Tell me if I got this right.
The problems with a roadable airplane are:
1. A single powerplant needs to provide two
different kinds of power or you have the weight
of two powerplants.
2. The undercarriage needs to be dual use which
is complex and heavy. Having a separate
undercarriage for driving and landing is heavy.
3. The undercarriage and the rest of the vehicle
gets beaten up while driving.
4. The low speed vehicle classification is too restrictive
and a regular car needs to meet safety requirements.
It looks almost impossible.
-Jeff Martin
1? Yes.
2? Maybe.
3? To some extent.
4? Yes.
Not impossible. To get around the car crash rules which adds about 500
pounds to the typical small car you need to make it 3 wheels and
register it
as a motor cycle. Also the smog rules are relaxed for motor cycles.
Yes the suspension and wheel drive does add a bit of weight but not
a show stopper.
Generally speaking cars are shorter than fuselages so you need to choose
an aircraft type that has a short fuselage. That would be a canard.
I realized one of the unique features of the rotary
is its very simple e-shaft. If one makes it longer and
larger in diameter on the front end one can get power out of both
ends. One end is mated to a stock VW transmission and the
other end uses one of Ken Welters 3:1 cog belt reduction drives.
You take off in first gear and get much better acceleration to
flying speed. This is due to the traction you get out of tires
as opposed to a highly slipping prop. As soon as you run out of
RPM in first you push in the clutch and shift into neutral.
the prop takes over.
For road work you remove the canard and main wings
and tow them behind you. The only drawback here is the weight
of the VW gear box and drive shafts.
Its a motor cycle on the ground as that circumvents a load of
EPA and DOT rules.
The large wheels also give you a bit more ground clearance for
suspension travel when landing. Suspension is on the down stops
when lowered for landing. Also the rotary gets better
gas millage just like any other ICE if you keep the cruise
RPM as low as possible.
Roadable airplanes ARE flyable. There are no technological
break throughs required. The vast majority of the
parts are off the shelf.
The main challenge is minimizing the weight penalty.
Most roadable aircraft designs use twin booms for the tail but
the Ruttan Canard configuration is a better fit with roadable
requirements IMHO. To my knowledge nobody has flown the canard
configuration yet.
With the gear retracted there will be near zero aerodynamic
penalties.
One of the design parameters one needs to pay a lot of attention
to on a roadable is the weight of the wheels and tires.
I suggest dragster forged aluminum front wheels and tires at 15 by 3 1/2
for the rear. You need diameter as the cruise RPM on
the ground using the VW tx requires a rather large diameter
tire.
The front tire can be a light weight motorcycle wheel
and tire. Motor cycle disc brakes will also keep the weight
down.
The large wheels also give you a bit more ground clearance for
suspension travel when landing. Suspension is on the down stops
when lowered for landing. Also the rotary gets better
gas millage just like any other ICE if you keep the cruise
RPM as low as possible.
Trailer configuration.
You build narrow wheels and part of the hitch into the leading edge
of the wings and strap the canard to one of them. Hinge the tip vertical
stabilizers to lie flat (more or less) on top of the wings.
Paul Lamar
Perry Micks response on when you need the trailer and when you don't.
In most cases would you even need to trailer the wings? You keep the car
at home and the wings at your local airport. Drive to airport, put on
wings. Fly to your destination. Leave wings at that airport. Drive
locally around that airport. When you are ready to go home, drive back
to destination airport and put the wings back on. Takeoff and fly back
to home airport. Take wings off and drive home, leaving wings at local
airport.
Perry Mick
http://www.rotaryeng.net/roadable.html
Perry has a good point - Unless you plan on landing at airport B and
driving to airport C for your take-off to return to airport A, what do
you need to drag them around for ? Part of the media misconception
fueling these scams for flying cars is the fact that we can not use
public roads for take off or landing w/o some emergency. That leaves
airports and private land with the owner's prior permission to T & L.
Also part of this misconception is the car must be 4 wheels and 4 seats,
drive 85 mph, fly at 200 mph, get 20 mpg, be as safe as a Volvo. Did I
miss anything ? LOL !!
I think the next jump in technology for ALL cars (to make them very very
light and thus efficient to make and drive) is to move the primary air
bags to the outside of the car. Using the technology Mercedes did for
auto panic brakes in an impending crash, sensors would deploy the
external air bag when the crash for that side is imminent. Similar to
the Mars probe landing. Think about how much lighter the car can be
without all the structural steel to protect in all these various crash
scenarios ? I have watched crash tests on prototypes. Lots of energy to
dissipate. Something air bags do well. Such a car could easily be both
safe and light enough for wings :-)
-dave
That is a good idea Dave. I just found an old RX2 brochure that I got
when I bought my new RX2 back in 1973. The weight of the 1973 RX2 two door
car was 2,325 pounds with no aluminum body parts. The 2004 RX8 with the same weight
rotary engine is just over 3000 pounds with aluminum body parts.
What is amazing about this idea is the airbags can be smaller if you can knock
600 pounds out of the weight of the car.
--
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2007 All world wide rights reserved.