Subject: Oil Coolers: Here You Go, Paul :-)
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 8/1/2008, 9:20 PM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


Dear Paul:

Here you go!

Les Nordman :-)

Thanks Les

------------------------------------------------------------------------

 > Date: Tue, 6 May 2008 08:24:10 -0700
 > From: rotaryeng@earthlink.net
 > To: rotaryeng@earthlink.net
 > Subject: Oil Coolers
 >
 > > Oil Cooler/s for RX-8 engine
 > >
 > > What size oil cooler should I be looking at if we don't have the
 > > standard one
 > > and maybe some suggestions on which ones / brands might be the options
 > >
 > > Anyone got some suggestions?
 > >
 > > Thanks
 > >
 > > Regards David
 > >
 > > For a two hundred HP RX8 engine you will need something about 300
 > > cubic inches.
 > > Preferable about two inches thick or thinner. The best shape would
 > > be square or
 > > about 12 inches high by about 12 inches wide by about two inches
 > > thick.
 > > Make sure it will withstand 150 psi minimum. Internal finning in the
 > > tubes
 > > improves the heat transfer from the oil to the metal. Also lower
 > > weight
 > > oils cool the engine better for the same reason. Use 10W fully
 > > synthetic or
 > > lower in the engine while mixing two cycle oil with the fuel as it
 > > burns better.
 > >
 > > Don't go on the manufactures engine HP recommendations as the rotary
 > > rejects
 > > three times the oil heat. Most piston engines reject only 10% to
 > > cooling the oil while
 > > the rotary rejects 30% or more. In other words as far as oil coolers
 > > are concerned
 > > a 200 HP rotary requires a 600 HP piston engine oil cooler.
 > >
 > > Setrab is a good international company.
 > > http://www.setrab.com/index.php?id=68
 > > --
 > > Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
 > >
 > >
 > > Paul,
 > >
 > > Nice discussion about oil. You mention the Setrab coolers. Since that
 > > is what I use I thought I would share my experience. You outlined the
 > > 11x18" cooler but I started out with the 11x15" and found that was
 > > larger than I needed. I am now using the 11x10" cooler (PN 50-634).
 > > Even then I have about 20 sq in of the face covered with duct tape just
 > > to get oil temps up to about 150. Worst case is a 100 deg day, heat
 > > soaked engine (I was giving rides to multiple people) and 85 kt climb
 > > out at 34" MAP [turbo] and I finally got the oil to climb above 200
(my
 > > personal
 > > red line). Flattening the climb to 100 kts without reducing power
quickly
 > > brought the temps back down. WOT in level flight oil temps never exceed
 > > 150.
 > >
 > > Now, I should mention that my oil cooler is very well-fed with air (the
 > > entire right cowl inlet). If I were to use a larger face radiator and
 > > smaller cowl opening I could probably achieve the same results with
less
 > > cooling drag. Also, 34" MAP in a steep climb out for me, with my
 > > over pitched prop and 2.17 gear box is significantly less than 200 h.p.
 > >
 > > One other thing I should mention about the Setrab. I have had a
 > > recurring problem with a small leak in the same location on 3 coolers.
 > > I kept thinking that I has some sort of mounting issue causing the leak
 > > until I dissected one of the coolers and found that there was faulty
 > > brazing in the trouble spot. A dab of JB weld fixed the leak and has
 > > held for the last 50+ hrs (it is a fairly small leak anyway). I called
 > > the company and they just wanted to keep blaming over torque on
 > > installation (but I used a torque wrench). It was clear that they have
 > > had a big problem with customers "over torquing" the AN fittings when
 > > installed. Best they could do was offer me a replacement cooler at a
 > > discount - which I still have since the one with JB weld is working
fine.
 > >
 > > Will sell that one for $290+ shipping if anyone is interested, JB weld
 > > not included :-)
 > >
 > > --
 > > David Leonard
 > >
 > > Turbo Rotary RV-6 N4VY
 > > http://N4VY.RotaryRoster.net
 > > http://RotaryRoster.net
 > >
 > > ----------------------------------------------------
 > >
 > > We never did get pictures of your new installation Dave.
 > > I would still like to see them. Here are some old ones
 > > dating back to Dec. 2007. Nicely done, well sealed K&W oil
 > > cooler duct on the right side.
 > >
 > > Do you have movable cowl flaps on it yet? :)
 > > What are the oil and water temps flat out at top speed?
 > > What is the top speed? When you are climbing out at 85 kts
 > > what is the gross weight and rate of climb (FPM)? From that one
 > > can calculate the climb HP being used.
 > >
 > > When you cut it open did you notice fins inside the tubes?
 > >
 > > BTW I suggest testing the cooler to 150 PSI with hot oil before
using them
 >
 > > as
 > > the rotary is much much harder on coolers than a piston engine
 > > that typically operates on only 40 psi. We see oil pressures
 > > on the dyno when the rotary engine oil is still cold at well over
100 psi.
 > >
 > > A hydraulic hand pump from a cheap Chinese jack will work along
 > > with a pressure gage. Boil the low viscosity oil so it gets above
250 F or
 >
 > > so
 > > before you pour it into the cooler. Oil cooler failures are serous
 > > as we have had at least two in flight oil fires and one fatality due
 > > to failed oil coolers in the last ten years. Mistral has also had
 > > an oil cooler expand due to over pressure.
 > >
 > > The stock 2nd gen oil coolers work fine but they are getting scarce.
 > > I think they were custom built by Modine for Mazda.
 > >
 > > I am surprised about the Setrab leak. Perhaps we need to find another
 > > supplier.
 > >
 > > Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
 >
 >
 >
 > Paul--we found your recommended oil cooler sizes for good plate/fin heat
 > exchangers a good guide. Used the 13 1/2" tall x 11 5/8" wide Setrab and
 > Serck-Mocal for the RV-3 and RV-4. Worked well overall but was a little
 > marginal for very high output missions including x/c races when the RV-3
 > ridden hard. There it ran up to 225 degrees oil @ 7,000 rpm; 235/239
mph in
 > two-way test GPS runs; 65 degrees OAT; 1650 and 1700 EGTs...ditto on hot
 > days when doing very steep, extended climbs. Didn't have any problems
with
 > it when we ran the same modified 13B with nitrous @ 350 hp in short climb
 > competition). Common cowl flap for oil/water heat exchangers.
 >
 > Dave Leonard--kudos for the work on your RV-6 installation. Have you
 > weighed firewall fwd excluding mount/gear or calculated estimation vs.
 > equivalent h.p. Lycoming RV-6? Also, what size fittings for oil lines?
 >
 > Steve Beckham
 >
 > No beating a good cross country air race to test your cooling system :)
 > Top speed equals the cube root of Horsepower :)
 >
 > A lot depends on the feed duct or diffuser and how well the
 > air can find its way out of the back side of the cooler.
 > If the back side of the cooler is restricted the pressure build
 > up behind the cooler can affect the air flow through the cooler.
 >
 > I discuss all that in my book "How to Cool Your Wankel".
 >
 > --
 > Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.
 >
 >
 > Paul,
 > On our side, air racing speed is defined as "cubic dollars"......
 > Pics of our fresh paint job attached. No decals, all hand painted
graphics.
 > Larry Childs
 >
 >
 > Looks great Larry.
 > --
 > Paul Lamar ...No rotor no motor.

-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2008 All world wide rights reserved.