Subject: Zenair 801 motor mount loads.
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 5/30/2008, 7:51 PM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


A little background on our motor mounts for everyone:
Auto engines are designed to be installed in cars and not aircraft.
Unfortunately the Mazda rotary is no exception.

Aircraft engine designers gave some thought on how the engine was  being
installed in aircraft so they provides certain mounting lugs for the
purpose.
These lugs are not found on auto engines. So we must come up with
something
else.

In effect what we are doing is copying the Questair Venture mount.  If
it is good enough for a 500 pound, 600 HP engine and 350 MPH racer  it is
good
enough for me. In effect their long Schertz beam located at the
engine/prop
CG is
a 2 inch diameter 4130 tube. Ours is a stronger 4130 rectangle . 065 wall
3.44
inches wide and 2 inches high. 4130 has the best fatigue  characteristics
of common aircraft materials. The long beam gives room for the  exhaust
system mounted on the left side.

I was very impressed with Questair Venture MM structural design  features
and its low weight to strength ratio. The designer choose not to use
the stock aircraft mounts for good reasons. In fact we use the  same type
and
brand of Barry industrial rubber bushings. The QA engine is  mounted with
only three mounts.
There is a course in structural engineering college called  "redundant
constraint"
and load paths which has to do with why you only need 3 mounts.

People that have flown in QA's say they are one of the smoothest  piston
engine
airplanes. The same guy that designed this mount also designed the  piper
Malibu airplane.

You can read up more about motor mounts on
http://www.rotaryeng.net/motor.html

In the case of the Zenith 801  some of the loads go down that  diagonal
angle
and into the side skin and back to where the landing gear is  attached to
the
fuse.
The angles, with the fuse skins and the motor mount act as a beam.  The fly
in the ointment
is the large hole for the door. All this is so complicated that  only FEA
would
give a better picture.

In any monocoque structure most of the load is taken by the skin.
Wikipedia has a good dissertation on it.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monocoque

The angles are mostly for stiffening the skin against buckling.
In our case the upper (mid) motor mount mainly puts the side and  cowl skin
in
tension and shear and transfers some of the load back up to the  tubes
going to the wing.

The upper (mid) mounts take about 800 pounds each horizontal load  in a 6G
hard landing.
BTW the FAA standard is only 4.5 G's for landing loads. We design  for 6
G's.
The prop torque load of about 600 foot pounds is about 300 pounds  added to
one
rubber bushings and subtracted from the other due to the 2 foot OA  lenght
of
the beam.

The load goes from the 4130 steel brackets (87F-11) into the lateral
beam (8F7-7) assisted by (8F7-1) and then into the skin assisted  by the
angles
marked by red lines. It would be better if the mid mounts were  moved out
board
closer to the skins. See Zenith firewall details jpg.

Of course if the mains hit first the aircraft pitches forward
and the nose gear then takes a lot of the landing loads. If it  hits on the
nose gear first
it takes all the loads and the load path is directly into the  engine by
way of the firewall and motor mount.

The thrust load never approaches those levels. Assume you have max  climb
out
at 100 MPH or 150 FPS. Assume the fixed pitch climb prop is  optimized for
100 MPH and reaches
max efficiency at that speed or about 80%. 250 HP is 137,500 pound  feet
per
second
or 916 pounds potential max thrust at 150 FPS. 80% of that is 733  pounds
of
thrust total.
That is mainly applied to the mid mounts as each one sees half of  that
or only about 366 pounds. At higher speeds the prop thrust drops  of due to
speed.

You won't see max thrust and max load due to a hard landing at the  same
time
so they are not additive. You probably have to drop it in from   five to
ten
feet
or so to see 6 G's.

It would be easier to design these motor mounts  if Zenith  provided scale
dwg's of the firewall
with dimensions for most of the associated  parts.

I am open to suggestions for improvements.

Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.


Doesn't the MM landing impact load depend on compliance of the  landing
gear and tire system?  Stiff gear and small tires might raise the MM
load for a given descent rate?  Just picking nits..


Regards,

Matt-

True but we assume the 6G's are applied to the fuse to be
on the conservative side. It does not add that much weight to
the MM.

BTW I suspect the weak point in the load path is where the lateral  beam
87F-7 is riveted to the diagonal angle. I would add a simple .035"  thick
aluminum patch to the outside of the skin on both sides.
That would pick up the upper horizontal angles.

We ARE asking more from this A/C design using a 250 HP engine.
The original had, at max, a 180 HP 4 cyl A/C engine.
The rotary, at the 250 HP p-port level, is making as much
HP as a much heavier six cylinder A/C engine without the weight
penalty. As such it will make one spectacular STOL without
the fuel burn and cost penalty of a turbo prop engine.
--
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.


Oh wait..  Whether 6g is a realistic load to the MM is dependent on
the compliance of the gear system - for a given sink rate.
Regardless, 6g is probably pretty conservative...  I remember Mike
Melville talking about how the most extreme turbulence he ever has
seen was around 2.5g..  I can buy that since throwing the airplane
swiftly into a 2.5g pull seems like a violent maneuver.  That's
equivalent to enough pull to maintain altitude in a more than 60deg
bank..


Regards,

Matt-

I consider 6G to the engine. In other words the 300 pound
engine/gearbox/prop combination is going to look like it weighs 1800  pounds.
The rest of the aircraft may see more or less. We suggest static
testing the motor mount to that level by using the fuse and main
landing gear as a lever to pick up the front of a car. Perhaps that
is a bit severe. It test everything including the main landing gear  and
the  horz stab :) Jerry tested the Schertz beam by driving a truck up
on it.


Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

That was the old style S-beam.  The new fully boxed beam is surely
much stronger.     Jerry

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2008 All world wide rights reserved.