Hi Steve Beckman,
Would you refresh my memory on a few things?
As I recall in the Sun n Fun Time To Climb contest from a dead stop to
3000 feet Allen Tolle's PS p-port rotary powered RV3 did it in an all time
record 59 seconds using NOS and a climb prop. Is that a correct statement?
What year was that? I think it was 1996 or 1997 as I recall.
As I recall the gear box went out in the same Sun n Fun 100 mile
cross country race. I think you guys loaded it on a trailer and
towed it back to Oregon.
Do you have any pictures of the cooling system of that airplane?
This is a picture of your airplane. Do you have any pictures of
this cooling system?
BTW we have an Everette Hatch Memorial Race Fund. The money was donated by
the Aircraft Rotary Engine Newsletter subscribers. The current value of
the fund is
about $1000. Currently this prize will be given to the first rotary
powered
airplane that averages over 220 MPH in the annual EAA Dayton Ohio to OSH
Wisc.
500 mile cross country race in July of this year.
This Power Sport 2 rotor P-port powered Velocity aircraft came close to
winning the
prize in 2007 by averaging 212 MPH as I recall. The pilot told me if he
had
known of the prize he would have cranked it up a bit :)
I think Tom Parkes or Mark Seitle 3 rotor powered Lancair ES should be
able to
do it. Tom's in particular as it is turbo charged. Tracy Crook is a dark
horse
as his 3 rotor powered RV8 has not flown yet as far as I know. I don't
think
his current RX8 engine powered RV4 can do it.
Tracy won the prize in 2003 as I recall for the Sun 100 averaging
over 200 MPH in his side port 13B. The bar and prize money was lower in
those days. This pictures was taken by Vaghn Mann
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2007 All world wide rights reserved.
Paul--when I get caught up on things, I'll try to go through the files for
additional data that you requested in your email. I talked to Jack Cox
about the nitrous runs at Sun'N Fun this morning and he is sending me his
Sport Aviation report back then. I had it but lost it along the way. Ditto
most of my file notes with our flight tests prior to the race and race day.
The notes I found show we ran the nitrous in the Sun'n Fun Aeroshell
Time-To-Climb competition with the Mazda conversion engine in 1997 (see
below). It was run normally aspirated in the Sun 100 race where we won our
class dispite Alan following Klaus Savier off-course. This significantly
lowered the recorded speed. Here are just a few rough notes for now....
For the Sun'N Fun competitions, the SuperLight prototype engine we were
flight testing in Alan's RV-3 was removed and the Mazda conversion engine
installed. Full up weight of the RV-3 with our SuperLight engine was 608
pounds. My notes show that with our Mazda conversion engine it was 668
pounds as compared to 0-360 Lycoming RV-3 weight of 800 pounds. The
SuperLight prototype used our original aluminum housings and planetary
reduction gear--we can review the details of this engine later. It was a
sweet piece. In Oregon, we removed the prototype, pre-production
Powersport 200 Mazda conversion engine from my RV-4. It was hauled in the
motor home down to Fresno to put it Alan's RV-3. This was our first
pre-production "conversion" engine, using Mazda's stock housings as a
starting point. It incorporated the systems we developed over the years for
the SuperLight engines--including our periperal ports incorporating the
throttle plates in the rotor housings, ignition, and fuel injection. New
to this engine was the torsionally stiff internal spur gear reduction gear
to eliminate the complexity and cost of the pendulous dampers required to
address the torsional factors associated with the planetary recuction drive.
All the production costs of those original design pieces simply added more
to the cost of the engines than the market could bear, so that's why we were
in the process of gearing up to produce the Mazda-based aircraft engines.
We designed a one-off engine mount for the RV-3 for the conversion
engine/reduction gear. The SuperLight had a special mount with attachments
cast into two end housings, so those tubes had to be cut off and new tubes
fabricated and welded before they left. In Alan's hangar, the RV-3 mount
was modified to fit. It was not pretty. Everett had to weld it with a
torch down there but it did the job. The rear (third point )attach off the
back of the engine was goofy but adequate.
In March of 1997, the engine RV-3 installation was equipped with two nitrous
tanks, and associated pieces and switches were installed and static tested
and then flight tested. The results of this configuration were pretty much
as projected. The jet nozzles we built for the plenum really worked well.
We picked up approx. 50 h.p. from this alone. With 100 h.p. nitrous nozzles
it put out approximately 150 additional h.p.--350 h.p. total. Static
without nitrous was 4800 rpm; with nitrous was 5600 rpm static; bottle
pressure of 700.Don Rivera of AirFlow Performance helped line us with the
nitrous/fuel requirements. Our basic fuel injection system uses an AirFlow
Performance fuel controller/servo produced by Don specifically for the
engine. It's basically the same as what Don produces for the Lycomings but
"detached" from his venturi. He makes a great system and it is delightlful
to work with him. We designed, made and tested our own venturi to provide a
signal to Don's fuel controller/venturi so we could locate the venturi at
the entrance of the plenum. This was done to allow us to locate the
servo/controller right on the side of the engine with short, direct lever
interconnect to the throttle arms. Don used to work at Bendix and his
system uses those well-tested basic principles. It is dirt simple. Always
worked flawlessly. We configured the fuel and induction system with
production and various installations in mind. to keep everything compact as
possible..so the engine could be bolted in to any airframe.
In the RV-3, normally aspirated, notes on one test show a two-way average
GPS reading was 235-239 mph, 2500 feet, temperature of 65 degrees@ 7,000 rpm
with 70x85 fixed-pitch wood prop....210-215 degrees water temp and 225
degrees oil.. Full rich was 1700 front EGT and 1650 rear. Reduction gear
ratio of 2.32. So you can see with the thick ends of the wooden prop there
were losses at the prop tip at 7000 rpm race speeds. Worth noting here our
normal cruise rpm was in the 5000-5600 range. Notes show that in the RV-3,
5,000 cruise usually was approx. 200 mph with 71x97 cruise prop. There was
absolutely no drag cleanup regarding engine/airframe and it had that
horrible square firewall airflow exit. We'll work on this kind of stuff on
the new airplane.
Prior to and during Sun'N Fun competitions I had to stay and work so our
friend Dean Hobbensiefken drove down with Everett to Alan's place and after
flight testing and tuning the nitrous set, Dean and Everett drove the motor
home from Alan's place to Sun'N Fun. Alan and Everett gave our forum
presentation there. Will get you Jack Cox's report in Sport Aviation
regarding the first day of Time-To-Climb competition and the cross-country
race. Don't know if it has the times or not. He said that in 1997 we had
the fast time on day one (can't find the sheet with our time but will keep
looking). First race was against the Thunder Mustang with Dave Morss up and
we were able to put them on the trailer. Don't think folks expected that
result. The Sun 100 (mile) cross country race followed that first day
qualifying. Although I remember we won for our class we toasted the rear
bearing in the reduction drive at about the finish line. We suspected it
might be a problem .
The guys took the wings off the RV-3, put it on the trailer and towed it
home. When you look at the photographs taken of this engine in Alan's RV-3
(see Sport Aviation, July 1996, pages 90-95) you can see the RV-4 mounting
points cast into the power-section-to reduction gear adaptor, hanging in the
breeze unused. After the races in 1997, we removed the engine, made some
design changes to the reduction gear; disassembled the power section to see
the results of using the nitrous, and reassembled everything and reinstalled
it in my RV-4 and flew it until Everett passed out and crashed October 27
that fall.
After Everett died, all the Powersport stuff went with the sale of
Powersport to Ray Richardson, owner of Ratech Machine, who named the
business Powersport Aviation. I can fill you in on the status of all that
off-line. We've obtained numerous original pieces of equipment from him for
our current project. Included are the annular inlet aluminum cowling we
built for the RV-3, engine mount and our first redesigned internal spur
reduction gear which went with the assembled first production engine in the
sale to Richardson, and some other pieces. I hope he gets his financial act
together because that little engine and reduction gear has a lot of sweat
and blood invested from this end. And Steve Weinzierl did a good job with
engineering his tweaks for inclusion in the reduction gear. It made it
somewhat heavier than our original reduction gear that went with the sale
but it should be a very good and safe piece. Very good torsionally and it
is hell-for-stout. I personally like the simplicity of our fuel
system/injection but I'm old school in that regard.
Meanwhile, Francis Romig is the master machinist who did all our machining
on the orignal engines and he is working with me and Phillip Groelz to build
a clone engine to use this reduction gear and engine mount. Don Rivera has
the reproduction plenum presently for flow testing and we'll use Don's dual
electric pump package.
Cooling system--I do have some cooling system photographs of the RV-3. Have
scads of good transparencies of the RV-4. The Sport Aviation article
reference above shows the general layout of the RV-3 but it was very
different than the RV-4 as it was originally done for the very light
prototype all aluminum engine which was waaay forward.. The two heat
exchangers angle up on the sides as shown and one lays horizonally between
them (looks like a "u" from the front of the aircraft with the sides of the
"u" angled out). We were able to retain this configuration in the RV-3 with
the heavier conversion engine but it's a lot tighter. If we retain this
setup, plan now is to use one of the same actual plate-fin brazed heat
exchangers with two new ones (two for water and one for oil...all same size)
in same exact configuration as we designed the system in the RV-3. You'll
recognize these from your race-car days. Standard Serck/Mocal, etc units.
We found that using the largest possible area with thinnest possible section
allowed us to achieve lowest drag with low delta-P for good cooling when
you need it the most. Airflow controlled with cowl flap. Used a common
swirl pot welded for the installation. Have to make a new one as it was
lost along the way. But we want to look at possible alternative exhaust
routing/muffler so that all may change configuration..
Hope to have the engine/reduction gear in the airframe soon to start working
on those details. After all that we'll build a mount to fit it on the
dyno. Testing to include mufflers and other exhaust experiments. If all
goes well along the way, it would be fun to think about the Dayton-OSH race.
But obviously not this year and don't want to do it until if and when we get
this piece fully sorted out and fully flight tested and we know we would be
competitive. In the RV-3 it is not without risk given the fact that if we
get our act together, it will be well over VNE straight and level. And our
target speeds are higher on this installation than before. Regarding the
three rotor, I worry about torsional issues due to the frequencies
involved...as I remember everything comes together within the operating
range. Have some basic preliminary data in my file. I think Steve Weinzierl
had some work done in this regard for Ray Richardson with that professor
from North Dakota when they instrumented a three-rotor some time ago after I
sold Powersport. But I have not seen that data. Have you? Be good for
somebody to really get serious about a torsional vibrational analysis/ study
on it. Don't wanna see anybody get hurt. Have seen first hand (more than
once) what happens. Take care Paul.
Steve Beckman
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2007 All world wide rights reserved.