> Paul,
> If the new corner seals use DLC, having a nitrided or other hard
> material on the side plates becomes very important. Any idea if they
> used those corner seals on the LeMans engine?
> Bill Jepson
Bill,
Everything I have been told about mating wearing surfaces tells me the
hardest surface wins the wear war. However Larry did say "hard and
slippery", perhaps the slipperiness of the material may off-set the
tendency
for higher wear of the side housings.
Then again why is it so slippery - I can only imagine that it is
somewhat
porous and holds an oil film.
The small contact area of the corner seal, is the main side housing
wear
evidenced in most engines in the past and is the main stumbling
block to the
successful development of the aluminum side housings IMHO.
Perhaps then, this development has helped overcome that particular wear
problem - but I'm only guessing.
George (down under)
George,
The definition of "wear" and the definition of "hard" are two of the
most relative terms in engineering IMO. To have good wear you need two
levels of hardness even when lubricated. Usually the softer of the two
materials is expected to slough off material. The rate at which it does
that is the critical thing obviously. For instance the ceramic apex
seals are harder than the chrome surface of the inner rotor housing
face. The chrome is hard enough though that the rate of wear on the
housing is very slow. Getting two materials that are just far enough
apart on the hardness scale is the crucial point. Raw cast iron wouldn't
be good there. The nitride coating put on the standard side plates is
very thin but quite hard.
Bill Jepson
George,
Slippery, from an engineering point of view would be called the "coefficient
of friction".
We looked at many materials for zero contamination robots for wafer fabs
when I worked in Silicon Valley. We used a really easy way to test between
different materials. Make exact 1" square blocks out of steel or aluminum,
then coat them with the different surface treatments (leave one uncoated for
reference).
Place them the edge of a piece of 1/4" thick, 12" square glass, the slowly
start picking up that edge of the glass. The part with the lowest
coefficient of friction will slide first. This test can be performed using
coated ground material instead of the glass to find the friction between
different coatings.
You must remember, that this has to be followed by a "wear test". In our
case, that really means beat the daylights out of an engine on the test
stand and then tear it down.
Larry
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2008 All world wide rights reserved.