Subject: Lancair nose gear.
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 9/28/2007, 8:56 AM
To: AARotary Engine



            On another subject, some of the Lancair ES's have developed
        cracks in
            their motor mounts. I may need to remove my mount and send it
        back for
            magna-fluxing and repair. There have been a number of
   severe shimmy
            incidents, one resulted in nose gear collapse. They're still
        trying to
            figure out why that's happening. I have not experienced any
        shimmy in
            six landings, but they usually begin later on, after 100 or so
            landings. Personally, I believe that the mounts are
   cracking which
            weakens the mount and allows the shimmy to occur. The
   cracks are
        on the
            cross-over tube right at the nose strut attachment. I'll be
            inspecting mine for cracks this weekend. Hopefully, I won't
   have to
            ground it for mount/strut repairs.

            Other than that, it flies great!

            Mark S.

            Sorry about messing up the margins. ;-(

             From just looking at these pictures of the MM
            it does not look like it has any positive damping in
   rotation other
            than the friction in the cylinder seals. Once the seals
   wear a bit
            the friction is probably reduced. A scissor link and a circular
            disk damper could be retrofitted. I'll do a 3D for you.

            The structural design is not great either. It needs an FEA
   done
            as there are tubes in bending and torsion. I take it you are
        using the
            stock Continental bed mount. I have never been a fan of
   that mount.
            Also some of the bays are not triangulated. CC copied it
        unfortunately.

            I take it you steer with the brakes?

            Has Tom Parke's had any nose gear problems. Tom?

            Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.





   Paul,

   I figured some sort of bending/twisting was happening to cause those
   cracks.  As for the strut, it does have an internal damping mechanism.
   Some of those have blown the o-ring which resulted in severe shimmy, or
   maybe it is the other way around (severe shimmy caused it to blow the
   o-ring).  There's a mod to those to add a second o-ring.  So far, mine
   is doing fine.  I feel that the shimmy is caused by the weakened motor
   mount.  The strut mounts in the area where the cracks are forming.

   Would you mind if I forward your analysis of the Lancair motor mount to
   the Lancair group?  They are headed down the path of adding gussets.  I
   don't feel they are addressing the real problem (as you described).

   Thanks,
   Mark

   No problem Mark. Glad to help them out. I would like to shoot the
   guy that
   designed that original mount way back when if he is still alive :)
   Unconfirmed rumor has it it was Steve Whitman.

   You may not have room for the red diagonals so here is a quick and dirty
   band aid. Cut that vertical tube out and replace it with larger
   diameter thicker
   wall as it is obviously in torsion and bending. Replace the front
   lateral tube with
   a larger one and using a 180 degree wrapped finger patch on all the
   joints in that area.

   Add the lateral tube between the front rubber bushings missing in
   the Lancair ES copy.
   Put a small diagonal in the front bay. This is an attempt to
   transfer some
   of the lateral twisting loads to the tubing ring around the bottom
   of the engine.

   The trouble with these bad motor mounts that rely on the torsional
   and bending strength
   of tubing is; you beef up one area and another area then becomes a
   problem.
   Sooner or later they all become a problem with cracks developing. I
   cringe every
   time I see one. Impossible to analyze without FEA. Piston engines
   are worse than
   rotaries  as they vibrate more and stronger.

   If somebody wants to do an FEA I can supply them with a dwg in Rhino
   that can
   be imported into Solid Works.
   --
   Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.



While there's certainly no excuse for crummy design, I'd say that it's
definitely preferable to damage the motor mount than to damage the
firewall (if you have a choice).  The Cessna 182 nose gear design, which
is totally different, but equally lame (mounts the nose gear directly to
the center of the firewall - total after though) is almost guaranteed to
damage the firewall if crunched a bit too hard.  Tubing is easier to fix
than sheet metal (or structural composite in the case of the Lancair)
Right next to the bad mixture distribution on the Cont O-470, the nose
gear design is my least favorite aspect of the airplane.

I guess what I am saying is, don't make the motor mount/nose gear
assembly _too_ strong..


Regards,

Matt-


Good point Matt.

That is why I do not let my wife land the C182 even though she is a student pilot. :)

Actually somebody "landed" a Bonanza at SZP and broke the Continental aluminum castings
that attach the engine to the rubber bushings. The aluminum box under the engine was OK.
Of course they also buckled the wing spar :)  My point is (if I have one) is a lot of
the nose landing gear load on the Lancair ES goes directly into the mass of the engine
as it should. One of the few positive aspects to the design. In the Questair Venture ALL
of the nose landing gear load goes directly into the engine. It is all a question of load
paths. Keep them as short as possible.
-- 
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2006 All world wide rights reserved.