Subject: Another Turbo Bites the dust
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 6/22/2008, 7:59 AM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


         Today I flew from San Diego to Brownville Texas to attend a
         formation
         flying clinic.  After 6 hours of WOT flight I was descending through
         5000' (down from 15.5k) an just a few miles from the airport
         when I had
         a sudden and sickening drop in manifold pressure.   The engine
         was still
         running fine, and I had plenty of altitude to make the runway, so I
         continued on debating weather or not to flip the turbo oil shutoff
         switch.  I had grown to respect this turbo so much that I finally
         decided that I had just blown out a fitting somewhere in the intake
         system downstream of the turbo.  I even continued on to a low
         pass for
         show rather than just landing.  When I eventually had time to
         take off
         the cowl I was disappointed to find that all the fitting were in
         place
         and that the compressor wheel turns only with significant
         resistance.

         So the turbo is dead, and I am out of the formation clinic and
         will have
         to decide tomorrow about flying home with a dead turbo.  Will
         maybe be
         able to take a look in the hot side and see what I see.

         This turbo was the TO4 hybrid with a fixed wide open waste gate.
          It had
         130 hrs of mostly hard duty.  Sigh.

         --
         David Leonard

         Turbo Rotary RV-6 N4VY
         http://N4VY.RotaryRoster.net
         http://RotaryRoster.net

         Sorry to hear that Dave. You are our main turbo development man.

         Let me review the configuration. Larger TO4 compressor wheel
         adapted to stock
         late 2nd gen turbo. Is that correct? Was the stock turbine trimmed?
         Is this the one with the enlarged exducer?

         Turbo life is now up from two hours to 130 hours to look at the
         positive side.

         IMHO We still need a turbo tach.

         ---------------------------------------------------------------

         Dave, I wager when the turbine cracked is when you got to 15,500
         feet for
         awhile. I think that is when the turbo RPM exceeded its obvious
         red line.
         The higher you go the less back pressure on the turbine and the
         higher
         the turbine RPM. I know you know this but we have a lot of new
         readers.

         I also think what we need is a  simple diverter valve ahead of
         the turbo that
         positively diverts the exhaust gas to  an auxiliary exhaust pipe
         bypassing
         the turbo completely.

         Conventional waste gates don't do this. They merely open a hole
         in the exhaust
         manifold in the hopes this will reduce the pressure across the
         turbine and
         cause it to slow down. Obviously it is not working well enough.

         This diverter valve can be operated by a signal from the turbo
         tachometer
         limiting the turbine RPM. There is not a lot we can do about
         exhaust gas
         temperature but we can limit turbine RPM. Turbines fail from a
         combination
         of RPM and temperature. Limit one or the other and the turbine
         will live.

         This chart from Caterpillar graphs the situation. The red dotted
         line on the
         right is the RPM limit. The red dotted line on the left is the
         turbine
         inlet temperature. One must stay between the red lines. The
         black curves
         can be considered as HP lines as this is a diesel. More fuel
         more HP.

         Do we need a 3D?

         BTW Dave this R&D you are doing IMHO will become invaluable when
         the time comes
         to build a turbo compound rotary. I thank you in advance. The
         world will
         owe you a debt of gratitude.
         --
         Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor

     .
     Paul,
     You snatched the words right out of my mouth and it's something I
     suggested
     some time ago. At the time you requested a drawing and II supplied a
     rough
     one, but to be fair all things must be tried and I would suggest
     they have
     been pretty well tried by Dave to this point.

     I wonder how Mistral are doing theirs. Regardless restricting the
     heat and
     flow is the most obvious way to assure survivability of the Turbo IMHO.
     George (down under)

     I am rapidly coming to the conclusion that the problem lies with the
     RPM and not the turbine temps. 1050 C is 1900 F.

     The turbine temps are about half the EGT temps.


     Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.


Paul,
This may sound overly simplistic, but if too much heat is the culprit,
why not move the turbo further away from the exhaust ports?  Seems to me
that this would dissipate a good portion of the excessive heat and also
the excess flow as the exhaust  will contract as it cools.  I vaguely
recall seeing a picture of someone's turbo installation where the turbo
is located downstream of a tangential muffler (possibly Tom Parkes'
20B).  Tom doesn't post often, but last I heard, he wasn't having any
turbo problems.

Mark S.
67.7 hrs (no turbo)

I now don't think heat is the main problem given the recent Borg Warner
FEA's on the subject. The turbine is operating at half the EGT's temps.
See the attached charts of temperature.

I think the reason Tom's is working better is its a large aircraft turbo.
Obviously aircraft turbo's are designed differently and for  a constant speed engine
and moderate to high  engine HP. That to me means a modest HP turbine with a
large compressor. There is so much kinetic energy in the rotary engine exhaust it
is easy to over speed the car turbo charger. Brief over speeds don't hurt it.
Long term over speeds will destroy it.

The aircraft turbo has the effect of keeping the turbo charger RPM within limits. Dave
had his car turbo charger modified along those lines. A larger compressor
was added.

"The compressor is a 60-1 and the turbine is a TO4 clipped to fit in
the stock housing.  With the wastgate open [it] can only make about 30" MAP
at that altitude, but I can't use it all because my prop is not big
enough.  I hit 6700 engine RPM but I didn't feel comfortable staying
there."  [2.17:1 gear box].

BNR Supercars
393 Coupland Rd.
Branchville, AL 35120
  (205) 640-1193
BNRsupercars@yahoo.com / AIM: BNRsupercars


I think that was  a large step in the right direction. With a spacer
between the stock 2nd gen turbo and stock  manifold a yet larger compressor
could be added.

Unfortunately what was also done, as I recall, was the exducer was opened
out which was a small step in the wrong direction.

"The turbine housing is opened up tremendously therefore decreasing backpressure."

You want to keep some back pressure on the turbine to keep the turbine HP and RPM down.

Most car turbocharger tuner guys don't understand the problems adapting car
turbo chargers to aircraft use.

It is all in Hugh MacInnes book "Turbochargers" but you have to
read between the lines sometimes and think about the implications.

BTW I also might add there is a pulsating super sonic shock wave emanating
from the rotary engine exhaust. If that wave strikes the turbine blade it could
excite the blade at its natural resonant frequency or one of it's harmonics and
fatigue it over time. The 2 rotor pulse frequency is twice the RPM or 200 pulses per
second at 6000 RPM.

The stock 2nd gen manifold lines up the turbo charger inlet with the rear rotor.
There is a straight shot.

Tom's manifold is different. The three rotor dumps
the exhaust into a large tube and then into the turbo charger.
The frequency at 6000 RPM is also higher at 300 pulses per second.

It might be wise to move the turbo charger back (forward on the car)
about 2.5 inches on the new fabricated manifold with diverter valve
to force the shock wave to turn and break it up.
-- 
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2008 All world wide rights reserved.