Subject: Oil to water heat exchanger data
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 2/26/2008, 1:24 PM
To: AARotary Engine



               Matt,
               Yes, the oil cooler is 3/8" thicker than the glycol
           exchanger.  Also,
               maybe more significant, is that the fin count is much
   higher for
           the oil
               cooler, resulting in higher drag/pressure drop across
   it.  I had
               considered adding a dedicated exit duct for the oil
   cooler, but
           didn't
               want to pay the drag penalty.  That's when I decided to
   try the
               oil-to-water exchanger.  The beauty with that solution
   is that
           it didn't
               cost me any additional cooling drag. I feel that if I could
       fit a
               slightly larger glycol exchanger in place of what I'm
   running
           now, that
               I could eliminate the oil/air exchanger altogether.  I
   even flew
           with
               50% of the oil/air exchanger blocked off.  It was pretty
   close
           with the
               current glycol exchanger, but not quite enough to fly in
   Texas
           in the
               summertime.  So, I left the oil/air exchanger in place
   and don't
           have
               any more cooling problems.  That's a real good feeling.

               Mark S.


           Mark,

           So you're not interested in the cooling redundancy that Paul has
           suggested as a good idea - using oil-air and glycol-air
       exchangers at
           the same time?  I still think that would be the direction I'd
       go.  In
           fact, I'd make that a requirement, as I think it's something
       that could
           make for a more favorable outcome should the airplane suffer
   from a
           single component failure..

           Maybe it's just anecdotal, but the vaunted P-51 Mustang has a
       separate
           oil-air cooler, as I believe do the other Merlin powered
   aircraft
           (Spitfires, Hurricanes, etc).  I think the P-40 (Allison
       powered) was
           the same way.

           The Mustang had an induction air to glycol supercharger
       intercooler, but
           this ran with a separate cooling loop from the engine - and had
       its own
           coolant pump and air-glycol exchanger.  This allowed putting the
           intercooler where the directness/compactness/packaging is
       important.  It
           wouldn't be practical to have a duct feeding an air-air
   intercooler
           between the stages of the supercharger (on a Merlin).

           Please keep in mind, I don't have a rotary powered airplane,
   nor a
           liquid cooled airplane, nor even an airplane I built myself, so
       take my
           ideas with a grain of salt..  :)

           I also commend you for putting together an airplane that's
   running
           well.  I admire the accomplishment.


           Regards,

           Matt-

       Matt,
       I do have a glycol-air and an oil-air exchanger, but also an
   oil-glycol
       exchanger.  I don't see where removing the oil-glycol exchanger
   is going
       to improve the time I have to get on the ground should the
   glycol system
       spring a leak.  I may explore the possibility of building a
   dedicated
       exit duct for the oil-air exchanger though... in my spare
   time.  If that
       works out, then I'll consider removing the oil-glycol exchanger.

       Mark S.


   Mark,

   I'm not necessarily proposing that you remove the oil-glycol exchanger.
   I just got the impression you were moving towards removing the oil-air
   cooler if you could get the temps where you wanted them without it..  I
   believe you said, "My only regret is that there isn't enough excess
   cooling capacity that would allow me to remove the oil/air exchanger
   completely."

   Having both the oil-air and oil-glycol exchangers doesn't bother me.

   Going without an oil-air exchanger bothers me.  If you lose a bunch of
   glycol you won't be directly cooling the metal in the engine, _nor_ will
   you be cooling the oil that keeps the bearings and rotors happy.  If you
   have an oil-air exchanger, losing glycol supply doesn't directly impact
   your ability to supply cool oil to the bearings and rotors, and so I
   think that means the engine will run longer.



   Regards,

   Matt-


Matt,
That's probably a good point.  I hope to never find myself in that
situation.  I wonder if the extra glycol capacity provided by the
oil/water exchanger would cancel out any benefits to having the oil
cooled by an oil/air exchanger.  I suppose that would depend on the size
of the leak.

FYI... I'm running aluminum tubing with wiggins couplings for added
reliability.

Mark S.

The water comes out much faster after it starts boiling :)
-- 
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2007 All world wide rights reserved.