Subject: NASA part numbers/became coatings
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 7/18/2008, 12:12 PM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


       Paul,

       Please comment on Steve's usage of the term "creep."  We need to
    get the
       terms and physical phenomenon straight..

       Why do the rotor housings not seem to suffer from the same
    deformation
       (creep?) problems as the side housings?  They should be under the
    same
       clamp-up pressure.  Is the stackup being completely of Aluminum
    instead
       of fe-al-fe a source of trouble?

       Very interesting info about the coatings.


       Regards,

       Matt-

       I am not sure what Steve means by that.  Creep usually means a
    permanent
       deflection of material over a long period of time. Very few aluminum
       engines are affected by this in aircraft or car engines.

       Perhaps there is a part in his end housings that were not adequately
       cooled
       and creep was occurring at elevated temperatures over 250 F.

       Jim Mederer mentioned something about that near the main bearings and
       he added material to counter it. I am not sure if it was creep or
       just plain
       yield or cracking.

       What I am talking about in the context of coatings is local
       deflection (not permanent)
       to the aluminum under the coating as the seal passes over them.
       Mazda devised a test rig
       to check this mode of coating failure and it was described in the
       Lemans SAE paper.

       http://www.rotaryeng.net/4-rotor-1-5.pdf/
       and
       http://www.rotaryeng.net/4-rotor-6-11.pdf/

       What may have been interpreted as creep in the past on rotor housing
       is when then were permanently deflected due to over heating. That
       was not
       creep.

       What was happening was the rotor housings were over expanding
       against the steel
       tension bolts and taking a permanent set. When the engine cooled off
       you had a coolant leak into the combustion chamber. That pretty much
       went
       away about the late 80's when Mazda switched to a high silicon, low
       thermal
       expansion alloy. Also the tension bolts were necked down reducing
       the tensile
       spring rate.

       I have only seen that happen lately when the engine was run
       with out coolant at high power. Of course the steel liner was melted
       as well.

       -
       Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.



    I apologize Paul..  I didn't read Steve's post carefully enough.  I
    think I've got it now.  The "creep" or distortion he's talking about is
    strictly on the wear surface, right?

    Due to high power operation.

    I take that to mean that the wear surface might be getting too hot and
    thus becomes weaker, and then the seals chew into it.  Does that sound
    right?

    If it's heat weakening the base metal, I wonder what's primary factor
    driving that.  Combustion gas exposure or friction?  Lack of cooling?
    Under oiling?  Mismatch between the side seal material and the surface
    coating?  A combination?


    Regards,

    Matt-

    I have no idea. I am waiting to hear from Steve on what he means
    when he says creep.

    I suspect the base metal is merely deflecting and not weakening.
    The term weakening is not in the lexicon of the mechanical engineering.
    The terms are yield... a permanent deformation of the material.
    and deflection.... a non permanent deformation.

    The bottom line is to duplicate the Mazda test rigs.
    Pay particular attention to the plating tester. Chrome on steel
    was far and away superior to anything else Mazda tried.

    Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.



When I said weakening I meant lowered yield strength and hardness
(lowered modulus) due to high temperature.

We can duplicate the test rigs, but it pays to come up with a plausible
hypothesis before doing the experiments.


Matt-

OK Yes I think the modulus of elasticity goes down with temp on aluminum.
-- 
Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2008 All world wide rights reserved.