Subject: turbo-compounding and the Prius
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 3/1/2008, 10:42 AM
To: AAA Put this in the To box



The higher the voltage the less the current. It also saves motor and alternator
weight. Controlling and converting such high voltage to DC however adds  a lot of cost
to the semiconductors required.

A 30 KW DC motor is about 40 HP. The neat thing about DC motors is they have very high
torque at low RPM so the acceleration from a dead stop is excellent. However acceleration
at 50 kilometer per hour or 30 MPH on up is strictly a function of the power to weight
ratio of the vehicle and to a lessor extent the aerodynamic drag and tire rolling drag.
This is why Prius's are not popular except in the large southerly moderate climate cities
like LA and Perth where people drive around on the freeways at steady speeds. Actually at
the head of every moving traffic jam in LA there is a 80 MPH top speed Prius. In the
northern and in hot southern cities you need a lot of extra electrical  power to heat
and cool the car which subtracts from the MPG.

Toyota spent big bucks reducing the weight, tire rolling drag and aero drag on the Prius.
If the same measures were applied to all cars the MPG would also be improved.

Electricity is not free. The over all eff. of the electric car depends on where
the electricity comes from. In those countries like Europe and Japan that generate
most of the juice from a nuclear power plants there is no direct impact on the environment except
for what do you do with the waste? However in the US and China most of the juice comes from
burning coal and oil. The over all eff. of the electric car then does not look so good.

A good power plant can get 50% of the heat energy out of coal or oil using bottoming cycle
engines. A bottoming cycle engine recovers waste heat in the exhaust similar to turbo
compounding.  Then you must convert the heat in the form of mechanical energy to electricity.
Lets say that is 90% eff. We are now down to 45% OA. Then you must transfer the electricity
to where it is needed which could be hundreds of miles away. Give it another 90%. We are down
to 40.5% OA. Then you must convert it from thousands of volts down to 220 AC volts. Give
that 95% so we are down to 38.5% OA. Now you must jack it back up from 220 AC to 288 volts
DC to charge the batteries. Give that 85%. Now we are down to 32.7% OA. About the same as a
diesel engine or turbo compound Wankel powered car but without the drawbacks of poor high speed
acceleration, extra weight (natural resources like copper and iron) and the heating and
cooling limitations.  You can argue with the exact numbers but the conversion steps
required are facts. There is no free lunch.

In the Dust to Dust study the Mazda RX8 rates higher than the Prius. Think how much better
it would rate with a turbo compound rotary. Here is a car that is 500 pounds lighter
than other four passenger cars with similar HP. This illustrates the big advantage of
the  high power to weight ratio of the rotary engine in it's reduced use of natural
resources like iron and aluminum.

BTW My 1973 RX2 was 500 pounds lighter than the RX8 with the same weight rotary
engine but that is another story having do with crashing.

Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

Very interesting report !!  It looks like it was not done by "a car guy"
though. Key to the cost per mile is the est. life miles. They show the
RX8 at only 139K miles. This sounds very very low to me and the Prius at
109K sounds a tad high due to the $8000 price of the replacement battery
pack not covered under warranty. The problem is it has about 250 size D
batteries in it, but they are not individually serviceable.

Also highly suspect is the RAM pickup. They show only 231K miles for it.
Clearly this is not the diesel. Less than 30% of the RAM trucks produced
are gas engines so the study should have been with the diesel. It looks
like the H1 diesel was selected over the gas version as only the diesel
would go the 379K miles they are showing,

-dave

He is a car guy and a rotor head. I contacted him about the RX8 life mileage
estimate and he agreed to increase it. Here is his response.

I'll forward this to him as well.


Paul...

You're right. The miles in lifetime is incorrect and will be corrected
in the next release of D2D.

FYI, I was once the managing editor of the Wankel Report published by Ward's
Communications (Detroit). It was specifically for engineers and did quite well,
later becoming Engine Update including all matter of techy stuff on all sorts of powerplants.

I actually read every word of Jan Norby's book on the Wankel (which, at the
time, was the definitive technical work about the engine) in 1970 or thereabout.
Jan thought I was crazy and possibly only one of five people in the world to have
read it cover to cover. At the time, I could name every part in the Wankel
including the confounded (at the time) seals -- in German. "Epitrochoid" became
part of my party vocabulary and would drop it in mixed company just to show off.

FYI2: The American Motors version of the Wankel was code-named OGRE
(Operation Gremlin, Rotary Engine).

Glad you enjoy your rotaries. It's a great engine.

Best,

Art


The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2007 All world wide rights reserved.