Subject: P-Port Renesis Housings
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 6/9/2008, 12:01 PM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


>
> Hello Paul,
>
> I contacted Mazdatrix about paying them to run a bunch of sweeps on
> various length manifolds to replicate the TIMS on the R26B for
> my car
> project on a p-port RX-8 engine. I had a troubling conversation with
> Don/Dave? about the dyno runs you posted versus what he said
> they really
> were from an air density calculation error they encountered. He said
> some other things about rough running, intense fuel column flow, etc.
> and seemed upset with you over your supposedly not reposting the
> correctdyno graphs and misleading people about p-porting RX-8
> housings. Suffice
> it to say you two have conflicting stories on what the final
> outcome of
> this all is. However as someone who has been around the block I
> understand there is always two sides to a story. I am not passing
> judgement until I hear what you have to say about this but it
> seemed a
> pretty damning acusation. It should be noted that he didnt come
> out and
> start slamming you. He seemed reluctant to talk about the
> situation at
> first other than saying it was a waste of time and he had no
> interest in
> the system. So could you fill me in on what the situation is on
> this. I
> am very interested in taking this setup to the street and later
> applyingit to a 4 rotor setup but if I have been misled then I
> would appreciate
> notice that this is the case to avoid wasting money.
>
> Thank you,
>
> Rob Woods
>
>
> Yes he did notify me of the error  after a a period of time
> but I did
> not feel it was worth correcting the data on youtube. 150 HP is
> probablyno problem so I have been quoting  that number
> lately. We got about that on a
> 13B p-port on the same dyno so I felt 150 HP at 7500 RPM was no
> problem for
> an RX8 p-port engine with a 17% larger exhaust port area and a higher
> compression ratio. For aircraft use plus or minus 10 HP in a 250
> HP engine
> is hardly noticeable as it will barely affect the top speed. You
> might be
> able to measure it in climb rate. The aircraft engine runs in a
> much narrower
> RPM range than most car engines. HP below 7500 with a fixed
> pitch prop is
> of no interest. What one is more concerned with is fuel burn at cruise
> RPM's of 4500 to 6000 RPM. HP with a fixed pitch prop is way way down
> at those RPM's.
>
> At $650 a day for dyno time I cannot afford to spend days tuning
> the engine
> to a fare thee well. Especially since all we had a was a Weber
> carb to work
> with which I felt was a bit on the small side. Also it is not
> possible to lean
> the Weber carb while the engine is running. The fuel burn and
> mixture ratio was
> all over the map indicating to me the Weber was not coping well
> with the
> tuned manifold. Air flows both in AND out of a carb with a tuned
> manifold.I will re run the test when I get the right aircraft
> carbs on there.
> For the fuel injection guys that is no problem as all you have
> to do
> is change the mixture look up table.
>
> Perhaps this is not what one would want for a car race engine
> anyway. One should
> be interested in what it will put out at 11,000 RPM and the max
> torque RPM
> so one can change the gear ratios to suit. With enough gears in
> the gear
> box the range can be narrower. In a Formula One engine it is
> 17,00 to 19,000
> as I recall.
>
> I had no need to run a bunch of test with different length
> runners as I already
> have that data from Mazda. We tried two different lengths on the
> 13B p-port
> to correlate the data with the Lemans engine data. It correlated well
> as we copied the Lemans tuning.
>
> Dave was very impressed/concerned  by the intense fuel
> column flow but I
> have seen that many times before starting in 1965 and I know the
> cause.It is a byproduct of any tuned manifold. Dave has limited
> experience with
> tuned p-port manifolds as that is not normally done on SCCA car
> race engines.
> In fact I invented the ram air box on the Chaparral 2D to
> contain it. All
> professional race cars now use ram air boxes when allowed by the
> rules.
> Dave has never been a fan of p-port engines and they are outlawed
> in most SCCA racing classes. Jim Mederer of Racing Beat has said
> the same
> thing to me. The urban myth was p-ports were no good for street
> cars or road racing below 8,000 RPM. Mazda themselves proved that
> was not the case with the Lemans winning engine. So did the early
> Power Sport guys, Steve Beckham and Everett Hatch. Their p-port engine
> was tuned for about 6000 RPM and archived about 215 HP in later
> versions. It is all a matter of tuning the intake manifold correctly.
>
> There is another factor and that is how the dyno is operated.
> Most car dyno operators do "sweeps". For aircraft engines that
> is not what
> we want. We want to see how much HP the engine will generate
> at a steady 7500 RPM and what is the fuel burn at reduced prop load
> at 5000 RPM. A prop dyno is better suited to aircraft operating
> conditions.
>
> Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

I watched the F1 race in Montreal this weekend.  The top RPM shown on TV
indicated 19,000 RPM that is for most of the cars.

On the personal side.  If Mazda is capable of producing a PP B26
running it for 24 hours.  Then one should not be concerned if a PP
engine will or will not work.  It has already been done.  It is only a
matter of adjustments not a waste of time.

Marc Joseph


The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2008 All world wide rights reserved.