Subject: Higher power for your rotary.]
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 6/18/2008, 10:20 AM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


      How much Beryllium is in the compound?  I used to use BeCu in a high
      pressure system.  No special precautions were taken when
   machining and
      berylliosis risk was well know by the machine shop.  If they were
      machining beryllium, it was a big deal.  BeCu typically has 1-2% Be
      content.

      Bob W

   Bob the BeAl alloy lists Beryllium at 60-63% with the remnant AL. That
   is not
   an insignificant amount! While this material is interesting for it's
   lightness, it
   hardly seems worth the other risks. This isn't like the idoicy about
   Asbestos
   where a 20 year exposure might cause problems. The idiots cleaning up
   asbestos
   in hasmat suits are protecting their phony-baloney jobs. Beryllium
   is PROVEN
   to cause serious effects, and any sagnifigant unprotected exposure to
   the dust
   can cause FATAL lung disease. Good reasons to avoid using it unless
   nothing
   else will do. A braised lightweight rotor in steel could still cut the
   weight and not
   need any special handling. Detonation gun coatings for aluminum side
   plates and
   diamond grinding sound like childs play by comparison. And we KNOW that
   they
   work! Mazda has even provided the type of materials in the LeMans engine
   paper.
   Hell the aluminum side plates would lighten the 2 rotor by 20 pounds and
   the 3
   rotor by a lot more than that. Since we don't really need more than
   7,500 RPM
   and that doesn't tax the standard e-shaft and rotors why bother? We
   already
   have a means of doing these things that has been tested in 24 hours of
   RACING
   use. Seems a better way to lighten things up than working in a expensive
   alloy
   unproven for our use, that...oh by the way might KILL us! I think
   some focus
   would be a good idea here. And lastly lets re-state what sent us down
   this road
   Current F1 engines are now approaching the power density of a rotary by
   reving
   to 19,000 RPM! And for some reason we might want to stress our
   engines in a
   similar way? Just using P-ports and aluminum end plates it might take F1
   another
   20 years to catch up! it might be real fun to compare HP per dollar!
   Bill Jepson


   Your are missing the point here Bill. This is not about a light
   weight A/C engine. It is about high RPM and HP. The rotor weight
   controls RPM. In order to double the RPM and HP one must reduce
   the rotor weight to 25% of it current 9 pound weight. You are not going
   to do that with an all steel rotor. A current 2.5 L Formula 1 engine
   is putting out 900 HP at 19,000 RPM while weighing about 125 KG
   or about 275 pounds. You are not going to get 900 HP out of
   a NA 2.6 L P-port 13B at 11,000 RPM no matter how light weight it is.
   You would be real lucky to see 350 HP. This is the current rational
   among the anti rotary crowd. They don't see the need for the rotary.
   Without
   respect for the rotary there will be no rotary engines made.
   Unfortunately
   displacement is still a yard stick for engine performance in car racing.

   Yes certain precautions need to be taken in making aluminum-beryllium
   alloy parts  but it has and is being done done. Certain parts in
   satellites
   and other things are made from aluminum-beryllium alloy as well as
   pistons.
   Once the piston  is in the engine there is no exposure to dust.

   IMHO you are over reacting here. If we really wanted to do something
   to reduce carcinogens in the air how about starting with black smoke
   from diesel engines? Especially school bus engines.

   --
   Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.



Paul,  What is the material and weight of Mistrals rotors?

On another slightly different note, I recall someone working on titanium
rotors (?)  Improvement without the complications?
Dave D.

They are basically the same as Mazda rotors but they are their own castings
as that is the only way to get the engine certified.

I don't know why the titanium rotors never caught on. Perhaps it is the heat
transfer rate. They may also require steel inserts for the apex seal slots
as I think titanium may have a problem with wear.
-- 
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2008 All world wide rights reserved.