Subject: Diesel Myths? RE: Efficiency in the CAFE... RE: 16B
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 6/16/2008, 5:17 PM
To: AAA Put this in the To box



I was in a town hall at a Major OEM - someone asked  if we could meet the meet the proposed new CAFE numbers - the rep said nope, it was not possible. I already had the Mic to ask my question - when will they sell the wonderful cars they make for the rest of the world that get well north of 60 mpg here ? (diesel compacts) - He said "What ? Diesel?  No, Americans don't want these cars." There is the preception near the glass ceiling that we are all happy to drive our 15 mpg SUV's    They only way this will change is buyer feed back with pocket book and letters.

David Arbogast

That may be the CEO perception but there are concrete reasons why
that is not happening here. It has to do with the cost of reducing NOX.

There is a NOX limit in this country. According to Bruce Briggs in his book
"The
War Against the Automobile" the NOX limit was entirely unnecessary as it
takes both
HC and NOX to form smog. Kill one or the other and you kill smog. NOX
by it self is not noxious.

Our Congress, in their infinite wisdom and lack of engineering
understanding,
killed both and in the process effectively killed the diesel and lean
burn engines. You, my friends, have been paying for this since about
1975 or 1980. You cannot trust lawyers to do the right thing. Vote
carefully.
Vote for engineers :)

Also, I might add, the particulate filters required to trap the black
smoke from a diesel apply back pressure to the engine reducing
the efficiency. At Le Mans, where particulate filters are required,
that did not matter as the rules were adjusted to favor the diesel
regardless of the fuel burn.
-- 
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.



Paul - VW and Benz and GM and Ford and Dodge are all selling on-road diesel
vehicles in most of the 47 states east of you.  Some of the states in the NE
have adopted CARB recommendations, so they have to import 'used' vehicles
with about 7500 miles on them...but they're out here.

Yes - NOX is an issue.  In my '97 VW diesel the ECU programming is modified
relative to its European brothers and sisters - one of the changes is
retarded injection timing.  Power is down a bit (90 vs. about 105) but so is
NOX.  The cooled EGR helps NOX as well, and the catalytic converter takes
care of CO.

One of the (many!) challenges with biodiesel, BTW, is that while it lowers
CO - most of which is 'current production' carbon - it raises NOX output.

Yes - folks in the US have a bad taste in their mouth (punny...) after GMs
'diesels' of the '70s.  But cars are sold in the US on power and sex...and a
VW Lupo has neither...but is (well, was) a great 'city car' that gave around
70 MPG...with no batteries and no hybrid electronics.

http://www.usatoday.com/money/consumer/autos/mareview/mauto497.htm
"...VW markets a variety of Lupos, none intended for the USA because of
their tiny size and lack of power..."

 VW and Benz are both selling 2009 model diesels that are 50-state legal -
meeting the most stringent emissions requirements in the world and the same
for gas- and diesel-powered on road vehicles.

 Andy Hecker


Yes but are they cost effective given the increase price of diesel fuel
and combined with the increase cost of the direct injection and the need and cost to
refill the urea tanks and the cost of the particulate filter in
the exhaust? I don't think so. Combine that with the scarcity of diesel stations.

How many have they sold and what do they cost to buy?

Give me the numbers not just the PR.

Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2008 All world wide rights reserved.