Hey Paul,
I heard a rumor that Buly is going to Lycoming.. Is that true??
Matt-
Yes. He could not deal with the EFI. I don't blame him.
For some one not trained in single chip microcomputer hardware
it is real tough to deal with. The vast majority of people have
enough
trouble with just simple wiring like lights and starters.
You just can't see them electrons :)
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
I am one of those who found EFI intimidating but I always thought I
would deal with it when the time came. However, there is almost a
continuous thread of problems faced by other builders trying to get
reliable performance out of the the electronic ignition and EFI
which of course I have been reading for years. I can't exaggerate
the relief I felt the when I decided to go to crank fired ignition
and a carb. It was a matter of accepting my own limitations. Jerry
Furthermore one is expected to solder 37 tiny wires on this
connector. I would say 80% of the people on here don't have the eye
sight,
skill and manual dexterity required to do this let alone the
electronic knowledge
to trouble shoot such a system.
I suggested years ago a simple printed circuit board adapter and screw
type connectors but the idea was rejected out of hand.
--
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
I have 670 hours now and zero problems with [the stock] EFI. Believe
it or not
my
airplane engine has never been flooded. Always starts hot or cold wx,
hot or cold engine.
Perry
Well you don't have an RX8 engine either :)
--
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
Perry,
Do you have a turbocharged engine or NA?
Doug Fir
It's stock 1986 NA.
In the early days (1999) I was worried about the EFI not being a
redundant system, but it's reliability is now proven (it was "proven"
anyway in car use). Redundancy is only needed for failure prone systems,
such as magnetos.
The only redundancy I have is a dual battery system, independently
selectable but I always run "both". Two sealed r-g lead-acid batteries.
I've never had a battery failure either, I replaced the originals after
5 years, running on the second set now.
Perry
I also might add, Perry is a very talented professional electronic engineer
so EFI holds no mysteries for him.
Now on the other hand (correct me if I am wrong Perry) he still has
not got it to lean the engine manually :)
I still think you need to try a pot in the mass airflow sensor circuit Perry.
--
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
Perry,
Thanks. Sound like you have a KISS system to me, and it is proven now. What
is the highest altitude you have flown your bird? I will be going EFI as
well by choice but then again for various reasons I also don't have a
choice:) I really don't know what all the phobia is about. With a little
study anyone can master the basics of modifying the standard auto CPU. For
safety sake pot the board, and use a back-up if desired.
If Megasquirt would work with a mass flow sensor than I would consider that
route. I've given up on using Tracy's unit and it is for sale if anyone
needs one real cheap.
Doug Fir
Hi Doug,
Can you describe what you have done and the results you got with
Tracy's unit that have pushed you to the decision to give up on using
it. There are a lot of us that are planning on using it and knowing what
you found as shortcomings would be very helpful. Thanx, DaveM
Dave
The short answer is it was only going to be used for initial testing on a
side port Renesis engine on a dyno. I have never used Tracy's unit and it is
still new in the box, so I am not qualified to say how it will work on most
planes. Dave Leonard is the man to ask. He is running a turbo charged 13B.
The long answer is I am now building up a TEST engine with many variables
that Tracy's unit was never designed to accommodate. My challenge to make a
reliable 300+HP biofuel driven 13B engine has become a wee bit more
involved then I had originally anticipated. By spending more time in paper
research for the past several years and seeing the results of others has
helped to eliminate at least one test engine stage.
Now the first stage engine test is a NA P-ported, Renesis rotor 10:1 beast.
Second stage it is boosted, 3rd. stage it is turbocompounded. Final stage
depends on what is deemed reliable but it will be all aluminum.
I am absolutely confident I can hit the HP target but a reasonable fuel
economy remains the biggest challenge. As such I want to have control over
exactly when and how long the fuel injectors activate. I also believe the
mass airflow sensor would be the better way to go for my C/S prop plane.
Hope this helps. Contact me if you want more details on the engine.
Regards
Doug F.
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.