Subject: Getting the e-shaft nut off.
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 8/31/2008, 10:34 AM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


     For the new guys.

        Harbor Freight has a 3/4 inch impact wrench for $70 bucks.
        A real bargain. It had this nut off in 15 seconds.

        A 1/2 inch will work with time but why fool around.
        It is well worth having the right tool.

        Next you smack it with a 10 pound sledge. No wimpy claw hammer will
        work.

        Paul Lamar

   If you have struck the flywheel or counter weight in order to break the
   taper fit. Or you have pried on the flywheel or counter weight, or the
   engine has been stored by sitting it on the flywheel. Or you did not
   install the new thrust assembly yourself or know for a fact that a new
   assembly has been installed. You must proceed as though the thrust
   assembly has been destroyed, and replace all of the pieces that touch
   the thrust bearings, and the thrust bearings. All of the resistance you
   feel when you pry on the flywheel, and all of the resistance to you
   pounding on the flywheel or counter weight, is generated by the thrust
   assembly, and the very tiny needle bearings.

   Remove the big nut with an impact gun. Screw the nut back onto the
   shaft, but leave a 1/8" gap to the flywheel or counter weight. Place the
   factory puller, or the Racing Beat puller, or a home made puller on the
   crank and tighten the bolts. If the wheel does not pop off, heat one
   spot on the flywheel near the crank very hot. The wheel will pop loose.
   If you have not reinstalled the big nut, the flywheel will come off with
   the puller attached and make a really ugly mark on the floor, or
   your foot.

   If you have no equipment to remove the nut. Drill through the nut in a
   flat, in line with the crank with a 1/8" bit. Make 3 or 4 holes, close
   together (touching).  Walk the nut off with a punch and light hammer.
   Keep the nut for removing the flywheel, and later to mount your big
   degree wheel. Buy a new nut or use a nut in good condition.

   Buy a new flat washer for the back of the front counter weight. A new
   thrust plate. A new washer for the front of the crank (thick) and two
   new bearings. Braze the old thrust plate to the bottom of your oil can
   to keep it from tipping over. Discard all or the other parts, so they
   can never find their way into another engine. The spacer sleeve can be
   used again.

   A failed bearing produces shards that will slip right through the bug
   screen on the oil pickup tube and lock up the oil pump. A common cause
   of death  in rebuilt street engines.

   Lynn E. Hanover

   Not all true Lynn. The flywheel and e-shaft combo has lots of
   inertia so
   striking it with a large hammer does not transfer much force to the
   needle
   thrust bearings. It excites the flywheel in its natural resonant
   vibratory mode
   which releases it from the e-shaft. I agree with everything else.

   Those needle thrust bearings are a lot tougher than they appear.
   Tracy ran his
   engine for 650 hours with the engine thrust bearing taking about 500
   pounds of
   axial force from the Ford helical sun gear. Indentations where
   formed in the
   e-shaft pilot bearing area by the spline on the PSRU input shaft. At
   that time
   there was no separate sun gear thrust bearing in the Ross PSRU he
   was using. Yes
   it destroyed the engine needle thrust bearing but it took a long
   time. The
   engine did not stop running.

   Perry Mick flew his direct drive ducted fan rotary for many hours
   with the
   engine needle thrust bearing taking about 500 pounds of prop thrust.
   Yes it
   destroyed the bearing but it took a long time. Bad 2nd gen bearing
   on the right
   with the new larger 3rd gen bearing on the left. Again the engine
   did not stop
   running. Those bearings have static ratings in the 10,000 to 20,000
   pound
   category. See the attached page.

   I am not saying they are up to a lot of continuous thrust while
   running at high
   RPM unless they are properly sized. It helps to use two or more back
   to back as
   that reduces the RPM of any one bearing. Tracy now uses three back
   to back to
   take the thrust from the helical sun gear in his new PSRUs. It is
   high RPM they
   don't like. They are very strong however in the static mode. I doubt
   seriously
   you can hurt them by one or two strikes on the flywheel. In most
   cases they are
   replaced anyway when a competent person does an overall as they are
   quite cheap.

   It appears this engine is going to need an over haul anyway as there
   was no
   compression in the front rotor.

   Paul Lamar

When you strike the flywheel in line with the crank, with enough force
to deform the tapered hole and release the taper, you deform the thrust
plate into a slightly conical shape. In this situation the bearings are
being stressed only on their very outside ends. You would then be
loading only a microscopic area of each roller, and the application book
has no table for that. Could be in the millions of pounds per square
foot. Same thing if you use pry tool or pound wedges under the flywheel
to load the taper while you beat on it.

Stick a pry bar under the flywheel near the crank and pry a bit, and the
springy feel is thrust plate flex.

If you have just a counter weight, you can bend the piece, as it is
quite malleable.

The rear thrust bearing in a street car will sometimes fail when a high
pressure clutch cover is installed. Nothing to do with the bearing
rating, just the thrust plate flex problem. If the mounting diameter had
been smaller, and, or the plate just a bit thicker, there would have
been no failures at all. Now comes the FD twin turbo engine with bigger
diameter thrust bearings. Why? Shorter lever arm on the thrust plate?

There is a proper method for removing these pieces. If you don't have
the factory puller, or the Racing Beat replica, you can make your own.
It will not hurt the crank, or the flywheel or the counter weight. If
you leave the nut on the crank but loose 1/8" it won't even hurt you.

For a junk engine coming apart for rebuild, fine beat the crap out of
it. But flush the thrust assembly as soon as the bolts are out of it.
And build a puller for servicing your airplane engines. There are so few
things that can go wrong inside this engine, that it seems a shame to
add one.

Lynn E. Hanover

You don't hit it in line with the e-shaft. You hit it on the outer edge.
I also disagree agree with your impact load calculations. Most of the impact is absorbed by the mass of the flywheel.

BTW the Rolex GT races is on the speed channel right now.
Nick Ham went from sixth to 2nd in the RX8 passing a bunch of V8 Pontiac's before the first turn :)

Paul Lamar

-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2008 All world wide rights reserved.