Subject: Needle valve slide carbs. Was P-port
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 11/27/2007, 6:04 AM
To: AARotary Engine


Here is the needle design and a chart showing fuel jet port area as a
function
of the smaller diameter of the needle. The OD of the needle is .2 inches.

Looks like the small diameter should be about .16" for a fuel flow
of 22 gallons an hour high power at 2 psi fuel pressure.

This is going to be one super cheap FI system using only off the shelf
low
pressure fuel pumps and  an adjustable low pressure regulator.

Dave, hang on to my RX8 p-port engine. I am making one of these and we
will be trying it again on the dyno soon. Stand off mist should
not be a problem as the fuel is injected down near the engine
16 inches away from the runner bell mouths and about 3 inches
in from the p-port itself. In other words inside the sealed slide
throttle.
-- 
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

Paul,
If your referring to the graph in the previous e-mail ( 2 psi) and your
estimating approx ( I use my own figures) 10.5 gph x 6 lbs per gallon = 63
lb/hr ( per rotor) would indicate .063 "( dia). In my flat needle .0625" (
1/16") is half of my ground needle of 1/8 "( .125").

Most of the needles I've seen are no more than 1/8" before taper and I
have
copied that. Being one piece your needle my be thicker. In this
application,
I would reconsider the hollow needle with the small holes at the back like
the Ellison. The low pressure are behind the needle is the same principle
as
in the flat needle.
George (down under)


Opss you are right! I need more like 100 pounds per hour or 16.7 gallons
an hour
per rotor. Looks like the small diameter will be .1 inch or less. I was
mistakenly
reading the chart as gallons per hour. Of course I can always jack up the
pressure
a bit to squirt more fuel with  small diameter of .1 inch.

There is no reason a .2 inch needle instead of .125 inch diameter cannot
be used.
What counts is the opening AREA of the jet. The small diameter is what
counts.

I need the larger diameter for structural reasons as the needles are
connected end to end.

I am figuring full rich 12.5:1  WOT.

Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

Paul,
I never really used the graph until today myself (even though I've seen it
many times before), it is a good guide and reinforces my previous
estimations, so I have copied it and placed it in my carb folder.

Would you be using 16.7 gallons per hour( per rotor) at WOT ?

I agree, there is no reason that a thicker needle isn't appropriate
considering the design. I am just throwing around ideas and a thicker needle
would accommodate fuel flow through the center of the needle like the
Ellison - just an idea!

I also agree that the fuel pressure can be adjusted to accommodate slight
design imperfections - be flexible, that's my motto!

Tell me Paul, is that why Ellison calls their carb a fuel injector carb,
perhaps we can call our designs (although a little different) low pressure
fuel injection.
George (down under)


Easy. The engine will gulp fuel at full or over rich.
Here is a chart showing GPH on the dyno with a Weber carb that is not
necessarily tuned properly for a tuned manifold.
Amazingly the rotary engine still runs sucking down
over 30 gallons an hour. Surprisingly it is still not pumping out
black smoke out the exhaust pipe. When you see a diesel truck
pumping out black smoke the engine is running super rich.

This is no different than an air cooled aircraft engine that
uses a rich mixture to keep the cylinder heads cool.
A stock 200 HP Piper Turbo Arrow is adjusted to  suck down .65 BSFC or
22 gallons per hour during take off and climb out.

Our carbs (I call mine the Long Needle) are almost identical to a
Posa carb which are widely used on VW aircraft engines.
The Posa uses gravity feed instead of a fuel pump and
pressure regulator we are using.

Posa description plagiarized off the net:
http://webhome.idirect.com/~omacphe/posa.htm
"It is a simple fuel/air metering unit consisting of an orifice/needle
combination for fuel regulation and a slide (which carries the needle)
for air metering. In it's most common form there is no float bowl,
fuel is simply supplied directly to the orifice.

I was amazed at the amount of bad press surrounding the "POSA".
This led to serious consideration of replacing it before the engine
had even been run. I decided to try it anyway but had low expectations
of success. I was so skeptical in fact I remember being shocked by
how well the engine started and ran the first time I tried it. With
this early success I decided to press on with the
Revflow carb and intake system unchanged."

"Without a float bowl, the POSA is sensitive to fuel pressure variations.
It was designed to be used in gravity flow systems. Gravity flow systems depend
on head pressure to flow fuel. Head is the distance between the level of fuel
in the tank and the carburettor fuel fitting. The larger this distance the
greater the pressure (and consequently flow) to the carb. High wing aircraft
with wing mounted fuel tanks are especially well suited to this system with
heads in the 2 - 3 foot range. Low wing aircraft present more of a challenge
to gravity flow fuel systems simply because we typically have less head available."
End of quote.

Consequently this is a good web site to help you tune our type of simple carb.

The Ellison is a lot like the Posa. The problem with the Ellison is cost.
It cost a whole bunch of money to laser drill a bunch of holes in those hollow
needles. I got a couple of quotes. Several hundred dollars for just the holes.
The Ellison is like the Posa  except it has a built in low pressure pressure regulator

Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

Paul,
Pity about the manufacturing costs, Ellison must do it in-house.
I looked at those needle dimensions ( Revmaster) and mine is pretty similar,
however I allow for some adjustment up and down  and the last 5mm ranges
from .066" to .061" so it may still be a little thick, as the Revmaster lean
one is .055" - I may have to grind a little more or 'up the pressure'.
George ( down under)


Up the pressure is a good thing.

Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2007 All world wide rights reserved.