Formula One 1 engine technology is pressing the current power
to weight ratio advantage of the rotary.
Currently a NA 3 rotor P-port running about 11,000 RPM is
generating about 550 HP as a guess. Bare block weight is 260 pounds.
Back in the 1980's the NA P-port two rotor had no problem
generating about 300 HP at about 9000 RPM while weighing
200 pounds (bare block weight) with cast iron end and center housings.
Aluminum irons could cut that weight to about 150 pounds.
On the other hand formula one tech has approached that
power to weight ratio advantage. Of course rotaries
are outlawed in Formula 1 but that is neither here nor there
for this discussion. They should be allowed to reap the advantages
of the huge amounts of engine development money generated in Formula 1
http://www.pureluckdesign.com/ferrari/f1engine/
"A time traveler from 50 years ago would find today's Formula 1 cars
radically different, but would be equally surprised at the relative
lack of change in engine technology. Turbochargers have come and
gone and there hasn't been a switch to two-stroke or rotary, scotch
yoke engines - let alone to gas turbines or something not even invented
in 1950. The good old four-stroke internal combustion engine powered the
very first Grand Prix car in 1906 and lives on in a form instantly
recognizable by any time-traveling engineers from 1950."
"The power output of the four-stroke internal combustion engine
is a function of the torque seen at its flywheel and the speed
at which that flywheel spins."
"The increase in performance of the current 3.0-liter engines
is purely a function of faster flywheel (crankshaft) speed."
"To attain 800hp, a current Fl engine must turn in the region
of 17,000rpm, which means its peak power bmep roughly equals
that of the 1967 DFV."
"Since 1998, Ilmor has manufactured pistons from an aluminum-beryllium
alloy, thereby reducing their weight by a third, possibly more,
and gaining enhanced thermal conductivity."
End of quotes.
How can we get the speed of the rotary up to 17,000 or 19,000
RPM? If you can't beat them join them in the switch to
aluminum-beryllium alloy (ABA) for the rotor. That is the key.
http://www.reade.com/Products/Alloys/aluminum_beryllium_alloy_al_be.html
ABA density is .076 pounds per cubic inch while that of cast iron
is .3 pounds per cubic inch. The current nine pound rotor is cast iron.
.076/.3 is .25 so an ABA rotor would weigh about 2.28 pounds or less
as ABA is stronger than cast iron.
The limit to the RPM in a rotary is the centrifugal load on
the rotor bearing.
Load = mV^2/r
r drops out for equal size engines.
V is proportional to RPM so 11,000 squared is 121 million.
m is proportional to weight so 9# X 121,000,000 is 1089,000,000.
So 1089 million is our load target.
Load = 1,089,000,000 = 9# X RPM1^2 = 2.28# X RPM2^2
or 1089,000,000 / 2.28 = RPM2^2 = 544500000
So 1089/2.28 = RPM^2 = 477,663,1578
The new RPM = the square root of 477,663,1578 or 23,334 RPM!!!
HP is proportional to RPM so my guess is
23,334/11,000 X 550 or 1,167 HP for a NA P-port 3 rotor!!!!!
Same rotor bearing load.
Of course the rotary would still be a lot cheaper than
a Formula 1 engine as there are not a lot of the other
high tech expensive parts such as titanium rods and pneumatic valves.
Turbo compound would be easier as now we are really getting
up to turbine RPM speeds.
Sure we don't need 1000 HP in our passenger cars but the point is
you can make the engine much much smaller hybrid or otherwise and
still get enough HP.
That drastically cuts the size and weight of the car improving the MPG.
Bob W please check my arithmetic.
-
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
Good thinking.
Just looking at the math, since Force is M * acc, and with constants
removed F = M *n^2
If mass M1 is .25 M, reduced by a factor of 4 , n1^2 is allowed to go up
by a factor of 4 for equal force.
So n = sqrt of n^2 or n1 = sqrt of 4 = 2n,
If the first n with cast iron rotor is 11,000 rpm the new n1 with BAB
rotors is 22,000 rpm, roughly. (depending on the exact weight ratio)
Wonder what BAB will cost compared to 'standard' Al alloys, or compared
to the presently used cast iron rotors.
The thermal stability of cast iron is higher than that of Al-alloys. ABA
would have to be closer to cast iron to take the beating in the Rotary
engine.
Rolf
Thanks Rolf.
I think you mean ABA instead of BAB? Aluminum-Bryllium Alloy
is closer to cast iron than aluminum.
Paul Lamar
Paul,
I have used Be-38AL alloy that is now sold as AlBeMet162 by BrushWellman.
The following link will give you very good material properties data.
http://www.berylliumproducts.com/Attributes.aspx?id=AlBeMet162
The main issue would be wear in the apex seal and corner seal areas (would
need a hardened insert). The side clearances would also have to be looser,
as this grows more than cast iron. On the up side, the coefficient of heat
transfer is very good. This would make charge cooling more effective for
those engines, and oil cooling more effective on Mazda style.
And boy would these be expensive parts.....
Although.... it tig welds very nicely, so a multi part rotor could be made
and welded together.....
Anyone with a big pot of money? :)
Larry
Agreed and all good observations. Not something we can do but certainly
within what Mazda can do. Thanks also for the fabrication tips.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
I think an immediate application for this would be a UAV engine with
turbo compound. Even using iron end housing the stock Mazda engine would
be 20 pounds lighter or so. The counter weights would be lighter if the
rotors were only 2.28 pounds each.
Larry,
Possibly the apex seal slots could be chrome plated if AlBeMet162 can be
chromed.
In fact somebody ought to try chrome plating the stock Mazda apex seal
slots.
I think that ought to extend the life of the rotors when used with silicon
nitride apex seals.
--
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
Paul and George,
Race Engine magazine (out of England) just had an article on the Mazda 4
rotor. Their speculation is a 4 rotor built using today's technology would
dominate lemans racing. Our brain trust here believe the same. If we only
had that big pot of money for engine development and a bigger pot of money
to pay off the officials to make it legal....
On the BeAL parts, there is probably 5k work of material in a pair of
rotors. The chrome plating of the grooves could probably be done, just have
to work on getting the surface prep correct for adhesion. The chromed apex
seal grooves has been done by Mazda before, I believe in the 24 hour Le Mans
engine.
Larry
There were at least three AER engines in the race. None of them did very well.
The best was 56 laps down. Don't believe everything you read in magazines :)
The Mazda AER finished near last. Not on this list. What dominated was the 5 L and up V12 diesels
with 600 to 700 foot pounds of torque thanks to the rules that severely
handicapping gasoline engines.
The Judd was the best gas engine in LMP1 but was 19 laps
down at the end. The track is about 7 or 8 miles per lap so that is 133 to 152
miles back. In LMP2 it was the Porsche RS Spyder in what was left of LMP2.
The Porsche is using some Formula 1 tech as it is turning rather high
RPM's for a 3.5 L engine.
Even at the last month or so before the race they added at least 100 pounds ballast to
the gasoline LMP2 cars causing several major teams to tell them to stuff it. All
the gasoline powered cars were many laps back at the end while the two diesel
teams were on the same lap. The Aston Martin GT1 beat many LMP2 cars.
1. Capello/McNish/Kristensen Audi Sport North America Audi R10 TDi 24hr 00m 24.085s LMP1 381 laps
2. Gene/Minassian/Villeneuve Team Peugeot Total Peugeot 908 HDi +4m 31.094s LMP1
3. Klien/Montagny/Zonta Peugeot Sport Total Peugeot 908 HDi +2 laps LMP1
4. Luhr/Premat/Rockenfeller Audi Sport Team Joest Audi R10 TDi +7 laps LMP1
5. Lamy/Sarrazin/Wurz Team Peugeot Total Peugeot 908 HDi +13 laps LMP1
6. Biela/Pirro/Werner Audi Sport North America Audi R10 TDi +14 laps LMP1
7. Primat/Tinseau/Treluyer Pescarolo Sport Pescarolo 07-Judd +19 laps LMP1
8. Groppi/Ayari/Duval Team ORECA Matmut Courage-ORECA LC70-Judd +24 laps LMP1
9. Mucke/Charouz/Enge Charouz Racing System Lola-Aston Martin +27 laps LMP1
10. van Merkstein/Verstappen/Bleekemolen van Merksteijn Motorsport Porsche RS Spyder +27 laps LMP2
11. Ickx/Gregoire/Barbosa Rollcentre Racing Pescarolo 04-Judd +29 laps LMP1
12. Neilsen/Elgaard/Maassen Team Essex Porsche RS Spyder +34 laps LMP2
13. Brabham/Turner/Garcia Aston Martin Racing Aston Martin DBR9 +37 laps GT1
14. O'Connell/Magnussen/Fellows Corvette Racing Corvette C6.R +37 laps GT1
15. Beretta/Gavin/Papis Corvette Racing Corvette C6.R +40 laps GT1
16. Frentzen/Wendlinger/Piccini Aston Martin Racing Aston Martin DBR9 +42 laps GT1
17. Alphand/Policand/Moreau Luc Alphand Aventures Corvette C6.R +46 laps GT1
18. Ragues/Lahaye/Cheng Saulnier Racing Pescarolo 06-Judd +48 laps LMP2
19. Melo/Salo/Bruni Risi Competizione Ferrari F430 GT +55 laps GT2
20. Amaral/Pla/Smith Quifel-ASM Lola B05/40-AER +56 laps LMP2
21. Goueslard/Blanchemain/Pasquali Luc Alphand Aventures Corvette C6.R +56 laps GT1
22. Malucelli/Ruberti/Babini BMS Scuderia Italia Ferrari F430 GT +63 laps GT2
23. Kaffer/Nielsen/Ehret Farnbacher Racing Ferrari F430 GT +64 laps GT2
24. Hall/Goossens/Mowlem Creation AIM Creation CA07-AIM +65 laps LMP1
25. Ferte/Aucott/Daoudi JMB Ferrari F430 GT +69 laps GT2
26. Nicolet/Hein/Faggionato Saulnier Racing Pescarolo 05-Judd +70 laps LMP1
27. Davison/Henzler/Felbermayr Felbermayr-Proton Porsche 997 GT3 RSR +72 laps GT2
28. Bouchut/Bornhauser/Smet Larbre Competition Saleen S7-R +75 laps GT1
29. Barazi/Vergers/Moseley Barazi Epsilon Zytek 07S-Zytek +77 laps LMP2
30. Menten/Fittipaldi/Borcheller Team Modena Aston Martin DBR9 +79 laps GT1
31. Rostan/Devlin/Jeannette Bruichladdich Radical Radical SR9-AER +84 laps LMP2
32. Bergmeister/van Overbeek/Neiman Flying Lizard Motorsport Porsche 997 GT3 RSR +92 laps GT2
33. Itoh/Tachikawa/Kataoka Dome Racing Team Dome S102-Judd +109 laps LMP1
34. Kox/Rusinov/Hezemans IPB Spartak Racing Lamborghini Murcielago GTR +115 laps GT1-
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2008 All world wide rights reserved.