Subject: Mistral crash caused by exhaust system failure
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 6/6/2008, 10:49 AM
To: AAA Put this in the To box



   The following was posted on the Mistral-Engines web site. It is
   another data point on the very harsh environment of the exhaust
   system, particularly in the NA engines.
   Giff Marr
   LIV-P/Mistral 70%

   More fear than harm
   07 June 2008

   On Tuesday morning, 3rd of June, our test pilot, Mr Stephen Roth,
   took off for a first one-hour flight that went flawlessly. He
   landed at Palatka?s Kay Larkin Field Airport,Florida, to refuel.
   Pre-take-off checks were normal and so was take-off. On initial
   climb, however, the engine started to lose power while still  running
   perfectly smoothly. The pilot performed a 180° turn to return to  the
   airport. The loss of power increased, and the pilot was unable to
   maintain altitude.

   He landed the plane under control and at minimal airspeed in a
   wooded area to avoid buildings and houses. The wings were sheared
   off, one of them staying in a tree, and the fuselage fell sideways
   onto the ground. Coming to his rescue, two courageous citizens
   helped him out of the cockpit conscious and unharmed. There was no
   post-crash fire, only smoke from engine coolant leaking onto the
   heat exhaust.

   MISTRAL Engines is extremely happy and most relieved to announce
   that Stephen Roth suffers only from minor cuts and bruises. After a
   thorough check in the hospital, which proved to be short, he was
   released and able to go back to the site to contribute to the
   beginning FAA enquiry.

   MISTRAL Engines immediately dispatched to the site Mr Gordon
   Anderson, its Chief Operating Officer. On Thursday 5th of June, Mr
   Anderson, Mr Roth and the FAA investigator inspected the plane?s
   wreckage as well as the whole engine data log which was retrieved
   entirely uncompromised from MISTRAL?s proprietary Digital Engine
   Management (DEM) system.

   It was quickly evident that all engine parameters were normal from
   the moment of take-off to the moment of the accident, with the
   exception of abnormally low propeller RPM. The cause of the power
   loss was subsequently found in the failure of the internals of the
   exhaust system?s muffler, obstructing the free flow of exhaust  gases
   from the engine.

   This particular muffler was a temporary and experimental solution
   developed and manufactured by a third party, which was planned to  be
   replaced this coming summer by a certifiable unit, developed
   in-house. The FAA, acting on behalf of the NTSB1
   <ttp://www.mistral-engines.com/Media2/Mistral- News#sdfootnote1sym">,
   retained the muffler in order to conduct flow tests.

   A preliminary report was produced by MISTRAL Engines. It will be
   posted on this website shortly. A final company report will be
   issued after further analysis of the engine is conducted at
   MISTRAL?s facility in Geneva.

   After its pilot emerging unscarred from this mishap, MISTRAL is
   extremely relieved that its technology is proven uninvolved in the
   cause of the accident and that, through the innovative data logging
   capability of its DEM system, it was able to significantly
   contribute to a prompt and thorough determination of the causes.

   MISTRAL Engines is in the process of acquiring a new airframe to
   resume its flight testing programme as soon as possible, and the
   type certification programme of its G-300 engine model continues
   unhindered.

   1
   <ttp://www.mistral-engines.com/Media2/Mistral- News#sdfootnote1anc"> NTSB
   : National Transportation Safety Board


My opinion before reading this report was that one of the external
systems had failed and it is not surprising that it was the exhaust
system because this has happened REPEATEDLY to many rotary powered
aircraft.  It is surprising that it happened to Mistral given their
technical ability.  They certainly do not need advice from me.   However,
I recently tried to tame the mighty rotary exhaust by placing a small
tangential muffler ahead of the regular muffler.  This seemed to work
based on exhaust note on a RotaMax single rotor. No instrumentation  was
available at the time so I am reporting my subjective  evaluation.     It
was quite amazing how tame the exhaust immediately became and without
the creation of any back pressure.  Rotamax kept the prototype for
further experimentation.  I have not heard more.

The system is very compact and light weight.  It will fit inside the
cowl. I can't prove it but I think this system would protect the
internals of down stream mufflers provided they were well made out of
SS.     For the test a FlowMaster (I think) muffler was added to the
tangential.  It was very quiet. The FlowMaster by itself was not quiet
at all.    A smaller all stainless steel muffler such as the Magna  flow
could be used in final configuration. Burns Stainless has some small  and
expensive mufflers that look to be perfect for this application.  We
could easily  make our own.    In addition to cooling  the exhaust gas
and lessening the exhaust pulse another advantage of this system  is
that no muffler is hanging out in the breeze.   Jerry

First photo.  exhaust system is installed upside down to clear  fixture.
engine is running at about 6000 rpm.  You can see how calm it was
working next to the engine.   The only difference for a two rotor  would
be a longer tangential can.   When the tangential system is  installed in
its normal orientation, there is room for a small muffler to hang down
along side the engine.

Jerry Hey

That engine is running no load Jerry. There is a world of difference
between the amount of noise an engine puts out no load compared to  full
load max RPM. Run you car engine up at idle and then listen to it at  full throttle
max RPM during an acceleration run. I am not saying your muffler is  not working.
There is no doubt tangential mufflers work.

However you need to compare noises at max RPM run up with full load  like a prop
or on a dyno. Most of what people hear is the noise at takeoff speeds
and loads. True a lot of it is prop noise.

-- 
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

Yes, everything you say is true.  I wish the engine had been  on the
dyno,  I wish we had a prop on it.  I hope RotaMax  tests it
thoroughly with temp reads on inlet and out let and a lots of hours.
Never the less, if you had been at the initial running, it would be
reasonable to be hopeful.   Jerry

Well plenty of people have run tangential muffler starting with Dr. Porsche
on the prewar VW Beetle and millions have been built since. I think we can conclude
it works. Just don't put anything inside.

There was a special recently on the History Channel about noise.
I should record some of it and post it on youtube.

Believe or not noise is reduced by converting the energy in the noise
to heat. The gases swirling around inside the tang muffler
heat the can walls dissipating the noise.

Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2008 All world wide rights reserved.