Subject: Diesel verses gasoline aircraft.
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 4/27/2008, 2:19 PM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


    > > >> > 172 verses 172 diesel data from the Cessna web site.
    > > >> >
    > > >> >> Diesel fuel is a pound heavier than gasoline.
    > > >> >> Gas is six pounds per gallon and diesel is 7 pounds per
   gallon.
    > > >> >>
    > > >> >> 44.6 gallons of diesel weighs 312 pounds of fuel.
    > > >> >>
    > > >> >> Max useful load on a Diesel 172 is 742 pounds.
    > > >> >> Subtract the full fuel weight and you get 430 pounds.
    > > >> >> Range is 588 nm.
    > > >> >> 85% power is 132 HP.
    > > >> >> Cruise speed is 118 kts or 5 hours.
    > > >> >>
    > > >> >> 8.9 gallons an hour or 62.5 pounds per hour.
    > > >> >> BSFC is therefore .47. Not a lot different than a rotary.
    > > >> >> And typical for a diesel engine running near full power.
    > > >> >>
    > > >> >> A leaned rotary at 132 HP would be about the same BSFC
   but the
    > > >> >> gallons per hour would be higher at 62.5/6 or 10.4
   gallons per
    > > >> >> hour.
    > > >> >>
    > > >> >>
    > > >> >> ------------------------------------------------------
    > > >> >> The numbers for a stock Lycoming powered 172 are:
    > > >> >>
    > > >> >> 56 gallons of gasoline weighs 336 pounds of fuel.
    > > >> >> Max useful load is 758 pounds.
    > > >> >> Subtract the full fuel weight and you get 422 pounds.
    > > >> >> Range is 580 nm.
    > > >> >> 80% power is 128 HP.
    > > >> >> Cruise speed is 122 Kts or 4.8 hours. Four kts faster
   than the
    > > >> >> diesel.
    > > >> >>
    > > >> >> 11.8 gallons an hour or 69.6 pounds per hour.
    > > >> >> BSFC is therefore .54 which is a typical for a Lycoming
    > > >> >> rich of peak.
    > > >> >>
    > > >> >> It would take a long time to pay for the extra $15,000 you
    > > >> >> will pay for a diesel powered 172.
    > > >> >>
    > > >> >> Not to mention you are required to throw the diesel away
    > > >> >> at 1200 hours if it does not pass inspection. No overhaul
    > > >> >> allowed. If it does pass 1200 hour inspection you are
   required to
    > > >> >> throw it away at 2400 hours. No exceptions.
    > > >> >>
    > > >> >> At 100 hours a year that is 24 years. At that point the
   Mercedes
    > > >> >> diesel engine will probably no longer be available so the
    > > >> >> airplane, in theory, will be worthless. One would have to
   replace
    > > >> >> the engine now certified in the diesel powered 172 with some
    > > >> >> other engine and obtain an FAA STC.
    > > >> >>
    > > >> >>
    > > >> >> I don't see it :)
    > > >> >> --
    > > >> >> Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
    > > >> >
    > > >> > Paul, I don't know what the prices of diesel are in the
   lower 48,
    > > >> > but up here in Alaska I've seen it .20 to .30 cents a gallon
    > > >> > higher than Mogas. I have never been able to figure out
   why the
    > > >> > diesel seemed like a good idea in
    > > >> > an Aircraft...
    > > >> >
    > > >> > Rick in Alaska
    > > >> >
    > > >> >
    > > >> > It is higher here too. In Europe however it gets a tax break.
    > > >> > Gasoline is $7.50 a gallon and diesel is about $6.50 as I
   recall.
    > > >> > 100 LL in Europe is really expensive at around $10 a gallon
   or
    > > >> > more.
    > > >> >
    > > >> > All new US built air cooled piston engines require 100 LL.
    > > >> > In a lot of places in the world you can't get 100 LL.
    > > >> > Francois is positioning the Mistral rotary to run on auto gas
    > > >> > which is widely available world wide. Particularly in Russia.
    > > >> > I think Cessna has the diesel in mind for European sales.
    > > >> > In the States Cessna says Jet A only in the diesel 172.
    > > >> >
    > > >> > Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
    > > >>
    > > >> Given Thielerts share price development since a Hamburg court
    > > >> negated their 2003 thru 2005 financial reports in March,
    > > >> http://uk.finance.yahoo.com/q/bc?s=T3C.DE&t=1y
    > > >> Fuel consumptions is the least of a diesel owners worries
   right now.
    > > >>
    > > >> Mark W


    > > > The same Diamond TwinStar is apparently offered with Lycoming
    > Engines -
    > > > probably with an eye on the stateside market. The smart thing
   IMHO
    > > > would be for flight schools to get one of each or a 50/50
   split on a
    > > > new fleet. The amortized costs being the proof of the pudding
   :^)
    > > >
    > > > Fly & Build good -
    > > > Bryan In England



    > > The Lycoming powered DA42 was never pursued. There was no market
    > interest as
    > > far as I know. The DA 40 is certified with by Thierert and
   Lycoming
    > > powerplant.
    > >
    > > Mark W



    > More Thielert Diesel Woes
    >
    > AVWeb
    >
   (http://www.avweb.com/avwebflash/news/MoreTroubleFor_Thielert_197722-1.html)
    > says:
    >
    > "
    > *_MORE TROUBLE FOR THIELERT_
    > *
    > __ The supervisory board of Thielert AG, the German company that
    > manufactures Thielert diesel aircraft engines and also owns
   Texas-based
    > Superior Air Parts _said in a statement today_
    >
    >
   (http://web.thielert.com/typo3/index.php?id=534&backPID=534&tt_news=1203&L=1
    > )
    > it has dismissed "with cause" company founder Frank Thielert and
    > cancelled his employment contract in light of preliminary
   findings of a
    > criminal investigation into the company's financial affairs. The
   board
    > also dismissed Chief Financial Officer Roswitha Grosser and
   cancelled
    > her contract.
    > _As /AVweb/ reported_
    >
    > earlier, the company has been under investigation for a couple of
   years,
    > and in recent months the German courts have invalidated its
   financial
    > statements from 2003 to 2005. "It is to be assumed that the annual
    > financial statements for the years 2003, 2004 and 2005 are probably
    > incorrect and possibly void," a statement by the supervisory
   board said.
    > Up until late Wednesday, Thielert still had a job as the
   company's chief
    > operating officer, but the recent action and the resulting plunge in
    > share prices to just .43 Euros ? it's traded as high as 25.22 ?
   seem to
    > put the future of the company at stake. A restructuring plan that
    > included selling more shares to raise needed cash is now on hold.
    > "Investors which had intended to support the company in the
    > implementation of the planned restructuring package under certain
    > conditions, have informed the company on April 23, 2008 that they
   are no
    > longer willing to provide such support," the statement reads. "The
    > restructuring measures to deal with the company's liquidity
   crisis, as
    > mentioned in the disclosure announcement of April 9, 2008, therefore
    > cannot be implemented as planned."
    > An investigative report by _Defense Industry Daily_
    >
    >
   (http://www.defenseindustrydaily.com/Thielerts-Troubles-Criminal-Investigations-and-a-Cash-Crunch-04801/)said
    > the criminal investigation revolved around allegations that the
   company
    > had created false invoices and included them as part of their
   accounts
    > receivables to enhance the financial position of the company.
    > *Related Content:*
    > Why is this bad news? Maybe for more reasons than you think.
    > _Editorial Director Paul Bertorelli blogs about it on /AVweb Insider
    >
   (http://www.avweb.com/blogs/insider/AVwebInsiderBlog_ThielertBoardSteamed_197721-1.html)/_
    >
    > I just cut and pasted from the AVWeb site and then included the
   links
    > just in case the mail system does not support the embedded links.
    >
    > Les Nordman


   Diesel (jetA) versus gasoline makes sense over here in Europe: price
   per
   liter (or gallon) and lower consumption per horsepower, makes that
   to make
   it short, the fuel bill per hour is about half with JetA diesel
   Thielert
   engines on DA40 or on C172, than on avgas piston engines.

   Of course this is very a artificial advantage, because all due to state
   taxes which drive avgas to very high price levels, whereas jetA is
   lower
   taxed. As long as governments do not change their policies, this
   advantage
   will remain.

   Over your country, in the US, where "true" market conditions
   prevail, the
   numbers do show that the advantage is far from paying for the
   increase in
   upfront cost at time af engine purchase.

   SIDE QUESTION: rotary engines can run on jetA, with spark ignition
   (no hope
   to get the compression for diesel ignition). The question is: how
   easily can
   an existing rotary engine be converted to jetA. Then next question:
   what
   kind of BSFC can be expected ?

   Thanks for the xperts who will provide answers to these.

   Rgds
   Philippe CHENEVIER (in France)

   Mistral spent a lot of money trying to get a practical diesel fueled
   rotary working. I think they gave up. The engine did not generates as
   much power and the BSFC was no better as I recall. I wish Francois
   would
   give us a final report.

   I also saw the Wankel Gmbh diesel fuel engine run at OSH and at the
   factory
   in Korb. Juergan Bax gave me a bottle of wine with the subject on
   the label.
   I still have it :)
   --
   Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.


   At a 60% increase in cost now, why would anyone want to use diesel?

   By the way I bought an engine 2nd gen 13B.

   Dan

   Does anybody know what the deal is with the cost of diesel? It
   should cost
   less than gasoline. I suspect it's political and that the refiners are
   diverting the available crude to gasoline, instead of diesel, but I
   don't
   know. I know that the refiners are now removing the sulfur from the
   diesel,
   which is a good thing, but I don't know how much that could be
   adding to the
   cost. What's the story?

   Steve Brazil


In the US they are going to pass the new bill for aviation spending.
They are not going to charge user fees instead they are going to up the
Jet A fuel tax. It will be far above mogas and still plenty higher than
100LL. How would the Rotary run on ethanol?

Dan


No problem for the engine. You just need to worry about the plumbing.

Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Copyright 1998-2007 All world wide rights reserved.