Tom,
Size, weight and location are advantageous perhaps, but
as for
efficiency I
am not so sure. When the water temperature is below 85
degrees, OK
sure.
Marine applications are like this but they dump the BTU
overboard
along with
the cooling water. In aviation more than likely on T.O,
when
cooling loads
and engine stress are greatest, the water temp. is going to
be over
185F.
With oil temps. at 200F + degrees, the delta T to water will
only be 15
degrees, 200 minus 185 degrees. If we use an oil-to-air
heat
exchanger, the
delta T with an 85 degree ambient air temperature would
be 200F
minus 85F or
115F degrees.
Heat moves towards the lower potential, so a higher
difference in
temperature (higher delta T) would result in a higher rate
of heat
transfer
and be more efficient. Of course this entails designing
proper
intake and
exhaust ducts (Paul's forte') that insures all of those
fins on the
oil-to-air heat exchanger are free of insulating air
boundary
layers, and
whole air mass moves through the duct in a timely and
orderly
fashion.
The same criteria applies to the water to air heat
exchanger.
As for why Ford trucks would offer the
oil-to-water-to-air heat
exchanger
in a towing application where the engine is under a
heavy duty
cycle I
haven't a clue. Perhaps someone could explain it to me.
Keeping
the engine
oil warm in the cold north? :)
Doug in Japan
One factor is the small amount of heat transfered to the oil
in most
piston engines. Some piston engine squirt oil
at the under side of the piston to cool them. Many aircraft
piston
engines do this as do some diesels. Never the less the heat
dissipated
by the oil is usually less than 10% of the total.
The rotary on the other hand has this oil cooled rotor that
forms
about half
of the area of the combustion chamber. This results in
one third
of the total heat rejection to the cooling system. As you
can see,
from this
heat balance chart, 50 HP or 25% of the HP out of the
e-shaft during
lean cruise is rejected
by the oil heat alone. At rich mixtures, typical during take
off and
climb out, the
percentage becomes greater. If the oil is cooler than the
glycol coolant it is not a good idea to transfer heat to
the oil
from the glycol.
One needs to delay heating the oil as long as possible with
a good
oil to air
heat exchanger and proper air ducting. More oil helps this
process
as it takes more heat to
heat a larger quantity of oil. The difficult history of the
Mazda
rotary installation
in aircraft has been mostly about keeping it cool both
oil and
glycol.
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
Doug,
I'm running an oil-to-water exchanger on my 3-rotor. I think
one of the
keys to whether or not this works is where you tap the water to
feed the
exchanger. I drilled & tapped a 1/2" NPT on the high pressure
side of
the water pump housing, just prior to where the coolant
enters the
engine. Then I returned the heated water to the engine out
(radiator
inlet). By doing it this way the water temp feeding the
oil-to-water
exchanger is much lower which increases the delta T across the
exchanger. It also increases the delta-t across the
radiator by
dumping more btu's into the system.
Paul stated that the "difficult history of the Mazda rotary
installation
in aircraft has been mostly about keeping it cool both oil and
glycol."
The beauty of using the oil to water exchanger is that it tends
to keep
the oil and water within about 10* of each other. Before
adding the
oil-to-water exchanger, my oil temps would run much higher
than the
water temps.
BTW Paul, I flew today and checked the CHT's. In an economy
cruise they
were around 180-185*F. The one nearest the water pump was the
coolest,
the one nearest the flywheel was the hottest, as you would
expect. One
of these days I'll think to check the CHT's during climb.
Mark S.
27.1 hrs
What was the outside air temp? How fast and long did you
climb out?
What was the climb rate FPM? What was the oil and glycol
temperature
just before you took off?
It's still winter in Austin TX. A one degree increase in ambient
temperature
is a one percent reduction in cooling capacity. Let me know
when you
fly in
100 F ambient air temperatures :) I am not saying it won't
work but
there is
X amount of heat to be dissipated. If you put it all in the
glycol
system
the glycol system MUST be 1/3rd larger than it would need
to be if
it were
just doing glycol. There is no free lunch. It is just common
sense.
Take some data and don't forget to record the ambient
temperature
and the
climb speed. Many people quote temps but they neglect to
measure or
mention
the out side air temperature and the climb speed.
A marginal cooling system will work if you climb out at 200
FPM at
130 to 150 MPH to 500 foot altitude. Texas is fairly flat in
your area.
Record temp out of the pump, out of the block, in the rad,
OUT of
the rad,
in the oil water HX, out of the oil water heat HX, climb speed,
climb duration
and last but not least the all important out side air
temperature.
This should give everybody a clue on just how complicated this
system is.
That is why I wrote a book on the subject.
The situation with an air cooled engine is not as bad as the
rate of heat transfer from cylinder fins to air is greater and
as the
fins heat up beyond 400 or 500 F the rate of heat transfer also
increase.
With a water cooled system there is a real limit of how hot the
glycol
can become before catastrophic boil over. The air/oil cooler
is not
as bad
as the boiling temp of oil is much much higher than that that of
glycol.
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
Paul,
Here's a little more data (from memory).
Climb was at 100 kts [115 MPH] , 1100 fpm from 520 ft to 1500 ft,
then 800 fpm up to
3000 msl at 115 kts [132]. Once I reach 500' agl I start reducing
the prop
rpm. For yesterday's flight prop rpm was set at 2300 for takeoff.
During the 800 fpm climb the oil temp was up to 205 and water
temp was
195.
OAT on the ground was 75, it was a beautiful, cloudless day. (Today
they're predicting a high of 87*... so much for the Texas winters)
I don't have all the other readings as I don't have that many
inputs on
my EFIS. But I do monitor the oil temp out of the engine (pre
oil/air
cooler) and oil temp pre oil/water cooler.
One thing I'm not sure you realize with my cooling system is that I
still have the oil-to-air exchanger installed. I was hoping
that there
would be enough capacity in the water radiator to handle the whole
cooling load, but that was not the case. The oil/air exchanger
is in
series with the oil/water exchanger. So, I left it in place and
feed
the hottest oil to that cooler first, then run it through the
oil-to-water cooler to bring it down another 25*. It was pretty
obvious
from the start that I had an excess of water cooling capacity and a
deficiency of oil cooling. So, all I'm doing is transferring
some of
the load from the oil to the water. If I could increase the cooling
capacity of the oil/air exchanger I probably wouldn't need the
oil/water
exchanger.
Mark S.
I went back and checked some old messages prior to installing the
oil water
HX but you never mentioned OAT or climb. Do you remember what that
may have
been?
"To answer your question on water temps; the water temps were never
a problem.
They would stabilize around 135-150, depending on MAP."
Sounds like your glycol system was very effective if not over kill.
Do you recall the size of the rad?
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
Paul,
The application was Ford Galaxy (probably w/390ci engine, but not
stated). Core size is 18 x 22.5 x 2.5, best I recall. Initial flight
was in August and the temps were in the mid 90's.
Mark S.
You obviously did a great job on the rad ducting. Core volume appears to
be about 1000 cubic inches where our rule of thumb call for 300
cubic inch
per rotor or about 900 at the max for a 3 rotor.
What I can't understand is why the oil cooler is not working better.
Perhaps you have some air leaks in the front duct or the back side
of the oil
cooler is too hot. Can you make some air temps measurements behind
the oil cooler?
What brand of oil cooler is that?
--
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
Paul,
The exhaust manifold is now shielded with 321ss so the oil exchanger
should see minimal radiated heat. My guess is that the water radiator
duct is working so well it is pressurizing the cowl and inhibiting the
air flow through the oil cooler. Could the location of the water inlet
be slightly higher pressure than that of the oil cooler inlet? Does oil
cooler's higher fin density drop the pressure even further? Whatever
the answer, I believe the water radiator is flowing more than its share
of air and is causing the oil cooler to choke.
Another thing, after first flight the oil temps were 240*+ even on
shallow climb. Obviously, this would not do for hot Texas summers. The
first thing I did was to increase the cowl exit area. That helped some
(supporting the above theory). I put a baffle along the lower edge of
the oil exchanger because the exit air from the oil cooler was at a 90*
angle to the air exiting the water radiator. This seemed to help a
little. Still, I couldn't climb at full power on a 90+ day due to high
oil temps. I guess I could have added a second oil/air cooler on the
other inlet, but it seemed worth a try to take advantage of some of the
excess water cooling capacity with the oil/water exchanger. My only
regret is that there isn't enough excess cooling capacity that would
allow me to remove the oil/air exchanger completely.
Mark S.
What are the core dimensions for the oil cooler and the brand name.
Is it new? It sure looks big enough. Fins per inch and tubes per inch
are a good way to characterize heat exchangers.
Cut the water supply to the oil/water HX during cruise and put a couple
of cowl flaps on it to warm the water. Engine eff. will go up.
That is perhaps as much as .02 down on the BSFC and .2 to .4 on the GPH.
There will be less aero cooling drag so MPG will go up significantly.
Matt may have hit on something by using a dedicated exit duct and cowl flap
for the oil cooler. It could converge down to the area of the scoop or less.
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2007 All world wide rights reserved.