"The problem is the slide has a throw of about 2", and adjustment of
needle
valves in the range of liquid flows we are interested in, happens in less
than a 1/16" linear travel, hence the need for several revolutions of the
knob to fine adjust them."
You are talking about a very short needle here. Apples and oranges. A long
needle
works in a carb BECAUSE it is long. Two inch long needles are ad-van-tages
and
not a drawback. The longer the better. Here is a needle curve out of a
Posa
carburetor. The diameter of the needle can be adjusted along its length.
There are half a dozen brands of long needle carbs that work fine.
Unfortunately PWM is NOT working too well in aircraft. Besides the
extra expense, users have trouble installing, tuning and maintaining the
PWM EFI system. Most people are not electronic technicians let alone EE's.
It is
way overkill for the average aircraft engine. Manually tuned aircraft
carbs also have years of proven research and use behind them too :)
We need something Joe Sixpack can understand and fix :) Present
company excepted :)
What works in a piston engine may not work in a p-port rotary. See my
last message.
Paul Lamar
Doug,
My primary goal is KISS, to achieve that the most simple yet safe system
possible- avoiding electronics wherever possible, that's why I suggested the
manual pump to Paul. However different people are comfortable with different
degrees of complexity and although electronics are great, my personal
concern is that when they fail, everything dependant upon them, fails as
well.
Why I am attempting my own carb is because I'm not comfortable with tuning a
complex and costly carb - mind you I haven't yet found one to suite my
application. The more simple ones ( like Aerocarb) are usually too small, as
this is their (demand driven) market.
As for the needle, I have opted to have 10mm of adjustment, which is massive
travel for a carb needle, I figure than I will have 5mm each way, this still
leaves about 3mm in the jet after full lean travel . It may take a few turns
of the leaning knob, and it may be a bit more than it is now in carbed
aircraft. I have opted to use Metric fine thread, where coarse would be
better suited, but at this stage I just am not sure, so I stick to fine
(1.25 pitch).
I know that our designs are different ( Paul's and mine) but I believe our
goals are essentially the same, it could be your design is totally different
again. I look forward to see it!
I have included a lot of info with my responses to, and discussions with
Paul, knowing he may not fully agree on certain points, but my hope was that
these points would serve as 'Grist for the Mill' for your development as
well.
George ( down under)
George,
Far be for me to discourage a researcher. Almost all of us who build our
own airplanes are doing some R&D on some part or other trying to 'improve'
it with the expense being our time. I agree that a P-port engine requires
a throttle up close and personal to the engine and a slide throttle offers
the least resistance at WOT. I admire the KISS principle as well. Sometimes
'keeping it simple' is simply using systems that have a proven reliability
factor. Combining a carb into the slide throttle is not KISS. On paper the
concept seems simple but getting it to work, like turbo-compounding mind
you, will takes hours of tweaking. AeroCarb and Ellison invested those
hours of research into their products. This is not to say don't try. Like
you said there is nothing available for you in your hp range.
The thread you mentioned on the needle adjustment sounds like one used on a
metric bolt. You might try a thread design like they use on lathe, and mill
table drives, to prevent jamming. Sorry the name of the thread escapes me
at the moment.
I am going with EFI because in my mind that is safer. It may not be
simpler, granted, but given the amount of development time and run time the
system has experienced, the data is there to prove the reliability and the
backup systems are known. I disagree with Paul about Joe Six Pack not being
able to program Tracy's computer or even Megasquirt. There are many
homebuilt airplanes flying that are made by people who hardly picked up a
tool in their life. Its called the 'learning process'. And when they get
stuck they ask a friend for assistance. Need I plug EAA here:)
My slide throttle plate is also metal perhaps chrome mild steel or electro
polished SUS 304 with top and bottom sides profiled cut to match the profile
groove cut in the Teflon spacer. I made it singular to eliminate any
possibility of air cross feed between the ports and to allow it to be
mounted horizontal or vertically. Like yours all part faces are to be
machined to assure absolute flatness and repeatability. It is not cheap and
the first design will need to be tweaked no doubt. When I am absolutely
satisfied with the performance I'll post the designs and pictures.
Doug Fir.
Acme thread.
Doug get back to me on this when you get EFI working :)
EFI adds well over a thousand dollars to a rotary's price.
Some people have quit the rotary engine rather than deal with the EFI
problems. I suspect they would rather keep the aircraft carb and magnetos
and change just the basic engine. Changing just one thing at a time is
the best scientific approach anyway.
Some guys pay less than a $1000 for the Mazda engine. Right now the acceptance
of the rotary is primarily based on cost. I guess it will be at least
another 15 years before it is bought because it is better. Nine years
ago when I started this news letter I naively thought it would
take only five years to gain acceptance because it was better.
We now have to focus on the reason people buy the engine in the
first place and that is low cost.
Rotamax may go a long way to putting the rotary on the map
if they are successful. Much of the current interest in the Rotamax
is due to the high price and unavailability of the Rotax 912 and 914.
I think that is happening because the military around the world
are buying Rotax engines for UAV's. The appreciation of the Euro
is also a factor in the Rotax engine price.
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2007 All world wide rights reserved.