Hello Paul,
I contacted Mazdatrix about paying them to run a bunch of sweeps on
various length manifolds to replicate the TIMS on the R26B for my car
project on a p-port RX-8 engine. I had a troubling conversation with
Don/Dave? about the dyno runs you posted versus what he said they really
were from an air density calculation error they encountered. He said
some other things about rough running, intense fuel column flow, etc.
and seemed upset with you over your supposedly not reposting the correct
dyno graphs and misleading people about p-porting RX-8 housings. Suffice
it to say you two have conflicting stories on what the final outcome of
this all is. However as someone who has been around the block I
understand there is always two sides to a story. I am not passing
judgement until I hear what you have to say about this but it seemed a
pretty damning acusation. It should be noted that he didnt come out and
start slamming you. He seemed reluctant to talk about the situation at
first other than saying it was a waste of time and he had no interest in
the system. So could you fill me in on what the situation is on this. I
am very interested in taking this setup to the street and later applying
it to a 4 rotor setup but if I have been misled then I would appreciate
notice that this is the case to avoid wasting money.
Thank you,
Rob Woods
Yes he did notify me of the error after a a period of time but I did
not feel it was worth correcting the data on youtube. 150 HP is probably
no problem so I have been quoting that number lately. We got about that
on a
13B p-port on the same dyno so I felt 150 HP at 7500 RPM was no problem
for
an RX8 p-port engine with a 17% larger exhaust port area and a higher
compression ratio. For aircraft use plus or minus 10 HP in a 250 HP engine
is hardly noticeable as it will barely affect the top speed. You might be
able to measure it in climb rate. The aircraft engine runs in a much
narrower
RPM range than most car engines. HP below 7500 with a fixed pitch prop is
of no interest. What one is more concerned with is fuel burn at cruise
RPM's of 4500 to 6000 RPM. HP with a fixed pitch prop is way way down
at those RPM's.
At $650 a day for dyno time I cannot afford to spend days tuning the
engine
to a fare thee well. Especially since all we had a was a Weber carb to
work
with which I felt was a bit on the small side. Also it is not possible to
lean
the Weber carb while the engine is running. The fuel burn and mixture
ratio was
all over the map indicating to me the Weber was not coping well with the
tuned manifold. Air flows both in AND out of a carb with a tuned manifold.
I will re run the test when I get the right aircraft carbs on there.
For the fuel injection guys that is no problem as all you have to do
is change the mixture look up table.
Perhaps this is not what one would want for a car race engine anyway. One
should
be interested in what it will put out at 11,000 RPM and the max torque RPM
so one can change the gear ratios to suit. With enough gears in the gear
box the range can be narrower. In a Formula One engine it is 17,00 to
19,000
as I recall.
I had no need to run a bunch of test with different length runners as I
already
have that data from Mazda. We tried two different lengths on the 13B
p-port
to correlate the data with the Lemans engine data. It correlated well
as we copied the Lemans tuning.
Dave was very impressed/concerned by the intense fuel column flow but I
have seen that many times before starting in 1965 and I know the cause.
It is a byproduct of any tuned manifold. Dave has limited experience with
tuned p-port manifolds as that is not normally done on SCCA car race
engines.
In fact I invented the ram air box on the Chaparral 2D to contain it. All
professional race cars now use ram air boxes when allowed by the rules.
Dave has never been a fan of p-port engines and they are outlawed
in most SCCA racing classes. Jim Mederer of Racing Beat has said the same
thing to me. The urban myth was p-ports were no good for street
cars or road racing below 8,000 RPM. Mazda themselves proved that
was not the case with the Lemans winning engine. So did the early
Power Sport guys, Steve Beckham and Everett Hatch. Their p-port engine
was tuned for about 6000 RPM and archived about 215 HP in later
versions. It is all a matter of tuning the intake manifold correctly.
There is another factor and that is how the dyno is operated.
Most car dyno operators do "sweeps". For aircraft engines that is not what
we want. We want to see how much HP the engine will generate
at a steady 7500 RPM and what is the fuel burn at reduced prop load
at 5000 RPM. A prop dyno is better suited to aircraft operating
conditions.
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
That is correct Paul. We were able to produce 180+ horsepower at 5500 rpm
on early engines using smaller diameter 1 9/16" diameter runners shown in
our "out-across-over and back" configuration from the plenum to the
peripheral ports which you show in some of your photos. Subsequent engines
used larger diameter intake runners of same length for higher h.p. Per your
notes, all our experience correlates to published Mazda data. For length,
we basically used the longest runner length we could reasonably fit in the
RV-3 and 4 cowlings. We tested many different diameter and length
combinations on the dynos.
Regarding carbs, on the prototype Powersport engines we did test fly a
Weber/Holly carb and tested Mikuni carbs on the dyno on the first engine but
these made less power and tractability was not as good (such as on short
final approaches and other changes in throttle setting) than our first fuel
injection system which had a homemade servo and the rest Hillborn based fuel
injection pieces in the constant flow system. Subsequent engines all used
constant flow fuel injection with a venturi that Evertt designed for the
plenum inlet for signal and Don Rivera's Airflow Performance fuel-servo
controller which worked flawlessly. When we used direct injection in the
rotor housings we used vented nozzles which Don supplied. These were vented
back in to the induction tubes. When we went to nozzle locations outboard
of the throttles we could use unvented nozzles.
Your photos show the above configuration with linkage inter-connect to the
throttles and controller/servo. This is the same system we built for the
current airplane not yet flown and Don has all the pieces now to test and
callibrate the controller.
Recommend Dave contact Don Rivera on automotive applications as well. Don
is a great guy and protege of the guy who designed and developed the
original Bendix fuel injection system. Don is a gold mine of expertise with
experience as far as I know the only manufacturer with extensive expertise
on both aircraft and automotive engines--both rotary and reciprocating
engines. Sean Tucker and other top sticks all use his stuff.
Don't know what effect placing our throttles in the port insert in the rotor
housings; that was the only configuration we ever tested on our peripheral
port engines. The first engine in 1988 used prototype dual side ports
(aluminum housings) with 14 and 16" runners (were too short) from a plenum
atop engine with throttles/shafts mounted in intake tubes leading to plenum.
This engine made 200 hp @ 7,000 and that is what led us to configure all
subsequent engines with peripheral ports which were a lot smaller and more
conservative than race car engines and modest sized, long runners to develop
rated power at low rpm. Up to that point we knew of no high performance
automotive rotary engine builders doing anything similar to this
configuration and such low target rpm and horsepower combination.
Steve Beckham
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2008 All world wide rights reserved.