> Paul
>
> Have you seen this?
>
> http://www.wipo.int/pctdb/en/wo.jsp?wo=2004074655
>
> Erik Wahlstrom
>
> Very interesting but so far I don't understand exactly what it is they
> are trying to do and I am not a lawyer let alone a patent lawyer :) Combining a
> Wankel rotary with a turbine is a good idea no matter how they go about it.
>
> However there must be something beyond that I don't understand or they
> would never get a patent.
>
> The dwg's are not too clear. Too bad they don't allow 3D's in patents.
>
> Paul Lamar
This is astonishing! It is obviously an attempt to patent the
conceptual framework of a turbo-compound engine. Their "gas turbine" is
a turbocharger and the wording about the "fixed pressure ratio" element
is so cleverly ambiguous that it could be any Otto cycle engine. This
reminds me of the "Look and Feel" patents that Apple once heaped claims
upon.
I could go on forever about this topic. But, I'll just comment that it
is sad, for me, to see American giants of engineering innovation like
Pratt & Whitney resorting to this sort of activity to generate revenue.
Aubrey Thompson
It looks like the patent office will give a patent to anybody
for anything and let it be fought out in the courts making the
lawyers rich. This one should be pretty easy to shoot down.
Paul Lamar
Well, this is just a patent application. I haven't read it in
detail, but if you look at the preliminary report on patentability, it
doesn't look very positive.
Bob W.