Subject: Solder verses crimp
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 9/24/2007, 7:59 AM
To: AARotary Engine




    >> I am one of those who found EFI intimidating but I
    >> always thought I
    >> would deal with it when the time came. However,
    >> there is almost a
    >> continuous thread of problems faced by other
    >> builders trying to get
    >> reliable performance out of the the electronic
    >> ignition and EFI
    >> which of course I have been reading for years. I
    >> can't exaggerate
    >> the relief I felt the when I decided to go to crank
    >> fired ignition
    >> and a carb. It was a matter of accepting my own
    >> limitations. Jerry
    >>
    >>
    >> Furthermore one is expected to solder 37 tiny wires
    >> on this
    >> connector. I would say 80% of the people on here
    >> don't have the eye sight,
    >> skill and manual dexterity required to do this let
    >> alone the electronic knowledge
    >> to trouble shoot such a system.
    >>
    >>
    >> I suggested years ago a simple printed circuit board
    >> adapter and screw
    >> type connectors but the idea was rejected out of
    >> hand.
    >> --
    >> Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
    >
    >
    > NO, NO NO! Soldering is out as far as the connectors
    > for the computers goes- you will not get the
    > consistant results that you need for reliable wiring.
    > I was lucky enough to have Richard Martin show me the
    > sub-D crimp style connectors. The crimpers make
    > absolutely consistant connections with the pins, which
    > you then insert into the connector body. If you put a
    > pin in the wrong hole, you can take the removal tool,
    > remove it and then put it in the right place. I would
    > not have tried to do my wiring with the solder type
    > pins. The connectors and gold plated pins, both female
    > and male are available from one electronics store here
    > in Seattle, but I am sure they are widely available.
    > As far as the crimping tool goes, I think it costs
    > about ~$100, but I got mine at Boeing Surplus for
    > about $10, and then had to turn a die on a metal lathe
    > for the size pins I was crimping. Crimping is the only
    > way to go on the computer wiring.
    >
    > Brian Trubee
    >
    >
    > IIRC, Bob Knuckols (sp?) of the AeroElectric connections agrees
   with the
    > crimp over solder for the average guy/gal to use. He states,
   again, IIRC,
    > that they are both equivalent as to electrical connectivity,
   however, the
    > crimp is more uniformly made for the average guy. FWIW.
    >
    > Chris
    >
    >
    > Guys....
    > You only have to look at aero standards. Crimp connectors are
   used for
    > commercial aircraft and all spacecraft. The electrical
   conductivity is not
    > the issue. A soldered connector can have the solder flow up the wires
    > internal to the insulation. The wire subjected to vibration will
   break right
    > where the solder stopped flowing. That is why we should only use
   crimp
    > connectors.
    > Larry
    >
    >
   Larry,


   Exactly. The same reason we use crimp connections to all of our
   industrial
   equipment. Using the proper wire standard is also a must in vibrational
   prone applications. All copper wire of the same diameter are not created
   equally.

   Doug F.


Crimping is the accepted motorsport method but almost as important is
the type of connectors and the tool used to crimp those connectors. 10
dollar harbor frieght units just dont cut the mustard. Here is a
discussion the FSAE people (I am one of them) had about this.

http://fsae.com/eve/forums/a/tpc/f/125607348/m/53010954411/p/1
Rob Woods


The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.