Subject: Mistral Crash maybe an exhaust problem
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 6/7/2008, 5:20 PM
To: AAA Put this in the To box



       > A Piper Arrow powered by a prototype Mistral
       > ( http://www.mistral-engines.com/ ) rotary aircraft engine crashed
       > after the
       > engine lost power following takeoff from Palatka Municipal-Lt. Kay
       > Larkin



I did the collapsed muffler deal at Sebring years back. The Flowmaster
(big suitcase looking thing) had all of the baffles piled up against the
rear outlet. The muffler swelled up like a giant pillow and the power
dropped off to nearly nothing. It didn't hurt the engine at all and we
raced at West Palm Beach the next weekend.

Lynn E. Hanover


Since you brought up the subject Lynn it is time to revisit the proper way of welding
the exhaust pipes to the exhaust flange.

The weld must be around the inside of the flange and not on the outside.
Even better is to have a non welded ball joint where the pipe joins the flange
like this early Steve Beckham and Everette Hatch Power Sport configuration.
That allows the exhaust system to expand and contract without stressing the joint.

http://www.rotaryeng.net/flange-welding.html

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Well now we know it had something to do with the muffler.
When I first saw these pictures I did not pay too much attention
as I thought it was made from Inconel.

On hindsight I can see several mistakes made by Mistral. Some of which may be moot
if constructed from Inconel. It might work as is if constructed out of Inconel.

First, was the two pipes were welded on the wrong side of the flange.
http://www.rotaryeng.net/flange-welding.html
We had a rotary powered Velocity crash because of this.

Second, a lot of trouble went into building a slip joint into the two piece inner can
and then the two clips were rosette welded to the outer can defeating the purpose
of making the inner can two pieces. Also one EGT can be higher than the other so there
will be distortions.

I always tell people NOT to put ANYTHING into the inner can as it will melt
for sure. Heck my C182 spit its guts out of the can on the ramp at Valdez and the EGT's
are only 1400 F and not 1800 F. One of my pax saw it and freaked out.
I said; "Not to worry we don't need that part." :)

Tom Jordans Limo EZ back in 2003 had a similar muffler to this one. You could stand
behind the prop and look directly into the can at full chat through the down pipe.
The inner stuff was white hot... almost transparent. Only a matter of time for that
to melt and be spit out through the prop. It could have hit me in the eye and
blinded me. Stupid stunt.

Since most people do not want to pay a $1,000 or $2,000 for an Inconel muffler
make the hollow can out of .065 inch thick 321 SS and let it go at that.
-- 
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.


Paul--Thank you for beating the drum regarding the unique demands of rotary
aircraft engine exhaust systems.
We cannot overemphasize the homework, diligence and precaution required in
this area to provide flight safety.

When Everett and I started our rotary aircraft engine dyno and flight test
program we had 70 combined years of engine and racing experience--including
some with rotary powered race cars--yet we were totally unprepared for what
we found with rotary aircraft engine exhaust systems.

Based on that experience, we concluded the combined performance,  size, and
safety demands imposed on rotary aircraft exhaust components are unique in
the four-cycle world.  The rotary aircraft engine demands a low back
pressure system that is compact, light, durable, with a pleasing exhaust
note, will fit inside various cowlings/airframes, and operate safety at
sustained high output for hours on end.  We know we can do one or more of
these things.  But to do them all....it is an order of magnitude.  Our
ultimate success with safe high performance rotary aircraft engines will
depend on it.  It is a work in progress.

Simply put, this is an issue that can kill you any number of ways and none
are pretty.

Due to the factors you have presented, the many factors involved in rotary
aircraft engine exhast systems are not simple.
We are all collectively on the learning curve.

It may be old news, but here are some of the basic things regarding exhaust
system design, construction and components we learned in our 12 year rotary
aircraft engine program.

1. Traditional automotive components, designs, materials and construction
would fail.  They did not work due to a plethora of  factors you have
explained.

2.  Systems developed for reciprocating and rotating piston/Mazda engine
race cars, and reciprocating aircraft engines, were not transferrable and
were not usable for numerous reasons.  Even with rotary engine race cars the
duration of high engine output/exhaust energy with the pedal down and and
staying there is generally measured in seconds down the straight and between
curves.  Ours in aircraft are measured in hours by comparison.  We don't
lift our foot for corners.

3. Even on dyno runs (these maxiumum output runs lasted minutes not hours)
we had top of the line mufflers puff up like a ballon and eventually assume
that appearance permanently--and crack. We modified a top of the line
Flowmaster for flight tests with a front section and baffles of 600 series
SS/Inconel.  Performance and sound quality was excellent due to combination
of volume, design,and low back pressure. But it had too many flat sections
and the rear (unmodified portion standard) deteriorated in a relatively
short time and blew up like a baloon.

4.  Learned to avoid flat sections in all components due to vibration and
cracking. The obvious exception was the flange and we found we didn't have
to use Inconel for those (321 was ok).  But Inconel or equivalent was
required for pipe sections close to out of the port and front section of the
muffler sections.  SS 321 could be made to work but requires a thicker,
heavier pipe section that adds weight.  Inconel just stronger and better in
every way.  The Inconel with the thinner wall has superior overall high
temperature performance--strength, creep, fatigue and temperature.

5. Learned to beware of cantilevered components and keep moment arms short

6. Exhaust pipes joined to other pipes/ports without special provision for
expansion would always ultimately crack  The only way we could make it work
to weld a pipe directly to an exhaust flange was to make it a stub pipe that
was very short with bellows or slip or swivel joint (swivel preferred but
most difficult) incorporated as close to, or as part of, the flange and port
insert.  We did use some Inconel bellows but really liked the simplicity,
funtionality and cost effectiveness of simple slip joints.

7. Anything we put inside a muffler would  be broken and pieces spit out
downstream eventually unless it was an open chamber muffler with properly
designed and constructed internal sections fully supported with 600 series
stainless (Inconel,etc) used in the front sections directly exposed to the
flame and pulse.

8. The use of Inconel and other  600 series stainless materials assured
nothing if other design factors was overlooked.  Early on we experienced
failures even with Inconel tubing  up to .100 wall

9. We learned never to assume that because it has worked for "x" hours that
it is an infinite life piece or assembly

10. In simple terms, we learned to visualize a violent percussive supersonic
blowtorch/hammer of 1600-1700 degrees turning metal translucent coming out
of the ports of the engine, pointed directly at a plastic cowling,
structure, wiring, fuel lines, and some cases even propeller.

Regarding this last point, some year back I flew back to Kansas and
inspected a beautiful, newly-built Velocity RG with a rotary engine and
three-blade MT prop.  The workmanship and features of this airframe were
beautiful.  It was a stunner, capable of winning Oshkosh.  It was built by a
great guy and the work and expense that had gone into it was clear.  It had
not yet flown but ran well and he was down to just fixing a few minor
glitches before the first flight.  Several things about the exhaust system
made me very nervous and told him so and why.  Later I heard it was lost on
its first flight due to exhaust system failure.  Looking at some of your
exhaust file photos it appears that it may be one of the examples you use.
Very sad.

Steve Beckham

They fixed it Steve and it is still flying.

Paul Lamar

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2008 All world wide rights reserved.