Subject: Of Course There Are! RE: Still No Synthetic Lubricant, eh?
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 5/16/2008, 9:31 AM
To: AAA Put this in the To box



     Paul,
   I wanted to make a quick comment as to our experience with synthetic
   oils.
   We have tested 3-4 oils out of every category this includes 2 Cycle oil,
   Bio Based Oil, Straight and Multi weight oils, as well as synthetic.

   Our engine does run a hotter rotor temp than the Mazda although
   here is what we seen out of synthetics.

   The oil provided great bearing and seal lubrication as well as a
   thin film for sealing the engine. The oil when burnt in the combustion
   process would leave a "concrete" like deposit and this would build on
   the rotor and in tear down and inspection this was next to impossible
   to remove. Our concern was what happens when a small piece of this
   "concrete" like debris lets loose and gets into the rotating assembly.

   Our experience thru testing all the various oils points to one
   oil as the clear winner for our engine and probably for the Mazda
   as well and here it is and here is why.

   This is an email response from our Engine Program Manager

   Eric,

   I did every check you could do for this oil. The obvious reason
   is the 30wt worked so good and Shell was pushing the multigrade,
   we tried it. Engine noise increased as well as heat, both internal
   and cooling system. This test of simply replacing 30wt with 10/40 was
   done several times.

   I have a book written by Chevron oil about many topics, one being
   the year, reason, why, multi weight oils where invented. It's the
   old proverb; you can't get something for nothing. It's widely accepted
   that the gain for using multi weight oils is at sacrifice of bearing
   lubrication. At engine loads it does not stay in contact with bearing
   surface and breaks down under hi heat. The surface film is simply not
   there in a multi grade oil. This is known by the oil community and
   readily available for anyone to read. They admit to why multi grade
   oil was invented.

   Car manufactures put the squeeze on Oil Company's to help with
   gas mileage and start up in all weather conditions. They wanted
   oil that could be used all year. Which it does, but at a sacrifice
   to lubrication.

   The RotaMax engine needs certain qualities for lubrication and
   heat management. The straight weight Rotella provides for the needs.
   It also is very compatible with LP fuels which multi weight is not.
   LP engines generally run higher internal heat.( Combustion )

   The final quality of the straight weight Rotella oil is the
   very high detergent cleaning capability, which the multi weights
   do not possess. Because of the multi weight oil break down, sludge
   is produced. Multi weight has a low flash point which is very bad
   for a charged cooled engine. This produces sludge.

   10/40 or any other multi weight and any brand should not be used
   in a RotaMax engine.

   A link to their website here.

   http://www.shell.com/home/Framework?siteId=rotella-en&FC2=/rotella-en/html/iwgen/products/zzz_lhn.html&FC3=/rotella-en/html/iwgen/products/product_rotellasingle.html
   <http://www.shell.com/home/Framework?siteId=rotella-en&FC2=/rotella-en/html/iwgen/products/zzz_lhn.html&FC3=/rotella-en/html/iwgen/products/product_rotellasingle.html>


   Eric Barger

   RotaMax Inc.

   www.rotamax.net <http://www.rotamax.net>

   Those of us in the aircraft industry are not likely to burn LP.

   The largest problem we have had over the last 38 years is a thick
   carbon build up
   on the rotors. This is something that does not show up in a few
   hours of running.
   I am talking about rotary engines with thousands of hours. Non
   synthetic oils break
   down and form carbon at around 250 degrees F. Synthetics are still alive
   at 450 to 500 F. Mazda Rotors run at 500 F and charge cooled OMC
   engine rotors
   run 600 to 700 F. Also since you have anti-friction roller and ball
   bearings
   throughout your engine I suspect clean burning two cycle oil would
   be ideal.
   Most two cycle engines use anti friction bearings and only two cycle oil
   for lubricating the bearings.

   I will get a sample of the Shell oil and give it our 500 degree F
   oven breakdown test.
   Anybody can run this test. Put a teaspoon worth of oil in a cat food
   can and
   heat it in an oven at 500 F for half an hour.


   Here is one of the original messages dating back to 1998

   -------- Original Message --------
   Subject: Oil Bake Off
   Date: Sun, 13 Sep 1998 00:29:20 -0700
   From: Paul <rotaryeng@earthlink.net <mailto:rotaryeng@earthlink.net>>
   To: bit@any <mailto:bit@any>


     Your not going to believe this Tracy.

   MMO was the worst of the lot. Nothing but thick varnish was left. No
   liquid was left. I also burned a fresh sample and it burned with thick
   black smoke which means a lot of particulates.

   The best I have tried so far has been the Quaker State Universal 2-Cycle
   Engine Oil. Only about 15% of the volume was cooked off. No varnish. The
   oil turned black and thickened slightly but that was about it.

   I set fire to a fresh sample and it burned a little bit like a sparkler
   with very little smoke.

   Rank:
   2 cycle was first
   synthetic was second
   10W30 was third
   and MMO was last.

   Course this is not a definative test. The proof is in
   the using. I can't wait to see the inside of your engine.
   How about borrowing a bore scope and have a look through the big spark
   plug hole. Take your exhaust off and have a look at the center of the
   apex seals.

     If anybody wants to try this please do.

   One teaspoon of oil in the bottom of a cut down cat food
   can, baked in a pre-heated oven at 500 degrees F for one hour. Get ready
   for a stinking kitchen. I would set up ventilation fans as well.


   Paul Lamar

The note was interesting, but one thing not made clear therein as two
different operating requirements were lumped together.  If we combine
lubricating (crankcase) and the rotor cooling (w/fuel from wing
tanks) oil as implied here, the way Mazda/rotomax OEM's use, I suppose
the oil recommendation described makes sense.  If separated, the two
tasks seem to require completely opposing characteristics.

Most of us mix oil/fuel in the wing tanks to cool rotors for many
reasons (lighter, more reliable, safer, etc.).  We want something that
either burns completely or leaves a fine ash that blows away in the
exhaust.  I don?t see how the data suggests an improvement over a
good/cheap 2-cycle oil for our most common need.  Given the data
supplied, MMO seems to be the best for this task?

The boil down test makes sense for crankcase oil that does not see the
combustion chamber, as it must withstand heat breakdown; synthetic
(single weight?) makes the best argument for that task.

MICHAEL D PARKER

Synthetic for the engine and two cycle oil for the apex seals.
IMHO MMO is a fraud.

Paul Lamar

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2008 All world wide rights reserved.