Subject: Just suppose we did. Rotor material]
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 6/29/2008, 6:13 PM
To: AAA Put this in the To box

   Suppose that we did have some well tested aluminum rotors, and they work
   fine, and the groove don't wear out, and they don't get too big when
   hot
   and open the seal end gaps and so on. Or, we slot the corner seals,

   and some how the
    crush fit for the steel backed rotor bearing does not
   vanish at operating temps, and we build an airplane engine with this
   magic aluminum.

   Suppose the new rotor weighs 1 pound instead of nearly 10 pounds.
   Counter weights will be down to about a pound each. Good news.

   Any additional HP will only come from processing more fuel, so if you
   really need more than 230 or so then you need more RPM and then maybe a
   3.5:1 reduction unit.

   Muffling will be more involved or with ceramic coatings a turbo.

   But you will be giving away more than one advantage of cast nodular
   iron, and there are many.
   The one I like is flywheel effect from 20 pounds of iron. The two torque
   pulses per revolution with no flywheel effect may be more fun than you
   can imagine. Once at speed there may not be a big problem, but shame on
   you at part throttle. And idle will be a school in tuning. Ignition only
   after TDC. Lean, slow
    burning mixture maybe only injecting alternate
   revolutions, and so on.

   So now its on the torque stand and has been running fine. The first
   reduction box is back at Tracy's to get autopsied, and power is good but
   now the new box is showing slivers of steel in the filter, and we have
   built a new heavy flywheel to take out those awful jerks and jumps under
   1600 RPM. Strange, the flywheel weighs 20 pounds????????

   If its for a race car, where recurring accelerations will yield improved
   times to RPM, then a very light rotating assembly is important. The
   weight differences may not show up on a dyno at all and lighter
   assemblies  may prove to be less effective when they allow undamped
   harmonics where heavier  pieces had no such problems. In a steady state
   power measurement the current engine might show up better than the new
   lighter rotor engine.

     So you buy a new race engine from the guy who beats the snot
    out of you
   every weekend, and your plan is that since you have identical cars and
   about the same equipment, and of course you can drive better than that
   old guy, you will teach him a lesson next week at Mid Ohio. Your home
   track.

   Ouch......He is still 2 seconds faster. Not as bad as 3 seconds but this
   engine he sold you must be lame.
   He says lets swap cars for the next session, you leap at the chance. His
   car was a past National champion.

   He is a second faster in your car than you are.. And he was only out for
   two laps. You stay out for the whole session 9 laps and your best was a
   second faster than your car. Damn...........

   He says lets walk the track at noon, and in the mean time here is a list
   I made up that might help you.

   During the walk you find out your solid knowledge of Mid Ohio turns out
   to be vestigial. He gifts you his copy of Driving in competition by Alan
   Johnson. His list says
    that the engine seems fine, the 4-5 spread is too
   tall. The final drive ratio is too tall, 4th is faster than shifting to
   5th then back. You need a carbon fiber drive shaft.
   Loose the Centerline wheels and buy PPS wheels. Mount Good-Years forget
   the Hoosiers. He says you have to wind it to 9,600 on each shift. The
   rear bar on full soft is still way too stiff.

   His crew chief, (another old guy) explains to your crew chief (also your
   father in-law) that the recurring acceleration of that extra mass costs
   time. The Good-Years only last 2 weekends but weigh 10 pounds and stick
   real good over 150 degrees.

   The Hoosiers last 4 weekends but weigh 15 pounds and need 200 plus
   degrees to stick at all. Not going to happen on the rear tires

   In the race:

   The old guy drives off his pace a bit, and gives you a driving clinic,
   just driving his line, you turn in your very best lap time ever. On the
   last lap, he
    shifts at 9,600 instead of 9,300 RPM and yanks you 6 cars
   down the long straight like he has 30 HP on you and wins again. You are
   now friends with the old guys, who and all and all seems to know more than you.
   The
   difference is the recurring acceleration of the rotating assembly where
   one is a whole lot heavier than the other. If you think about it longer,
   you see that braking is more effective as well.
   (Wheels and tires are big flywheels)
   On an inertia dyno, that measures time to RPM, the heavy rotating
   assembly will show up as less HP than a lighter rotating assembly. On
   a water brake dyno it may not show up at all.

   Lynn E. Hanover


   That is very good Lynn. You have a real talent for writing.
   Very interesting.

   The aluminum rotor will never be one pound. Iron .3 pounds per cubic inch.
   Aluminum .1 pounds per cubic inch.

   Hi silicon content aluminum expands much less than regular
    aluminum
   and is closer to iron. That is why they make pistons out of it..
   That is also why Mazda went to it for rotor housings.

   Piston ring slot wear is more of an issue in pistons as the rings
   move back and fourth unlike the apex seals in a rotary engine.

   So far I have not found a conversion for expansion per degree Kelvin
   to inches per inch per degree F. Perhaps someone on here can help me out.

   Don't forget the torque isolator. Tracy's is tunable
   and working very well. No real need for a 20 pound flywheel.
   And yes I think 150% more power will show up on a water brake dyno.
   That is of course the dyno is capable of 16,000 RPM.. P-ports both of course.


   Furthermore :)
   "In this study, an aluminum alloy, AA1050, was reinforced with an
   interconnected, axisymmetrical, galvanized iron wire preform.
   The composite was synthesized using disintegrated melt deposition
   technique followed by hot
    extrusion. Micro structural characterization
   conducted on the composite samples showed good interfacial integrity
   and low volume percent of non-interconnected porosity. Physical property
   characterization showed that the coefficient of thermal expansion of the
   composite decreased below the values predicted by the theoretical models.
   Hardness test conducted on the materials revealed that the composite
   matrix exhibited a higher hardness when compared to the monolithic
   aluminum alloy. Tensile property characterization revealed that, even
   with a low volume percentage (0.896%) of the reinforcement, the elastic
   modulus of the composite material increased beyond the value predicted
   by the Rule-of-Mixture model. The 0.2% yield strength and the ultimate
   tensile strength of the composite material and the monolithic aluminum
   alloy remained within each other¢s standard deviation while the ductility
   of the composite material
    decreased."


   Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.


http://www.unitconversion.org/unit_converter/thermal-expansion.html

http://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/linear-expansion-coefficients-d_95.html

About twice the expansion rate of cast iron.

Rob Woods

Great conversion site Rob. Thanks for finding that.

According to this site.  Si/Al Alloy is 000.000011  per degree F... inches
per inch while  steel is given at 0.0000063 per degree F... inches per inch
I don't have it for iron.

Lets say the 3 inch wide  Si/Al rotor gains 430 F from room temp when running
flat out. The Si/Al rotor gains 15 thousands in width while the steel rotor
gains 8 thousands in width. The Si/Al rotor then would then need to
be about 8 to 10 thousands of an inch narrower to fit the stock
rotor housing.

The current side seal slot depth in the cast iron rotor is
about 150 thousands (.15 inches).  The side seal slot in the Si/Al rotor
could then be 8 thousands of an inch deeper and the side seals themselves
are about 150 thousands wide. The Si/Al seals would then be about 154 thousands.
Each side shares the travel so I don't think that is necessary.

I'll leave the calculation of the increase in OD of the rotor to the reader but
it is equally not much of a problem.

The rotor bearings could be pressed into a steel insert cast into the rotor.
I notice the Corvette engine runs the mains in the aluminum block
directly with steel main bearing caps. That has got to be a heat distortion
nightmare :) Lots of aircraft engines run the main bearing shells in the aluminum
block directly. The bearing shells could be pressed into the Si/Al rotor after
it is heated to 500 F.

BTW an Al/Si rotor would pay off weight wise much better with a one rotor engine.
-- 
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2008 All world wide rights reserved.