Subject: Of Course There Are! RE: Still No Synthetic Lubricant, eh?
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 5/15/2008, 9:17 PM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


I've been using Mobil 1 since 1978 and have spoken at length with the
chemical engineers in the synthetic division at Mobil. Sounds like you
have gotten the trailing end of misplaced history / urban myth. There
have only been 2 issues with Mobil 1, both with the same root cause. In
simple terms, because it is so slippery, it does not suspend
contaminates well... the first was the aviation version. It could not
suspend the lead from 100LL.  Mobil bought many [aviation] engines back and
stopped
producing it [for aviation]. The second is the Ford (International)
PowerStroke diesel.
It has 110v fired injectors that get their primary push from engine
oil... the engine has an oil accumulator of about 3" diameter. The
injectors have such a tight tolerances that if you use Mobil 1 you will
get problems over time from the soot that the oil can't suspend.  My 2
PowerStrokes I used Mobil's Delvac 1 because it is designed to suspend
such contaminates.

My RX-3 loved Mobil 1 almost as much as I loved it :-)

-dave

Synthetic or petroleum based, soot 'control' isn't about base oil, it's
about the dispersant properties of the oil's additive package.  Delvac 1 is
a heavy duty diesel oil and absolutely must handle soot, as must all
compression ignition oils (API Cx - CI-4+, CJ-4, etc.).  Oils formulated for
spark ignition engines (API SL, SM, etc.) don't need nearly the dispersant
capability and don't work as well in diesel engines.  This isn't a problem
with the oil - this is a misapplication.

I suspect that Mazda's preference for petroleum base oils stems from seal
swell issues early man-made synthetics had.  The issues were solved in the
mid 70s, but the 'memory of the pain' lives on longer than the memory of the
cause.

Idemitsu made in the US, like most other oils made in the US, is made
primarily from dewaxed and hydrogen-saturated petroleum oil.  This 'Group
III' oil can be called synthetic in North America, but not Japan or Europe.
The only US companies making synthetic oils from man-made base oils (Group
IV - PAO and Group V ester) are AMSOIL, Exxon-Mobil, and Redline.  All the
rest - including Idemitsu, Royal Purple, and Castrol Syntec are Group III
based.  The US synthetic blends are Group III and petroleum (Group I and/or
Group II).

AMSOIL's XL oils are Group III based.  The rest, except for one of their
heavy duty diesel oils (PCO - a synth blend) are PAO and ester.  The Mobil 1
products (including Delvac 1) are PAO/ester, though some products appear to
contain some amount of Group III in the mix.  Redline is primarily ester
based.  AMSOIL's focus is long drain intervals and low wear.  Exxon-Mobil
appears to be more 'mainstream / typical drain interval'.  Redline isn't
about drain interval as much as it is about racing/extreme heat.  None is
necessarily 'better' than the other - they're shooting at different targets.

A couple of oil companies tried man-made synthetic aircraft piston engine
oils but they all had trouble with formulating products that could handle
the combination of lead and inactivity.  It was less expensive to cut the
liability tail and 'fall back' to the already proven petroleum products and
their 'debugged' additive packages.

Andy Hecker
San Antonio
Retired USAF
Commercial lube tech/oil dealer
QA tech for composite parts manufacturer



The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2008 All world wide rights reserved.