Subject: One rotor Rotamax at Copper State - some information of charge cooling
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 11/24/2007, 3:19 PM
To: AARotary Engine



       I agree with you, Paul, that air-cooling is not "free" as it
   does take
       horsepower to drive the required air pump.  Nevertheless, what
   if we
       took another look at cooling the Wankel engine with air directly?

       Porsche has had some experience with air-cooled engines in
   automobiles.
       In fact, the 5-liter 917 flat-12 engine was air-cooled (a
   photograph of
       which can be found here:
       http://www.pelicanparts.com/vasekauction/917-3/med/DSC02088.JPG).

       Paul Frere, in his article on the Porsche 917 in "Cars in Profile,
       Collection 1" (Profile Publications Limited, 1973, Doubleday &
   Company,
       1974), noted:

       "Another shaft drives  . . . the cooling blower running at 0.895
   engine
       speed . . . (p. 98)

       (A photo of the blower can be found here:
       http://www.pelicanparts.com/vasekauction/917-2/med/DSC01966.JPG)

       "(in 1969) . . . the engine had been developed to give some 580
   hp, and
       those who think an air-cooled racing engine loses too much power in
       driving its cooling blower will be interested to know that this
   absorbed
       only 17 bhp at peak revs (/and at 236 mph - LN/). . . .  This is,
of
       course, much less than the power required to drive a large water
       radiator
       through the atmosphere at over 200 mph. (p. 104)"

       On the basis of Porsche's automotive experience, could not an
       aircraft-based Wankel engine be cooled more efficiently with air
   than
       with a water-to-air radiator?  Especially if the air cooling
   system uses
       heat pipes?

       Les Nordman :-)

       Page 104 of which book?

       Porsche built a fan cooled aircraft engine for the Mooney and it
       burned more fuel
       than a Lycoming. You still have to get the cooling air into the
       cowling and out so the
       drag due to that is not zero.

       http://www.mooneyland.com/Mooney%20Models.htm
       < http://www.mooneyland.com/Mooney%20Models.htm>

       Robinson derates the Lycomings because of the cooling fans.

       It is near impossible to air cool a two rotor without separating
the
       rotor housings with more distance. That adds to the stress on the
       e-shaft
       and to the weight of the engine.

       I am not saying it is impossible. Just not practical.

       Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.


   I thought Robinson derates the chopper engines to promote
   longevity/reliability...


   Regards,

   Matt-

   They cannot deliver the rated HP to the gear box because they need
   to drive the fans. Some rogue engineer is likely to run the numbers
   and find the missing 10 HP in the climb rate :)
   --
   Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.


I apologize for being argumentative..  But, the Lycoming is derated 49hp
- from 180hp to 131hp.  49hp seems kinda high just to run a cooling
fan.  Plus, they don't allow the engine to turn the RPM required to make
180hp.  I'd guess what you're saying is partly true, but it doesn't
address all of the effect.

http://www.robinsonheli.com/r22specs.htm

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lycoming_O-360


Matt-

Wow! 131 HP. I stand corrected. I was going from memory thinking it was 150
HP.
Either the fan is sucking down more power than I thought and/or they chose
gearing that limited max RPM to 2652. RPM alone would be 2652/2700 X 180
or 176 HP.

If it was a engine life factor that does not say much for a Lycoming.

The claimed fuel burn at 8 to 10 gallons an hour means they are not
generating
that much power in cruise. 8 gallons at BSFC of .45 is 106 HP. Not much.
10 gallons is 133 HP is no allowance for blower HP. The blower
HP must be coming from some place. That is a huge blower they have in there.

If for some strange reason it was as low as .4 BSFC the numbers would be 120
HP and
150 HP. I am sure you won't see .4 BSFC without leaning and I don't think
Lycoming allows leaning. Perhaps the real number is somewhere in between.
Something in here is not adding up.

Frank Robinson should look at a Mistral engine with aluminum end plates.
http://www.mistral-engines.com/  A 300 HP three rotor with aluminum end
plates
should be about the same weight as a 180 HP O-360. About 285 pounds.
-- 
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.


Paul,

I'm pretty sure Robinson derates the Lycomings the way they do is because
the allowable rotor speed is a very narrow range.  You can't run those
engines at high rpm all the time and expect them to make TBO.  The allowable
rpm range of the rotors is around 10% --a Huey's main rotor RPM is around
300 to 325.  This is why turbines work so well in helicopters; turbines are
always running at high rpm.  At idle, they are running about 85% rpm; they
normally operate between 95 and 100% rpm.  With recips, you either run the
engines at high rpm and burn them up, as they do in Enstroms or put a big
one in at a reduced rating as they do with the Robinsons.

I think a rotary is the only recip type that can run at 5500 to 6000 rpm
continuously at between 75% and 100% manifold pressure.  This is why I'm
looking into it.  The hardest thing for me is packaging in an existing
platform.

Steve Brazil



The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2007 All world wide rights reserved.