>>> You think the DOE cares about rotaries? I'm of the opinion that the
>>> general public doesn't know what to make of them, and I personally
>>> wonder how widespread they could ever be in conventional
>>> transportation. That Mazda has stuck with them all these years is a
>>> benefit to those of us who want high power density for special
>>> applications.
>>>
>>> The step to plug-in hybrid and eventually full electric vehicles quite
>>> frankly seems much closer to reality than rotaries. What would you
>>> like to see them used in?
>>>
>>> -Chris
>>>
>>> P.S. I think rotaries will never overcome the oil consumption thing
>>> that causes higher HC emissions and certainly limits widespread
>>> adoption compared to "PZEV" reciprocating engines.
>>>
>>>
>>> ----------------------------------------------------------------
>>>
>>> The rotary is the only mass produced four stroke internal combustion
>>> engine
>>> without an exhaust valve. The exhaust valve alone is probably
>>> responsible for 20% of the total energy lost in the exhaust.
>>> That is not the same thing as saying the efficiency of the ICE can be
>>> improved 20% by the elimination of the exhaust valve. What I am saying
>>> is eliminating the exhaust valve increases the kinetic energy in the
>>> exhaust and making more available for a turbine.
>>>
>>> Since over half the energy in a gallon of gas is lost in the exhaust
>>> that makes the turbo compound rotary potentially the most efficient
>>> ICE of all with the possible exception of the turbo compound diesel.
>>>
>>> The exhaust valve is the Achilles heel of the turbo compound gasoline
>>> piston engine as if and when it breaks up it takes out the turbine.
>>> The exhaust of a diesel engine is much cooler. Thousands of CW R3350
>>> turbo compound engines were
>>> built in the 1940's and 1950's so there is no great leap to turbo
>>> compound technology. It could be in use in a year or two. Turbo
>>> compound diesel engines are already available. We have just seen the
>>> tip of the iceberg in turbo compound diesel engines. The current sales
>>> of Detroit Diesel turbo compound DD15 engines will see to that.
>>>
>>> Hybrids will use ICE's for the foreseeable future so one could use
>>> a turbo compound rotary in a hybrid as well. It would have advantages
>>> in the power to weight ratio and power to size ratio.
>>>
>>> The Hc emissions have been largely eliminated by the RX8 engine side
>>> exhaust port.
>>>
>>> There is no such thing as a zero emissions vehicle in the U.S. The
>>> electricity must come from somewhere and until there is wide spread
>>> adoption of nuclear power plants we will continue to burn oil, natural
>>> gas and coal for the vast majority of the electricity generated in the
>>> U.S.. The emissions are just exported to the source of the
>>> electricity. Sorry but those are the facts.
>>>
>>>
>>> Paul Lamar
>>>
>>>
------------------------------------------------------------------------
>>>
>>
>> --Paul,
>>
>> steve wolpin here.
>> what is the rolling resistance of the traction box in a rotrex compared
>> to the spur gear box in say a vortec? roughly? any idea?
>> the rotrex is much more compact but does it take more from the crank to
>> drive it for a similar cfm output?
>>
>> steve wolpin
>>
>> --------------------------------------------------------------
>>
>> No but I think Doug could also measure that.
>> How about it Doug? How much torque does it take to turn
>> the input shaft... both break away and after it starts turning?
>>
>> The thing about gears is they are limited to certain pitch line
velocities.
>> Only traction drives can go up to these kinds of RPM's.
>>
>> I think their claims of 98% efficient are unsubstantiated given the
>> need for the external traction drive cooling system.
>>
www.rotrex.com/pdfs/Rotrex_C-type_supercharger_installation_instructions-V1.
5.pdf
>>
>> I think these Paxton McCulloch curves are more like it with perhaps 30%
>> better thrown in for recent technology improvements to centrifugal
>> compressors. In other words I doubt it exceeds much above 80%.
>> Not the first time this company has made misleading statements
>> in their advertising.
>>
>> http://www.rotrex.com/
>>
>> It take HP to compress air so turbochargers are a better deal as they
utilize
>> otherwise waste HP from the exhaust much like turbo compound engines.
>> That HP burns more fuel. IMHO this companies claims of being "green"
are
>> greatly exaggerated :)
>>
>> Paul Lamar
>
>
> Paul,
>
> I can measure it of course but it will be the weekend before I get over
> to my workshop. Now I have to take advantage of the Michiwa's
> school's summer break and the unlimited access to their machine shop.
>
> Note the rotrex resistance will be different when warmed up. Cold the
> oil it is real draggy.
>
>
> Doug in Japan
Doug and Paul,
i am less concerned about cold torque requirement. mostly i'm wondering the
normal operating load put on the crank by the rotrex.
i understand gearboxes cannot achieve the rpm the traction box can. my comp
question is different than that: i want to know for the output in CFM the
rotrex(es) can achieve and the hp cost(s) of that, what is a comparable set
of
figures [output and hp cost] for a belt & gear-driven centrifugal with a
similar
cfm capacity that has been optimally sized?
steve wolpin
I assume you are talking about the HP consumed by the supercharger drive
alone.
The Paxton drive is a ball type traction drive so I assume it is comparable
to a
Rotrex roller type traction drive. I think the question you want answered
is: Is
a traction drive more efficient than a gear drive? My guess is no. It is
probably worse. So too a belt drive is probably worse than a pure gear
drive.
They are probably all in the 95% to 98% ball park.
Now as far as the total HP consumed by the supercharger at a given boost
level
I don't know the answer to that as well. All I have is this data to go on.
Perhaps some one smarter than I can calculate it based on the amount of
boost as
a function of RPM and HP out to the supercharger. These charts are the best
I
can do right at the moment.
It is very very rare indeed to see charts like this from a supercharger or
turbo
charger manufacturers. These are old charts and it is not in the best
interest
of the companies manufacturing super chargers to publish this data.
A turbo charger manufacturer would have to put the turbine section on a dyno
in order to produce such a chart. Some of the information one would need is
the exact amount of kinetic energy in the exhaust. Another way of doing it
is
measure the fuel flow as a function of HP before and after supercharging and
calculate the corresponding BSFC's. If we had the RPM of the turbo chargers
we were using we would have another piece of the puzzle.
My wild ass guess is the BSFC will be at least 10% worse with a
supercharger.
The last chart is for a turbo charged rotary and the BSFC is as good or
maybe
slightly better than a non turbo rotary.
BTW in case you are wondering none of this translates to car use as there
is something else far more fundamental with cars and that is the low
percentage
of peak power a car needs to cruise. A turbo charger, by its very nature,
does
not come into use until a fair amount of power is demanded from the engine.
Supercharged cars like the Mercedes disconnect the super charger while
cruising.
Paul Lamar
Paul,
They don't publish gear step up efficiency, but the F150 I ran with a
Procharger P1SC got the same gas mileage on the freeway with the blower as
it did without. This means the efficiency of the drive was very good.
Procharger builds many friction drive units as well, but their primary unit
for the street uses gears at a 1 to 4.1 step up ratio internally. You then
use the crank and blower pulleys to get the desired boost level.
If I were going to use a blower on an aircraft engine, a belt driven
procharger, as even if it had a failure, it would toss the belt and the
engine continues to run at lower hp. The gearboxes are self contained, so
you don't loose engine oil as you do with a turbo failure.
Larry
Yes but on the freeway you are not using any boost. You are using less than
50 HP. Even for a pick up truck. The boost from a centrifugal super charger is
proportional to RPM squared or more. So 3000 engine RPM the blower is not
working very hard. As I said the gear train alone is 95% eff. or better.
As I also said what I say is not applicable to car use :)
They don't publish HP consumed as function of boost either.
Paul Lamar
--
Steve,
Steve, I agree with you. Breakaway torque or even free spinning torque
doesn't tell us anything useful unless we are interested in momentary
loads on the belt. The breakaway is miniscule as I can turn it with two
fingers.
Rotrex gave me this attached PDF of the hp consumed for the model
C-30-64. They told me to add about 10% to hp consumption of the next
size up I am using. This info is useful only in that it gives an idea
what type of power the unit will handle. I went to their office in
Copenhagen directly and spoke with the designer of the unit so they were
a little more forth-coming. Hp consumed is propostional to the load
you are putting on it.
I was told that the C-30 series would easily handle 30Hp and the C-32
series would handle up over 80hp. through puts. The larger series have
a gear ratio closer to 7:1 and combined with a larger slower turbine,
and an approximate 2:1 final V-belt reduction, it is, I suspect, more
suitable for the T.C. job.
The C30-72 unit I have is better for providing a little boost. I differ
from Paul's approach in that I want to separate the tasks of driving
compressors and driving the compound gearing system. This however means
the supercharger is absorbing about 20hp of the output but the turbo
compound system sees the full power of the exhaust turbine. It must be
be designed to handle the 80hp. input. Net is 60hp BEFORE the PSRU
losses are figured in.
If you think about what happens to a automobile engine when the air
conditioner comes on during a hot day, you knows that torque (HP)
requirement pulls the engine rpm down resulting in a hp loss towards to
air-con and the friction in the belt that drives it. This is very
noticable in the small compact cars. The reverse also true. Turn off
the air-con and the engine rpm speeds up. How much depends on the ratio
of total engine hp to accessory load. In a large pickup truck you may
barely notice the difference
Engaging the turbo compound on an engine running at a 220 hp setting is
going to act like we just turned off ten air-con units. The freed up
torque drains will want to raise the engine rpms and horsepower but the
constant speed propeller, will automatically increase the pitch to
compensate for this increase of torque and hence keep the engine rpm as
desired. In the above example the engine continues to burn fuel at the
220 hp setting but the PSRU and hence propeller is seeing 280 hp.
Flight plans can be altered to take advantage of this. Go higher and
there is an even larger delta P across the exhaust turbine resulting in
more power for the same exhaust pressure.
Limiting design factors are the robustness of the PSRU, the support of
the overhanging T.C. pulley on the e-shaft, and the mechanisms to
disenage the exhaust turbine, supercharger and final T.C. belt drive.
These challenges are solvable with basic engineering. A more probematic
challenge is selecting the turbine. Aircraft turbines usually have a
high nickle content as they operate at higher power settings than
automobiles. Ditto an Inconel turbine wheel. Rough estimates indicate a
turbine wheel over 70 in dia. and an A/R above 1, in a TE-04 housing.
Custom turbines whether radially or axially might have to be the final
solution once the T.C. drive train proves to be realiable.
For turbo compound I believe we have to select the input speed and
ballpark the torque we are expecting and design backwards to size the
turbine. I assume we have to torque test the turbine and the traction
drive separately before adding it into the engine. Any Turbo compound
delivery producing less then a net 30hp is not worth the
weight/performance in IMHO. In that case a simpler turbocharger is the
better choice.
Doug in Japan
What was it I disagreed with Steve about Doug? :)
I was unaware of anything I said disagreed with what Steve said.
Thanks for the chart Doug. Very rare and candid data. Funny they don't put it
on their web site. I'll buy it. It looks reasonable and it is well matched to
the rotary. I converted it to HP and pounds per minute air flow so we could
compare apples to apples.
Paul Lamar
--
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2008 All world wide rights reserved.