Subject: Stationary Gear Center Plate Pics
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 7/13/2008, 9:32 PM
To: AAA Put this in the To box



   > Hey Guys,
        >
        > I finally came
    across some pictures of how they do a stacked 4 rotor
        > setup that we have seen from Austraila/Japan. I would assume they are
        > doing a machined down stationary gear but don't know if it is
   some
        > collar around that gear or the gear itself. I am sure
         staring it awhile
        > it will become more clear. Whats funny is the money they are charging
        > for this machine service. Does any one have any specs of the station
        > gear tooth profile itself? Also anything on the metallurgy of the
   RX-8
        > gears?
        >
        > Rob Woods
        >
        >
        >
        > Very interesting Rob. Thanks for the pictures. I have always been
   curious
        > about
        > that. It is the oil drain back that is tricky. I am guessing they are
        > starting
        > with the rear stationary gear.
        >
        > Paul Lamar ...No rotor
    no motor.

        Rob,
        I've always felt that the best approach was to have stationary gears
   each
        side of the rotor. This would eliminate the rotor cocking at combustion
   and
        eliminate the wear on the opposite side, hopefully.

        No machining costs are funny, in fact I find them extremely unfunny.

        I would also be interested in gear specs - I understand that
         racing people
        had the gears tip relieved and this is also part of the RX upgrade as well
        as the gears being hardened from 1989 on ( I think).
        George (down under)



   George,

   That would seem to make sense but the rotor gear would have to be one
   piece then and I don't know how that would work off the top of my head
   seeing as the gear is larger than the ID of the bearing area. If they
   two gears didn't phase/line up perfectly then I imagine that it would
   cause more trouble then the stock
    setup. This also comes back to one of
   my original questions. The weight of a rotor is a rpm limiting factor
   because of the rotor bearing or the tooth loads of the gears or both???
   I was led to believe that the gear teeth were the issue since you can
   always battle hydrodynamic forces with more flow and pressure. Having
   double gears would help solve this since you are getting more contact
   ratio per rotor. Don't know how you would squirt the oil into the rotor
   either at that point if you "close" the open windows. Reason I ask
   about
   tooth specs and material type is that would be an easy part oto make out
   of something much stronger if need be. I have real good connections with
   Taylor Race Engineering and know what they use on their top dog gear
   boxes and such.

   Rob Woods

   It is a bit of both but the bearing load is something you cannot do
   much about other than making the rotor out of aluminum. Mazda
    fooled
   around with different roll pin configuration and drastically reduced
   the gear loads. In simple theory there are no loads on the phasing
   gears. In practice there appears to be quite a bit and nobody is
   quite sure where it is coming from :)
   --
   Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.



In simple theory all the loads would go through the gear. It is the only
thing that doesn't move that the rotor reacts against. Did you think
about that reverse SIP rotor I was talking about? Seems to be the best
of both worlds in terms of weight vs. load. Also I am sure I saw it
through your site but NASA had a paper on their titanium rotors they
were working on. Why don't we talk more about that?

Rob Woods.


Not true. To quote Ansdale page 41 "no forces are imposed on these gears."
What forces there are come from inertia and friction. The pressure on the face of
the rotor is balanced so the loads go through the eccentric. There is no need
to react these loads. Also read pages 24 and 25 of Ken Yamamoto's book "Rotary Engine.
You can download it from http://www.wankel.net/~krwright/cars/rx7/manuals.html
Scroll down to the bottom of the page.

What is the NASA paper title or number and where do I down load it.

Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2008 All world wide rights reserved.