Subject: Needle valve slide carbs. Was P-port
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 11/26/2007, 5:36 PM
To: AARotary Engine


    >>> I don't know why I did not think of this a couple of years ago.
    >>> I just was not thinking fixed needle movable fuel jet.
    >>> This is by a factor of ten simpler and easier to build than
   anything I
    >>> have come up with
    >>> so far. It uses a low pressure pump and a low pressure pressure
    >>> regulator.
    >>> Your done!!!! Assuming you have a slide throttle. Adjust the
   regulator
    >>> to
    >>> lean.
    >>> Turn the pump on after the engine is turning over to start.
    >>> To prime turn the pump on for a second or two and then off.
    >>>
    >>> Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
    >>
    >> Paul,
    >> This seems to be a fixed needle, (with integral needle and jet) x 2.
    >>
    >> Wouldn't the fuel therefore need to be fed to the other, thicker
   end of
    >> the
    >> needle.The biggest draw-back of a fixed needle is getting the
   fuel to the
    >> jet, as the jet would be in most cases moving with the slide.
    >>
    >> You have designed around this problem but I do see a couple of
   things to
    >> consider, like the thickness of the needle- rod , but that is just a
    >> relative thing ( i.e. fuel flow to air flow). I would personally
   go for
    >> the
    >> flat ground needle to maintain more width thickness of the needle,
    >> therefore
    >> keeping the needle diameter down to the smallest size.
    >>
    >> One of the claimed draw-backs of the round ground needle is that
   it tends
    >> to
    >> rub against the jet wall in one area and causes uneven wear of
   the jet,
    >> that
    >> leads to an uneven flow distribution. However where it's one
   piece like
    >> this, there isn't that sort of problem.
    >>
    >> I may be wrong but I thought that round ground needles needed the
    >> increased
    >> signal of a venturi to better draw the fuel. That's why I like
   the flat
    >> ground needle as it creates it's own low pressure area behind
   the needle,
    >> which draws the fuel up through the jet. Then again you
   mentioned the low
    >> pressure pump and Regulator to initiate and maintain correct
   fuel flow. I
    >> will use the same system but just enough pressure to get the fuel to
    >> within
    >> striking distance, to respond to the low pressure area created
   by the
    >> flat
    >> ground needle.
    >>
    >> If I am seen to be pushing the flat ground needle, it's just
   because I
    >> would
    >> like both yourself and Doug to fully understand the benefits,
   before you
    >> eliminated it as a contended for a design.
    >>
    >> One other thing to consider is fuel cut-off, but I suppose you
   will just
    >> cut-off the fuel pump?
    >>
    >> George (down under)
    >>
    >>
    >> Here is the needle design and a chart showing fuel jet port area
   as a
    >> function
    >> of the smaller diameter of the needle. The OD of the needle is
   .2 inches.
    >>
    >> Looks like the small diameter should be about .16" for a fuel flow
    >> of 22 gallons an hour high power at 2 psi fuel pressure.
    >>
    >> This is going to be one super cheap FI system using only off the
   shelf
    >> low
    >> pressure fuel pumps and  an adjustable low pressure regulator.
    >>
    >> Dave, hang on to my RX8 p-port engine. I am making one of these
   and we
    >> will be trying it again on the dyno soon. Stand off mist should
    >> not be a problem as the fuel is injected down near the engine
    >> 16 inches away from the runner bell mouths and about 3 inches
    >> in from the p-port itself. In other words inside the sealed slide
    >> throttle.
    >> --
    >> Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
    >
    > Paul,
    > Most adjustable low pressure fuel regulators go to 6 psi, so if your
    > set-up
    > shows your running too lean you can adjust your regulator. I see the
    > regulator as the course adjustment and would suggest a fine
   adjustment of
    > the needle, simply by having a thread and nut to adjust the
   needle up and
    > down (back and forth).
    >
    > Of course most needles aren't just one linear line form fully open to
    > fully
    > closed, they are stepped and change from idle to cruise to wot.
   Exactly
    > where and by how much is a matter for experimentation. This is
   where an O2
    > sensor comes in handy, as it will identify where the needle is
   too thick
    > or
    > too thin.
    > George ( down under)
    >
    > That is a REAL good idea George. Really easy to implement on this
   design
    > as the needle sticks out the front end of the slide. Thanks for
   thinking
    > of
    > that. It could be motorized even with a big gear and a small
   pinion turned
    > by a DC motor.
    >
    > I don't think you need the stepped needle because in an aircraft
   engine
    > you adjust the leaning at steady RPM cruise. You take off at WOT.
   It is
    > not
    > like a car or a motor cycle where the RPM and load vary over a
   wide range.
    > All you need is to keep the engine running and the rotary will
   run from
    > about
    > 10:1 to 18:1 mixture.
    >
    > --
    > Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

   Paul,
   You may well be right about the needle taper, I hope you are, it
   would sure
   make things easier.

   On the threaded adjustment of the needle, this could be manually
   done, as it
   is currently done - from the cockpit / turn knob, for rich and lean,
   with
   the cable going from cockpit ( knob) to the needle/jet threaded rod.

   This is how I plan my rich/ lean adjustment also.

   The next thing I would reconsider is moving away from the electric
   pump and
   going back to the manual pump you designed a little while back OR
   have both
   for redundancy. Certainly use the electric pump for testing.

   The carb discussion has been very stimulating, I wish Doug had
   tossed in his
   2 cents worth. It's always interesting to see others opinions and if
   I have
   contributed in any way - it's my pleaser to do so. Acceptance of an idea
   reinforces that I am heading in the right direction also.

   George (down under)


I kind of like the idea of an engine driven primary pump.  I haven't
been keeping up with the details of this injection/carb system (I
apologize), but an engine driven pump might make flow regulation
easier.  As the engine slows down the pump can supply lower
pressure/volume.  Then you just need to regulate fuel flow based on
manifold pressure (or mass flow).

Use the electric pump to prime and as a backup.


Regards,

Matt-


The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2007 All world wide rights reserved.