Subject: Poor man's Hypobaric Chamber
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 3/5/2008, 9:26 PM
To: AAA Put this in the To box



Paul,

Do we have anyone on this newsletter with experience with engine
testing
within a hypobaric chamber? I am curious to know how they work.
I believe the chambers would have to have a means of blowing in
fresh air
while sucking the exhaust out at a greater rate than the input air to
keep
the chamber at partial vacuums.

With the Poor Mans hypobaric Chamber, PMHC, lets us say that our
purpose is
to only test how much the recovery turbine increases in power at higher
altitudes. We won't have to test heat exchangers and electronics
because we
are confident our over-designed systems will function well at high
altitudes.  Yea right:)  In any case the oil and water cooling is
handled
remotely like on standard dyno set ups.

Background info:

A turbocompound engine must be  boosted for the recovery of energy to
occur.
Let us assume we want to test the traditionally turbocompounding method
first. In operation both a supercharger and blow down turbine are
connected
to the drive shaft albeit in different locations. The supercharger is
taking
energy from the drive shaft and the blow down turbine is putting that
loss
and some 'plus alpha' power back into the shaft. In other words there
is a
net gain. Sort of like 'compounded interest'

Testing:

First the supercharger.  Factory test data curves showing power
consumption
at different pressures and airflows can be confirmed by running the
supercharger connected to a large electric motor and confirming the
results.
By the putting a torque arm on the free-to-rotate blower, and
running it
through a manifold simulating the manifold resistance, the compressor
becomes the load. Temp., pressure, and air flows are documented as
well.
Running the intake through a hypobaric (partial vacuum) chamber of
lets say
a 10 cubic foot thick steel pipe with a control valve set on the
intake set
to maintain a certain partial vacuum might work I think.

Second the exhaust.


Now imagine the  exhaust pipe is connected to our test turbine and from
there into a  another pipe hypobaric chamber.  Connected to the
outlet of
this pipe would be a blower which was reversed so as to suck. This
powerful
vacuum unit will be driven by the same supercharge 25kW 3phase
electric test
motor and interfaced with a vacuum sensor set to keep the exhaust
hypobaric
chamber at 14.95" of Hg if we were simulating 18,000 ft.  Running the
test
in winter would give us our low STP intake temperatures.

Let me back up and say that this testing would be done only after the
engine
is running stable and in the boosted conditions. Next the blowdown
turbine
needs to be connected to a dyno. After the output is confirmed from
different turbines we can connect the best candidate to the drive
shaft.

So what are we testing here?  We can understand that at a given CFM of
air
input, MAP, and altitude, how much power the blowdown turbine is
putting
out. We hold the altitude and vary the MAP and/or RPM and note the
results.
In short we know how the  turbine's will perform at increasing high
altitudes.

Now if the goal was to test a turbochargers at altitude than this
system
would work as well. We replace the supercharger, with a turbo
charger and
compressor, and either a flexible shaft from the compressor to the
dyno set
or the turbo exhaust to another blow down turbine and then dyno.

I would appreciate comment on any of these premises.


Sincerely


Doug in Japan

You could test at the top of Pikes Peak or mount Fuji.

Or you could rent Pratt & Whitney test chamber.

Paul Lamar

It was a surprise to me P & W doesn't care what happens post engine. Of
course our engine doesn't matter as much as theirs does about the
velocity entering the engine, but  T & P we also care about. The car
makers here all test their cars at Pike Peak, particularly the towing
ratings. Are there road up Mt Fuji ?

-dave

Dave,

There is a road up to the fifth station of Fuji at 2300 meters but
none to
the top.  I believe they had to bring the weather station dome on top by
helicopter. Mt Fuji is rugged and very exposed. Winds can and often do
literally blow people off the mountain. I was lucky to climb it on an
autumn
day devoid of both wind and people.

http://www.japan-guide.com/e/e6901.html

I will haul the  engine complete with cowlings, and heat exchangers
inside
the fan drive wind tunnel dyno up to altitudes for the final testing, but
now I am at the a turbine sizing planning stage.

About simulating high altitude testing, I reasoned that the input mass of
gases and fuel is  equal to the exit mass of gases but the temperature of
the gases and the volume of gases increase.

I don't fully understand how the ICE test chambers work but I reasoned
that
they must allow the exhaust gases, to expand completely and then pull
them
out of the chamber  with engine heat using huge exhaust fans. Their
biggest
inputs of energy to run the chamber then is in exhausting the chamber
at a
faster rate than the air comes in as well as the cooling loads for
providing
the make up air. It is hard to fathom the amount of energy that is
needed to
test a  jet engine at a simulated 65,000 feet.

I am now just concerned with testing the performance of one exhaust
turbine
at at simulated altitude. Can we computer model turbine performance at
altitude? Perhaps if we had some  data from turbo makers but that is like
pulling teeth.

On the input side of our engine we test at a temperature equivalent to
what
we know exists on a STP day at our test altitude.  We use nature as it is
expensive to create the large and constant volume of refrigerated air we
need. This means winter testing. Giving this matter some more thought,
since
we already know the performance of our compressor at different
altitudes we
can downgrade its performance by altering it to match the expected
performance at a given altitude. Perhaps we can choke the inlet and/or
bleed
air after the compressor.  This takes care of the input side.

On the exhaust side I'm not sure.  We would have to make the exhaust
think
it was exiting the pipe into a partial vacuum atmosphere. Could this be
accomplished before the gases are expanded by pulling a partial vacuum
on a
tee junction out near the final end of the exhaust manifold?  High
temperature would be the challenge so we would run a turbocharger in
reverse
via a electric motor.  Just upstream we would need a way to measure the
ambient pressure and a feedback loop to control either the  electric
motor
inverter or a solonoid operated bleed valve. Our testing would be done in
the steady state manner because with such small pipes, high
velocities, and
high temperatures, the challenge is daunting.


Ah well...  Back to the drawing board.


Doug in Japan.

Doug, contact Barber Nichols for turbines.
http://www.barber-nichols.com/email_us/
engineer@barber-nichols.com

Don't tell them I sent you.
Make like GM or Toyota.

Paul Lamar

The alloy will be very interesting to me $$$ will be the issue. The 3
examples below all look like low temperature turbines.

-dave

Jeff Spitzer is no longer on here as he is too busy.
Jeff worked for Moller when Moller had the OMC engine converted
to water cooling and two rotors. He also designed a scaled down
150 HP Junkers Jumo diesel engine and showed it at OSH one year.
He is the Chief Engineer on the GA Predator. He got it up to 57,000 feet
so he knows what he is talking about. He sent me this as part of
some other subject we were discussing.

Paul Lamar


Hi Paul,

I can't get sucked into these threads with my time constaints - pun
intended.  But the hypobaric chamber is actually quite simple.  You
simply run a large roots blower to suck air through a large diameter
pipe as the author suggested.  The roots blower is sized to suck much
more airflow than the engine uses thus creating a bypass situation.  The
intake and exhaust are simply tee'd into the large diameter pipe with
the intake upstream and the exhaust downstream.  Now here's the trick:
You control the vacuum by throttling the discharge from a [the] compressor of
the turbocharger and the flow upstream of the turbine.  The roots blower
sucks air through the turbine.  That makes the air do work and thus
lowers its temperature to more accurately represent high altitude
ambient (feeding air from a portable air conditioner will actually get
the correct temps).  Obviously, the turbocharger used for intake
pressure reduction must be properly sized and a pressurized oil source
is required (separate from the engine in case it quits - so as not to
munch your turbo).  For our 150 HP diesel engine to test at 16,000 ft we
needed a 40 hp blower and a properly sized T-04 turbo.  Testing a gas
engine would require a smaller blower because the diesel was using
considerably more airflow.

Jeff Spitzer


Jeff,


Thanks for your time. Your comments confirmed some hunches. I follow your
line of thinking but the wording is a bit confusing. I will want to test
with a super charger and only one exhaust turbine at first and that may be
immaterial to what you wrote.

Lets see if I got this right. We use a turbocharger as a low resistance,
fine tuning pressure control valve?  Reason: With a small chamber, regular
baffle valves can not react fast enough to keep a steady partial pressure.
If so then we mount the turbocharger so that its' turbine outlet connects to
the inlet of the large pipe which is our hypobaric chamber.  Naturally this
turbocharger is up stream of the intake  and  exhaust tees so that a partial
vacuum, created by the roots blower on the outlet end of the chamber, pulls
outside air through the turbo charger turbine.  As outside air is pulled
through the turbine it has little air flow resistance but its volume expands
into the lower pressure within the chamber and cools.  Boyles Law.
Throttling the attached compressor output, that is sucking as well as
blowing air into the outside ambient area, is simply a means of controlling
the speed of the turbine. Thus the amount of air going into the chamber and
hence partial pressure can be controlled. The turbocharger becomes the
'partial pressure controller' and has as a flow relationship with the Roots
blower and must be sized accordingly.  The roots blower and the air inlet
turbocharger  have to pass more air through the chamber than the engine
needs.


If I understand you correctly this is literally  a 'cool' idea:)


Doug in Japan



The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2007 All world wide rights reserved.