Since almost nobody voted I will choose the winners.
We had 13 submissions in the first go around.
Question:
------------------------------------------------
Every few months or a year the subject of the exact rotary engine
displacement comes up yet again. Here are a few indisputable facts.
Anybody near a rotary engine that is running can verify
these facts.
1. The one rotor rotary engines fires once per revolution
of the E-shaft. Easy to check. Stick your finger in the spark
plug lead :)
2. The displacement volume of one chamber of the Mazda rotary is
40 cubic inches. One can verify this by filling the combustion
chamber with a measured amount of oil through the spark plug holes
when the rotor is at bottom dead center.
3. The rotor rotates at one third of the e-shaft RPM.
Just look at the rotor phasing gears.
How then is one 40 cubic inch rotor chamber full of fuel
and air able to fire once per revolution of the eccentric
shaft?
There will be a prize for the first correct answer.
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
End of question.
---------------------------------------------------------------------
- ---------------
Dave Arbogast won that easy one with:
"Because there are 3 rotor faces - thus 3 chambers to go through
the "4 cycles" of ICE,
and the phasing gears make each of 3 chambers complete their
cycles once per
revolution of the e-shaft.
-dave Arbogast"
Second question:
---------------------------------------------------------------------
- -------------
The displacement of all internal combustion engines are calculated on
the amount of volume each cylinder displaces times the number
of cylinders.
Since the rotary has three 40 cubic inch chambers in the one
rotor engine
is the displacement 120 cubic inches?
If not what then is the real equivalent displacement of the Mazda
rotary engine and why?
The key is to study the operation of the two cylinder four stroke
piston engine.
This is the closest analogy to a one rotor Wankel.
Hint: Note that in one revolution of the 2 cylinder 4 stroke
piston engine only one of
the two cylinders fires. In the next revolution the other
cylinder fires and so on.
BTW This is and the high RPM of the Wankel make piston engine
ignition coils
unsuitable for the rotary.
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
--------------------------------------------------------------------
Since I got only a few votes I'll decide the winner based
partially tersness
and clarity. We also got about 13 responses. The winner is: Tom Lee.
"If we're simply looking for the piston displacement equivalent,
the rotary
has a pumping displacement of 40 CI per rotor (35 CI for the 12A/
70 mm housings)
where as a 4 stroke piston motor has only 1/2 the pumping
displacement they are
rated at. Wankel got it right, Otto was wrong...or vis vera if
you're the sentimental type.
Tom Lee "
---------------------------------------------------------------------
- ----------
Second place winner is Mark Steitle:
"Paul,
From past discussion, I believe it was agreed that displacement
of the 4-stroke
engine is determined by 720* of crankshaft rotation. As we know,
the rotary
requires 3 complete rotations (1080*) of the eccentric before it
starts over.
However, you only count two of the three chambers to find
"equivalent displacement"
because that is how many chambers will fire in 720* of eccentric
shaft rotation.
Therefore, the "equivalent displacement" for a one-rotor would by
40 x 2 = 80 cu in.,
or 40 x 2 x 2 = 160 cu in for a 2-rotor 13B.
It is my opinion that true total displacement should take into
account the firing
of all faces without repeating any, or 1080* eccentric rotation.
But that wasn't the question.
Mark Steitle."
---------------------------------------------------------------------
- --
Third place winner is Doug Fir:
"Ok ....having stuck my finger in the rotary engine coil wire I
notice that
every time the I heard a 'chug' and air escaped from the leading
plug hole
I got a little excited. Doing the same thing with the 2 cylinder
piston
engine I had to turn the engine over two revolutions before the
whoopee.
Therefore if we want to have a comparative displacement number,
comparing
apple and oranges so to speak, we have to measure the rotary at
twice the
number of combustion events. The one rotor, or one half 13B,
will have a
displacement of 655.48cc X 2 or 1.31096 liters of milk.
Doug in Japan."
---------------------------------------------------------------------
-
These people sent more stuff after the contest was over. Tom Lee had
already won.
--------------------------------------------------------------------
"So where's the list and where do we vote? Although I still
prefer the pumping
comparison over all others, I can't take credit for it. It's
something I
was told so long ago I forgot who told me. Still, all internal
combustion engines are air pumps. Any student is taught this
early on. Wankel did in fact use this logic to convert a
rotary air pump into an engine, although he went through
thousands of various designs to find what he thought was acceptable.
Tom Lee"
-------------------------------------------------------------------
"A cycle is when the piston goes through intake, compression,
ignition and
exhaust. Each rotor has three faces to go through the same
process. Karibian"
---------------------------------------------------------------------
-
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
Let's be fair here. I voted three times. And the rules didn't say I
couldn't vote for myself. And that I couldn't vote Daly.
Big Al from Chicago
BTW. Did you hear about the Chicago area gang leader who recently
had his legs machine-gunned off by one of his rivals? As the guy
was lying in a pool of his own blood, the other gangster went up to
him and said, "This is something you've knee-ded for a long time."
John Dinkel
This jpg is why we keep him around :)
Paul Lamar
Paul,
Just when I think my credibility is at an all-time low you mess
things up by sending around the cover of the RX-7 book. The author
signed yesterday only. On Tuesday he will be co-signing. And, yes,
I DO believe in making waves.
John Dinkel
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2007 All world wide rights reserved.