Subject: Diesel verses gasoline aircraft.
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 4/9/2008, 10:50 AM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


>   172 verses 172 diesel data from the Cessna web site.
>
>> Diesel fuel is a pound heavier than gasoline.
>> Gas is six pounds per gallon and diesel is 7 pounds per gallon.
>>
>> 44.6 gallons of diesel weighs 312 pounds of fuel.
>>
>> Max useful load on a Diesel 172 is 742 pounds.
>> Subtract the full fuel weight and you get 430 pounds.
>> Range is 588 nm.
>> 85% power is 132 HP.
>> Cruise speed is 118 kts or 5 hours.
>>
>> 8.9 gallons an hour or 62.5 pounds per hour.
>> BSFC is therefore .47. Not a lot different than a rotary.
>> And typical for a diesel engine running near full power.
>>
>> A leaned rotary at 132 HP would be about the same BSFC but the
>> gallons per hour would be higher at 62.5/6 or 10.4 gallons per
>> hour.
>>
>>
>> ------------------------------------------------------
>> The numbers for a stock Lycoming powered 172 are:
>>
>> 56 gallons of gasoline weighs 336 pounds of fuel.
>> Max useful load is 758 pounds.
>> Subtract the full fuel weight and you get 422 pounds.
>> Range is 580 nm.
>> 80% power is 128 HP.
>> Cruise speed is 122 Kts or 4.8 hours. Four kts faster than the
>> diesel.
>>
>> 11.8 gallons an hour or 69.6 pounds per hour.
>> BSFC is therefore .54 which is a typical for a Lycoming
>> rich of peak.
>>
>> It would take a long time to pay for the extra $15,000 you
>> will pay for a diesel powered 172.
>>
>> Not to mention you are required to throw the diesel away
>> at 1200 hours if it does not pass inspection. No overhaul
>> allowed. If it does pass 1200 hour inspection you are required to
>> throw it away at 2400 hours. No exceptions.
>>
>> At 100 hours a year that is 24 years. At that point the Mercedes
>> diesel engine will probably no longer be available so the
>> airplane, in theory, will be worthless. One would have to replace
>> the engine now certified in the diesel powered 172 with some
>> other engine and obtain an FAA STC.
>>
>>
>> I don't see it :)
>> --
>> Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
>
> Paul, I don't know what the prices of diesel are in the lower 48,
> but up here in Alaska I've seen it .20 to .30 cents a gallon
> higher than Mogas. I have never been able to figure out why the
> diesel seemed like a good idea in
> an Aircraft...
>
> Rick in Alaska
>
>
> It is higher here too. In Europe however it gets a tax break.
> Gasoline is $7.50 a gallon and diesel is about $6.50 as I recall.
> 100 LL in Europe is really expensive at around $10 a gallon or
> more.
>
> All new US built air cooled piston engines require 100 LL.
> In a lot of places in the world you can't get 100 LL.
> Francois is positioning the Mistral rotary to run on auto gas
> which is widely available world wide. Particularly in Russia.
> I think Cessna has the diesel in mind for European sales.
> In the States Cessna says Jet A only in the diesel 172.
>
> Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

Given Thielerts share price development since a Hamburg court
negated their 2003 thru 2005 financial reports in March,
http://uk.finance.yahoo.com/q/bc?s=T3C.DE&t=1y
Fuel consumptions is the least of a diesel owners worries right now.

Mark W



The same Diamond TwinStar is apparently offered with Lycoming Engines -
probably  with an eye on the stateside market. The smart thing IMHO
would be for flight schools to get one of each or a 50/50 split on a
new fleet. The amortized costs being the proof of the pudding :^)

Fly & Build good -
Bryan In England



The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2007 All world wide rights reserved.