Subject: Traction Drive for turbo compound
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 8/5/2008, 4:24 PM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


Paul,


While researching turbo-compounding, I came across pictures of your
traction drive on your site, and was wondering if you
had made any progress on it since the date on the pictures (5-22-06).
Does
it
work?

Also, I can find very little information about traction drives in
general, but I'm interested in reducing a 100,000 to 150,000 rpm
turbine down to manageable speeds for use on a conventional
reciprocating engine or rotary.  It looks a little like a planetary
differential without gears. Is it a continuously variable
transmission? Can you describe its operation? Would you share the
Solidworks files or drawings used to make it?

I'm fascinated by your description of the possible efficiencies in
turbo-compounding a rotary engine, and I'm very excited about the
implications of Mazda's new 1.6L all-aluminum direct-injection rotary
in homebuilt use.

Thanks,
-Chris

Traction drives do work. They have been widely used for years.
Doug on here has a Rotrex supercharger that uses a traction drive.
Paxton/McCulloch made truck super chargers starting in the late
1930's.

Yes I can send you some step files which work the best in Solid Works.

Paul Lamar

Paul,

That's fascinating. Seems like a very reasonable way to develop high
reduction ratios with shafts of otherwise unreasonably high speeds.

I have a million questions:

What exactly is meant by "high contact surface pressure", ie how does
one calculate the roller preload necessary for it to work? Does wear
substantially decrease the interference fit (or preload) over time?
What type/viscosity of oil is used? Is the ideal roller surface finish
very smooth?

Step files would be much appreciated.

Thanks,
-Chris

You need the torque out of the turbine. You can work backwards by
estimating
the torque knowing the HP and the RPM of the turbine.

My guess on a full chat 200 HP rotary would be 50 HP out of the
turbine.

HP eqauls torque times RPM divided by 5252.

My wild ass guess is about 1 foot pound at 100,000 RPM.

Then you need the coef. of friction for steel on steel in the presence
of traction fluid. There are several auto tranny traction drives on the
market
for cars so that is a good source of traction fluid. My guess on the
subject
is .3 coef. Next you know the geometery and you know the contact
pressure
you can calculate the torque capacity. FEA will give you the contact
pressure
of a steel ring deflected into a triangular shape with three internal
rollers.

Here is a pdf on traction fluid.

You insert the ring in a large lathe 3 jaw chuck and insert the rollers
and
release the chuck.

Doug may have done static torque measurements on the Rotrex.
I basically copied the Rotrex.

Paul Lamar


That should be no trouble for me to assess and tweak. I've been
second-guessing the simplicity of the drive -- it really is
straightforward.

Do Nissan/Audi/etc CVTs use a traction fluid? Figuring accurately for
coefficient of friction and whether or not to consider it linear
(constant with increasing contact pressure), and how critical roller
finish is are really the only issues I'm uncertain about. If .3 is
what you guess it to be, that gives me a good place to start.

Thanks,
-Chris

Yes they do Chris. It should be easy to find out what brand it is  as
that info is probably in the owner's manuals. I suspect the finish
should be
mirror quality.

BTW There is a golden opportunity out there to get a huge grant from
the DOE to study the rotary turbo compound. Now is the time to do that.

On the other hand we have had over 5000 hits on our youtube P-port
RX8 engine and only about 2500 total for all  three of our turbo
compound
videos. Obviously the youtube audiences is more interested in more
RX8 power
than they are in better RX8 MPG I am sad to say.

Paul Lamar

You think the DOE cares about rotaries? I'm of the opinion that the
general public doesn't know what to make of them, and I personally
wonder how widespread they could ever be in conventional
transportation. That Mazda has stuck with them all these years is a
benefit to those of us who want high power density for special
applications.

The step to plug-in hybrid and eventually full electric vehicles quite
frankly seems much closer to reality than rotaries. What would you
like to see them used in?

-Chris

P.S. I think rotaries will never overcome the oil consumption thing
that causes higher HC emissions and certainly limits widespread
adoption compared to "PZEV" reciprocating engines.


----------------------------------------------------------------

The rotary is the only mass produced four stroke internal combustion
engine
without an exhaust valve. The exhaust valve alone is probably
responsible for 20% of the total energy lost in the exhaust.
That is not the same thing as saying the efficiency of the ICE can be
improved 20% by the elimination of the exhaust valve. What I am saying
is eliminating the exhaust valve increases the kinetic energy in the
exhaust and making more available for a turbine.

Since over half the energy in a gallon of gas is lost in the exhaust
that makes the turbo compound rotary potentially the most efficient
ICE of all with the possible exception of the turbo compound diesel.

The exhaust valve is the Achilles heel of the turbo compound gasoline
piston engine as if and when it breaks up it takes out the turbine.
The exhaust of a diesel engine is much cooler. Thousands of CW R3350
turbo compound engines were
built in the 1940's and 1950's so there is no great leap to turbo
compound technology. It could be in use in a year or two. Turbo
compound diesel engines are already available. We have just seen the
tip of the iceberg in turbo compound diesel engines. The current sales
of Detroit Diesel turbo compound DD15 engines will see to that.

Hybrids will use ICE's for the foreseeable future so one could use
a turbo compound rotary in a hybrid as well. It would have advantages
in the power to weight ratio and power to size ratio.

The Hc emissions have been largely eliminated by the RX8 engine side
exhaust port.

There is no such thing as a zero emissions vehicle in the U.S. The
electricity must come from somewhere and until there is wide spread
adoption of nuclear power plants we will continue to burn oil, natural
gas and coal for the vast majority of the electricity generated in the
U.S.. The emissions are just exported to the source of the
electricity.  Sorry but those are the facts.


Paul Lamar

------------------------------------------------------------------------


--Paul,

steve wolpin here.
what is the rolling resistance of the traction box in a rotrex compared
to the spur gear box in say a vortec?  roughly?  any idea?
the rotrex is much more compact but does it take more from the crank to
drive it for a similar cfm output?

steve wolpin

--------------------------------------------------------------

No but I think Doug could also measure that.
How about it Doug? How much torque does it take to turn
the input shaft... both break away and after it starts turning?

The thing about gears is they are limited to certain pitch line velocities.
Only traction drives can go up to these kinds of RPM's.

I think their claims of 98% efficient are unsubstantiated given the
need for the external traction drive cooling system.
www.rotrex.com/pdfs/Rotrex_C-type_supercharger_installation_instructions-V1.5.pdf

I think these Paxton McCulloch curves are more like it with perhaps 30%
better thrown in for recent technology improvements to centrifugal
compressors. In other words I doubt it exceeds much above 80%.
Not the first time this company has made misleading statements
in their advertising.

http://www.rotrex.com/

It take HP to compress air so turbochargers are a better deal as they utilize
otherwise waste HP from the exhaust much like turbo compound engines.
That HP burns more fuel.  IMHO this companies claims of being "green" are
greatly exaggerated :)

Paul Lamar


Paul,

I can measure it of course but it will be the weekend before I get over
to my workshop.  Now I have to take advantage of the Michiwa's
school's summer break and the unlimited access to their machine shop.

Note the rotrex resistance will be different when warmed up.  Cold the
oil it is real draggy.


Doug in Japan

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2008 All world wide rights reserved.