Diesel (jetA) versus gasoline makes sense over here in Europe: price per
liter (or gallon) and lower consumption per horsepower, makes that to make
it short, the fuel bill per hour is about half with JetA diesel Thielert
engines on DA40 or on C172, than on avgas piston engines.
Of course this is very a artificial advantage, because all due to state
taxes which drive avgas to very high price levels, whereas jetA is lower
taxed. As long as governments do not change their policies, this advantage
will remain.
Over your country, in the US, where "true" market conditions prevail, the
numbers do show that the advantage is far from paying for the increase in
upfront cost at time af engine purchase.
SIDE QUESTION: rotary engines can run on jetA, with spark ignition (no hope
to get the compression for diesel ignition). The question is: how easily can
an existing rotary engine be converted to jetA. Then next question: what
kind of BSFC can be expected ?
Thanks for the xperts who will provide answers to these.
Rgds
Philippe CHENEVIER (in France)
Mistral spent a lot of money trying to get a practical diesel fueled
rotary working. I think they gave up. The engine did not generates as
much power and the BSFC was no better as I recall. I wish Francois would
give us a final report.
I also saw the Wankel Gmbh diesel fuel engine run at OSH and at the factory
in Korb. Juergan Bax gave me a bottle of wine with the subject on the label.
I still have it :)
--
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
OK, Paul, you got your interim report on Mistral jet-fuelled rotary
development. I'll try to be brief.
Mr Chenevier is correct, compression ignition is out of the picture with
rotary technology. Mistral is developing with the Swiss Federal
Institute of Technology in Lausanne (EPFL) a SPARK-IGNITED,
high-pressure direct-injected jet-fuelled rotary engine. We are 15
months into the program with another 12 months to go. The objective is
to achieve a power-density of at least 100hp per rotor (of 654cc). The
development is going in the right direction but there are still many
issues to be solved. Let's say that, in the best of case, we are 24
months away from a flying prototype.
We do this development because some markets require heavy-fuel engines
(the military especially). But a valid question is: why use Jet-A in
an internal-combustion engine when this fuel was designed for turbines?
Sure, it is possible as diesel engines have demonstrated, but at the
cost of significant additional complexity, heavier weight, reduced power
density, higher manufacturing, maintenance and overhaul costs, and
reduced reliability.
Jet-A is cheaper than gasoline? No, unless it is tax-subsidized, it is
approximately the same price as 100LL; mogas is the cheapest and by
far the best distributed fuel world-wide. Is mogas available on a few
airports? Sure, but it's a question of insufficient demand... the
solution is in creating this demand... as an illustration, 60% of German
and Austrian GA airport sell mogas, due to the (modest) demand of the
Rotax-powered fleet.
Finally, an answer to Steve's question: fuel price is basically
determined by two factors (its an oversimplification but it's good
enough an illustration):
1) The fuel's energy content per gallon.
2) The market demand for the fuel's particular "cut" of the feed. Jet-A
and diesel have 10-12% higher energy content (per gallon) than gasoline,
they are therefore, on average, that much more expensive than mogas
(avgas is a special case because of small volume and separate logistics).
The heavier fuels use a "cut" that is in competition with, for instance,
heating oil. In the winter, Jet-A and Diesel tend therefore to be more
expensive than average, while gasoline's price is below average (less
seasonal demand for the "lower cut"). The reverse tends to be true in
the summer. Other market factors come into play, but are of generally
lesser importance.
Let's just mention one interesting fact: the French automobile park is
over 70% diesel powered. French refineries cannot produce enough diesel
and France has therefore to import large quantities of that fuel
(primarily from Russia, I was told), paying a premium for it, plus
higher transport costs than those of crude. Diesel, which has been
historically much cheaper than gasoline because it was much less highly
taxed (hence explaining the composition of the French automobile park),
is becoming more expensive now that the European Union is imposing
identical taxation on all fuels. Things may therefore change. Some
people think that avgas' price will climb faster than Jet-A's... well,
that's far from being obvious, although avgas' price is a special case.
What is sure is that diesel fuel, as well as Jet-A, will stay at
significantly higher prices than mogas, unless differential taxes screw
up the market.
Fly safe,
Francois
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2007 All world wide rights reserved.