stretch, and planetary gears are simply not designed to operate
> at high RPM's and under such a great load as they are under while in use
> in an airplane. Planetary gears do well in situations that only require
> high RPM for a very brief period of time, but are not designed to
> operate under consistent and continuous use at high RPMs. This is a
> recipe for disaster in our opinion. Spur gears, as we use in our PSRU,
> on the other hand, are designed to safely operate at a high RPMs and
> under continuously use. We chose to use what we know to be the most
> dependable and reliable technology for this application because our
> objective was to do what makes sense in terms of safety, reliability,
> and ease of maintenance. "
>
> Erstwhile comments on the planetary? What do you think Mistral makes of
> this? Of course his re drives are mostly made for V8's but I really like
> the clutch feature as he implements it!
>
>
>
> Marc Wiese
>
>
> I talked to these people at OSH and they don't have a clue. The > centrifugal clutch
> is nice. Also the yearly Chev V8 conversion. Here this year gone the > next.
>
> -- > Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.


I also spoke with Bud at OSH and I believe his words were "I'm not interested in that" when
I asked him about a 3:1 ratio.  As Paul mentioned, his interest is only for recip auto
conversions, he does have 700hrs on his 383ci SBC however.  His price is up there too at
around $9k.  At that point I would just use the Mistral PSRU.  Personally, I don't understand
the concern about planetary gears that are designed properly....heck, pretty much all turbo
props use planetary gear sets as far as I know, and if a turboprop isn't high rpm, then I
don't know what is...

By the way Paul, I looked for you at the "Design Of Water Cooled Aircraft Cooling System."
I figured you would show up at that forum and I wanted to meet you in person, oh well,
maybe next time....

Heath

Sorry I missed you.
I usually don't do the forums. How did that one go? Who was the speaker?
Any interesting tid bits you can share.
-- 
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.


The presenter was Timothy Shankland and it was pretty good.... I only made
about half
of it and when I showed up he was going through some heat transfer equations
to
calculate cooling efficiency and how big of a radiator is required for a
given engine.
I didn't take notes, but it seamed like pretty standard stuff.  His engine
of choice
was a Subaru.

It turns out he had a similar test setup as you did where he strapped a test
fixture
to his station wagon and hooked up a manometer to determine the best ducting
configuration.

Heath

I was staring at one of the computer animation displays of how the wankel
works and it hit me that each rotor acts like a two-cylinder, four-stroke
engine, so two rotors act like a 200hp four-banger like a Lycoming O-360.
An O-360 would beat the snot out of a reasonably light set of spur
gears--the six cylinder, geared Lycomings are pretty hard on gears.  An
internal spur gear, like Powersport, makes a lot of sense because because
the meshing is much more gentle and the lash between the gears is much
smaller.  Tracy Crook has been doing well with his planetary gears and the
three rotor should be much easier on the gears.

Steve Brazil

Here are some graphs on the subject. What most people do is use
rubber torque isolators or dampers. An ounce of rubber is worth a pound
of engineering :)

Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.