Subject: pilot position - was VTOL power to weight
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 9/7/2007, 1:41 PM
To: AARotary Engine


     "I updated the web site so check out
http://www.rotaryeng.net/VTOL.html
     Let me know if you find any errors."

     Paul,

     In your Boeing table you are putting the Installed power to weight as
     lb/sq.ft.  Do you mean to say hp/lb?  Since lb/sq.ft. is disk
loading,
     shouldn't the number be between 9 and 15?

     I think your design would be benefited by having the pilot stand
     vertically
     in the take-off and landing modes.  I have flown hang-gliders in
     California
     with a prone harness and it is quite comfortable for a while.  After
     transition, the pilot could "tuck-up" and reposition himself to a
normal
     sitting configuration.  Two sets of rudder pedals would be required
of
     course.  This would allow much better ingress/egress for the
     pilot.  This
     would be unhandy for the pax unless he/she were beside the pilot
     instead of
     behind.

     Regards,

     Norm DeBoer

     Yes. Thanks for catching that Norm. I fixed it on the web site.
     The numbers are correct as the HP is always less than the empty
     and gross weight.

     The problem with the side pax is too little wing area :) When
     sitting side
     by side the fuselage width intrudes on the wing area. Maybe a
     thicker flying wing design would work better in that case.
     Should be less drag. You would need clearance under your knees
     to operate the rudder pedals. Perhaps a handle bar would be better.
     Back and fourth for pitch. Twist for roll and right and left for
     rudder. I think the Air Scooter does that. I am beginning to like
     the idea. Visibility to the right might be a problem.

     I was thinking of just a window in the floor so the pilot
     could bend forward and look down between his knees for landing.
     Perhaps a strategically placed mirror would help. People park
     by looking in the rear view mirror.

     What is it like to lie on your stomach for 3 hours? I have never
     done it.
     --
     Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.



Lie on your stomach, superman style?  I'd need a headrest (for the
forehead).  It'd be like riding a modern bicycle or a sport motorcycle.
It would be somewhat athletic.  We'd like to build this such that the
average pancake breakfast visiting aviator can operate it - not require
a fighter pilot.  Ergonomics are important.

One other consideration..  I'd prefer my cranium to not be the first
part of my body to arrive at any kind of crash that might be
encountered.  Much better the legs or bottom..


Cheers,

Matt-


Matt,

You are right exactly.  This is why you want to be standing up during the
VTOL take-off, transition and landing.  If a forced conventional landing is
required, the first choice IMHO is to use a BRS.  The second choice would be
to use the conventional sitting position while landing horizontally. I have
not worked out the details of how to do the pilot reconfiguration during
flight, however, the prone position is not uncomfortable for short periods.
I have flown prone while flying hang-gliders in California in the 70's.
This would be an interesting development project that could be accomplished
cheaply in a garage or basement.  Think of a mock-up that pivots close to
the cg of a pilot.  The prone postion and conventional position will need to
be intigrated with each other such that the pilot reconfiguration will come
easily and naturally. I am thinking of a flight suit that has a set of
straps and attachment carabiner rings built into it.  While prone, the suit
would distribute the body weight all over instead of into a few strap
locations.  It would almost become like lying on a hammock.  There may also
need to be rails built into the airframe with a way to move between the two
configurations easily and quickly.  Does anyone have any ideas on this?

After the pilot repositions himself, he would be sitting in the "normal"
upright position with all the ease of any pilot.  Yes, it would take a small
amount of athleticism to accomplish the "tuck-up" or "half-loop with-in the
vehicle" after transition of course - and a good distance from the ground,
however, I believe the average pilot could do this - at least I know I
could, and I'm not exactly a spring chicken anymore. :)

What I think would be more difficult would be to try and mount the vehicle
and position oneself with your legs above the rest of your body and with
your head at the bottom.  Hard to get into and hard to get out of.  Also a
disconcerting position to be in while backing down when landing vertically.
I know the military vehicles used a seat that was reconfigurable from a 90
degree to a 45 degree position, however, IMHO it is much better to be
standing up and looking out of a window in the belly as Paul suggests.  The
Hiller Flying Platform had an untrained soldier flying with twenty minutes
of training.  He would be standing the entire flight.  The Hiller was too
stable and could not acheive horizontal flight - not that it had wings to
fly with anyway, but that's another story.

The beauty of the A/C configuration as Paul has it laid out at this time, is
that there is no requirement to have any "mixer" complications as ducted
fans on the wings and nose would require.  All the controls will be the same
in hover and horizontal flight.  Also, the disk loading is well with-in
reason and the design should have no problem getting down to the target
weight to make VTOL possible.

Again, IMHO, I beleive that the important thing about this concept is to get
it in the air and proven.  The Brothers did not put on any pax until the
flyer had logged plenty of time solo. After our VTOL configuration is
proven, we can build on our experience and put in a passenger.  Anyway,
after the solo version is proven, if you want company, let them fly one of
their own, - next to you! :)

Cheers and Regards,

Norm DeBoer




The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.