Subject: John Andrich's turbo Long EZ cooling
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 10/24/2007, 6:36 AM
To: AARotary Engine



        John and his partner have been working on this for a long time.
        Something like
        20 years. Just recently did they get it flying. The first thing
   that
        happened was they lost an apex seal. Probably due to detonation.
        They over hauled the engine and then the turbo let go. Nothing
   new here
        as that is probably about the 8th 2nd gen turbo to let go. The
   turbo
        caught fire when it failed. Fortunately not a lot of damage and
   John
        was able
        to glide to a safe landing back at Camarillo. The turbo is being
        modified
        to Dave Leonards spec. Hopefully we will get a report after his
   5000
        to 6000
        mile trip.

        I was unaware they were flying. The last time I saw the
   airplane was
        about five or six years
        ago. If I had known about it I could have warned them about the
        detonation
        and the 2nd gen turbo. You MUST monitor the intake charge air
        temperature and keep
        it below 140 F or you WILL get detonation sooner rather than later.
        We have known about and discussed  the 2nd gen turbo problems
   for at
        least two years
        and maybe three.

        The PSRU is a home made belt unit built according to Blanton's
        plans. The ratio
        is 2:1 so they need a lot of boost to get the HP. They had the
   large
        pulley custom
        made by a broach shop in LA.

        They are running 50 inches Hg MAP for take off and 45 inches of
        HG  MAP for climb
        out.  Max rpm for climb out is 4500.  Static engine RPM is 5100
   RPM.
        The turbo is working hard.  Cruise is 4000 RPM with 42 inches
   of Hg.
        TAS is 160 MPH. Fuel burn on take off and climb out is about
   7.5 gallons
        an hour extrapolated from the last short trip when the turbo failed
        so they are not making very much power despite the high manifold
        pressure. The manifold itself is stock without the mass air flow
        sensor. Just the stock TB. You can get away with that if you
   use a belt
        drive as the engine sits lower. They are using Tracy's EFI unit
   instead
        of the stock computer.

        During prior cruise flights they were burning 4.6 to 5.0
   gallons and
        hour.
        More about the cooling system shortly.

        Did I get all this right John?

        Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.



   Courageous, but it seems that people insist on working too hard on
   things that they don't need to and skip taking care of some important
   stuff.  Buy the PSRU.  Build (or buy) a P-Port.  _Everyone's_ time is
   worth something.

   I think all new installs need to run on a test stand at high power
   settings - takeoff power - for at least 50 hours .  If not a test stand,
   on the chained down airplane with fan cooling.  People make too many
   rosey assumptions about how much better things will go once there's
   slipstream cooling air through the system.  I'd make exceptions to this
   if an install is a _direct_ copy of another which already works
   reliably.  In that case, only spend 25 hours on the stand.  There are no
   direct copies!!  Hah.  :)  Lots of useful stuff will be learned in the
   process of making it run well on the ground.  It's a tough pill to
   swallow because lots of builders really want to be fliers instead.

   I don't think they're undergeared so much as overpropped.  It's not all
   that unusual for a LongEz to cruise with the prop at 3000RPM.  They
   aren't supposed to have props with diameter greater than 62" (though
   some aircraft do), so I think 3000RPM is no big deal, and that would
   allow a 6000RPM engine speed.  They need less pitch, less diameter,
   and/or a better prop airfoil.  Do these guys have any other EZ
   experience?  Oh wait, are they running an IVO or Warp drive - I think I
   can see it in one of the pics.  How fast are they allowed to turn?  And
   at what RPM does that blade get really inefficient?


   Matt-

   I think you are being a bit hard on them Matt. A lot of these decisions
   were made over ten years ago. Probably before one could buy a PSRU
   off the
   shelf. These guys are true rotary engine pioneers along with Yvon
   Cournoyer
   and Ken Welter with a similar belt drive PSRU's. We have come a long
   way since
   1997. Turbo chargers have advantages at high altitude (12K to 14K)
   cruise.

   Here is the cooling stuff. The original configuration was a real thick
   (5 or 6 inches) custom rad core in the nose. I did not think it
   would work when
   I first saw it and of course it did not work. They adopted the super
   simple, super
   quick under the fuse mounted  heat exchanger with Kays & London wedge
   shaped diffuser. Works like a charm. Super slick cowl. So far water temp
   is 205 F take off and 185 F cruise.

   Oil cooling in the nose is two Earl's supply oil coolers back to
   back in the
   cross counter flow configuration. In other words the back cooler
   gets the
   hot oil first. Oil temp is 205 F on take off and climb out and 192 F
   in cruise.
   --
   Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.


Yeah Paul,  you're right..  I was at work when I wrote that.  I still
think they are over-propped..


Matt-

They could be. We will see when they get the new turbo charger.
One bit of evidence against that is the 5100 static RPM.

Perry Mick, what is your static RPM again? I think the Andrich turbo Long EZ MPG
might work out to be exceptional. It is showing some signs of that already.
John and I discussed the reasons for the new 16B. I think we both agree Mazda
made it larger with more torque so they could raise the RX8 axle ratio and
cut the 80 MPH cruise RPM to reduce engine friction. What would be ideal of
course is a constant speed prop.

-- 
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2007 All world wide rights reserved.