Subject: Oil to water heat exchanger data
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 2/26/2008, 12:42 PM
To: AARotary Engine


           Matt,
           Yes, the oil cooler is 3/8" thicker than the glycol
       exchanger.  Also,
           maybe more significant, is that the fin count is much higher for
       the oil
           cooler, resulting in higher drag/pressure drop across it.  I had
           considered adding a dedicated exit duct for the oil cooler, but
       didn't
           want to pay the drag penalty.  That's when I decided to try the
           oil-to-water exchanger.  The beauty with that solution is that
       it didn't
           cost me any additional cooling drag. I feel that if I could
   fit a
           slightly larger glycol exchanger in place of what I'm running
       now, that
           I could eliminate the oil/air exchanger altogether.  I even flew
       with
           50% of the oil/air exchanger blocked off.  It was pretty close
       with the
           current glycol exchanger, but not quite enough to fly in Texas
       in the
           summertime.  So, I left the oil/air exchanger in place and don't
       have
           any more cooling problems.  That's a real good feeling.

           Mark S.


       Mark,

       So you're not interested in the cooling redundancy that Paul has
       suggested as a good idea - using oil-air and glycol-air
   exchangers at
       the same time?  I still think that would be the direction I'd
   go.  In
       fact, I'd make that a requirement, as I think it's something
   that could
       make for a more favorable outcome should the airplane suffer from a
       single component failure..

       Maybe it's just anecdotal, but the vaunted P-51 Mustang has a
   separate
       oil-air cooler, as I believe do the other Merlin powered aircraft
       (Spitfires, Hurricanes, etc).  I think the P-40 (Allison
   powered) was
       the same way.

       The Mustang had an induction air to glycol supercharger
   intercooler, but
       this ran with a separate cooling loop from the engine - and had
   its own
       coolant pump and air-glycol exchanger.  This allowed putting the
       intercooler where the directness/compactness/packaging is
   important.  It
       wouldn't be practical to have a duct feeding an air-air intercooler
       between the stages of the supercharger (on a Merlin).

       Please keep in mind, I don't have a rotary powered airplane, nor a
       liquid cooled airplane, nor even an airplane I built myself, so
   take my
       ideas with a grain of salt..  :)

       I also commend you for putting together an airplane that's running
       well.  I admire the accomplishment.


       Regards,

       Matt-

   Matt,
   I do have a glycol-air and an oil-air exchanger, but also an oil-glycol
   exchanger.  I don't see where removing the oil-glycol exchanger is going
   to improve the time I have to get on the ground should the glycol system
   spring a leak.  I may explore the possibility of building a dedicated
   exit duct for the oil-air exchanger though... in my spare time.  If that
   works out, then I'll consider removing the oil-glycol exchanger.

   Mark S.


Mark,

I'm not necessarily proposing that you remove the oil-glycol exchanger.
I just got the impression you were moving towards removing the oil-air
cooler if you could get the temps where you wanted them without it..  I
believe you said, "My only regret is that there isn't enough excess
cooling capacity that would allow me to remove the oil/air exchanger
completely."

Having both the oil-air and oil-glycol exchangers doesn't bother me.

Going without an oil-air exchanger bothers me.  If you lose a bunch of
glycol you won't be directly cooling the metal in the engine, _nor_ will
you be cooling the oil that keeps the bearings and rotors happy.  If you
have an oil-air exchanger, losing glycol supply doesn't directly impact
your ability to supply cool oil to the bearings and rotors, and so I
think that means the engine will run longer.



Regards,

Matt-



The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2007 All world wide rights reserved.