Subject: Coolant/rotor housings for aircraft rotary
From: Paul Lamar
Date: 9/18/2008, 8:47 PM
To: AAA Put this in the To box




Hi, Steve:

Interesting read about your testing back in the late 80's.  I guess this
is a classic exercise in compromise.  I can't use straight water as a
coolant in Canada since it would freeze half of the year.  Was there any
data to support a 50/50 mix of water and _Propylene_ Glycol instead of
water/ethylene?  I like the bio-degradable part, and the propylene
appears to have an edge with thermal conductivity.

The Red Line's Water Wetter came in with pretty good marks in this
report from 'Turbo':
http://www.turbomagazine.com/features/0703_turp_cooling_system_additives/index.html

The 2 page article sure clears up a lot of mystery for me about coolant
and additives.  I'm going to check out running a propylene/water mix
with additive.  A good 'Canadian winter' approach.

Greg in Canada

Water Wetter exist because racing organization do not allow any kind of
Glycol
as it makes the track slippery when it spills.

Pure Ethylene Glycol is not used in engines because it actually has a
higher
freezing point. Excerpt from my book.

"The freezing point of pure water is higher than some winter temperatures,
and
its boiling point is lower than the coolant temperature at which a hot
(but not
overheated) engine can operate. Ethylene Glycol has a higher boiling point
than
water. This is especially an advantage on today's hotter running vehicles
with
multiple accessories and air conditioning. One drawback to using 100%
Ethylene
Glycol is that Ethylene Glycol does not absorb as much heat as water does.
Another is that the freezing point will actually be higher when the
ethylene
glycol concentration is too high. Ethylene Glycol is mixed with water
until it
is the correct concentration. The factory radiator fill is usually about
50%
water and 50% Ethylene Glycol, which provides protection against freezing
down
to -34 F. The freezing point of a mixture with a 70% concentration of
ethylene
glycol would be -85 F. Its boiling point of 235 F is 11 F higher than
would be
provided by a 50-50 mixture. A 70% concentration is the maximum that
should be
used."

Extra aircraft recommends changing the coolant ratio twice a year in the
liquid
cooled Continental engine.

"The development of the exact shape of the internal water jacket around
the
Wankel combustion chamber is still in a state of change after 40 years of
development as more and more power is extracted from the rotary. Some
turbo
charged Mazda rotary engines used in drag racing cars burning alcohol and
nitrous oxide are generating up to 400 HP per rotor or 800 HP for a two
rotor
engine. Several modifications have been tried such as grooving the walls
of the
water jacket to improve the heat transfer from the metal to the liquid
coolant.
See Figure M 1 on the next page."

"We have discovered that this is unnecessary if you limit your engine to
around
240 HP for take off and cruise at 200 HP. However this feature may come in
handy
in the future when we get more experience with higher HP turbo charged
Mazda two
and three rotor engines in aircraft use. Particularly when air racing
rotary
powered airplanes. BTW  a P-port, 215 HP 2 rotor powered Velocity aircraft
averaged 205 MPH in a 500 mile cross country air race in  Augast 2007.
We do know the two rotor Mazda engine will currently generate about 200 HP
continuously with out melting or cracking"

The full power metal temperatures in the hottest parts of the rotor
housing are
actually about 100 F below the typical air cooled aircraft engine.

Mark Steitle is currently running thermocouples in his three rotor...
rotor
housings and is reporting no excessive temperatures.

Paul Lamar



Good background Paul.
Regarding the rotor cooling issue, on all the original Powersport
prototypes, we found it necessary to add extra cooling capability and
turbulent flow around the spark plug bosses for sustained high power
settings and max power climbouts.  Before we did it, we would get coking on
the inside of the rotor housing but we were changing so many variables at
the time, who knows the degree to which the mod alleviated that problem.

We shared this experience and the modifications with the Mazda factory guys
when they visited in the late 1980's/1990.  When the third gen turbo engines
later came out they used a little bit of this modification around the spark
plug boss--appeared to be a simple mill cut.  But we found it took more than
that to work meaningfully for sustained output rather than the compartively
short duty full power cycle seen in auto  applications.  We used  the
Bridgeport and some hand work to do the mod.  Probably was not even new at
the time and it or something akin was probably already in use by Jim D,
Roger M, Jim at RB, Mazdatrix and all other folks who have done serious
rotary engine development work.  Don't remember, but it may have been Roger
who initially passed on the tip.  He was always helpful in areas such as
this, and with other technical data r.e. oil correction factor/bob weights
for balancing, exhaust, etc.  Also assume what we did and passed on was
reasonably copied on all the "new" Powersport engines at Raytech and I think
you told me the Velocity engine experience you cite was one of these.

Greg, thanks for the background piece.  As I remember for winter operation
or extended flight at high alttitudes below freezing we settled on a
solution of  propylene/water/water wetter combination.  But always swapped
it out for straight water/Water Wetter as soon as conditions permitted.

Steve Beckham.

All new rotor housings have the mill mod.

I think coking on the rotor housing wear surface is caused by that crap in the
crankcase being used to lube the apex seals. I have been using Mobil 1 in my
rotaries for years and I see no ill effects. About five years ago we did a
simple test. Put a teaspoon full of oil in a cat food can and bake it for a half
hour at 500 F. You will be amazed at the difference in oils. Mobile one was head
and shoulders above mineral oils and not quite as good as turbine oil.

Now we have Idemitsu rotary engine oil available from Mazdatrix. Especially
formulated for the rotary. That should solve the problem forever.


 Rotary Performance
311 E. Buckingham Rd
Garland, TX 75040
Email: sales@rx7.com
Phone: 972-530-3335
Fax: 972-414-2779
Website: www.rx-7.com

RotorSports Racing
465 Russell Farm Rd.
Kannapolis, NC 28081
Email: info@rotorsportsracing.com
Phone: 704-933-6222
Website: www.RotorSportsRacing.com

G&S Racing
460 N.W. 68th Ave.
Ocala, FL 34482
Phone: 352-237-7955
Fax: 352-237-7955

AIM Tuning
298F Gasoline Alley
Indianapolis, IN 46222
Email: info@aimtuning.com
Phone: 317-381-0898
Website: www.aimtuning.com

Apollo America Corporation
2041 Rosecrans Ave. #355
El Segundo, CA 90245
(310) 563-1930

E-mail us at sales@idemitsu-usa.com

Hours of Operation:
7AM - 4:30PM PST Monday thru Friday

Paul Lamar
--

Steve,

Sounds like the weakest link in the engine is the area around the spark
plugs.

 I am working on designing a leading dual plug insert that can bolted to
the outer housing along with water seal and then TIG welded on the
inside elongated axial hole.  I  plan to have it constructed on the
school's CNC out of Stainless 303 and multi-grooved all surface that
contacts the coolant.  It will have a hole for a temp. probe but now I
am wondering if I should plan for a water fitting as well:)

I want about 300Hp out of my boosted 13B for at least 5 minutes on
takeoff and 200 to 210Hp. for continuous long distance cruise. These
figures neccessitate getting serious cooling happening.

I am searching all possible way to increase coolant flow and heat
transfer as well as taking RB advice about grooving the water housings
on the hot side. Running E-85-E90  also cools the engine 100 degrees F.
but don't know how that effects heat transfer around the plugs.  For
water cooling I think I have gone overboard with a K&W rammed air feed
feeding a dual pass heat exchanger (each 1.7 inch thick) and a total of
over 900 cubic inches excluding end tanks.  Oil heat exchangers  are two
20B units) totaling about 375 cubic inches of capacity.

The bottleneck as you well know is the rear rotor housing seeing higher
water temps. I hope I can mitigate that by moving more coolant through
the engine with a  better water pump, though the ultimate answer for the
Mazda two rotor engine is a redesign in where they introduce the water
in and remove it.  Something more akin to the four rotor technique
perhaps?

Have you given any thought at Power Sport to redirect the coolant via the
intermediate housing axially outwards?


Doug in Japan


Doug:  Since I sold Powersport after Everett died, I am not affiliated with
the "new" Powersport-- called Powersport Aviation.

Regarding your other points, our last prototype alumuinum engine used a
version of the configuration you describe.  It introduced cooled water into
the engine at the spark plug bosses via an aluminum billet manifold/jet
assembly bolted to the assembled power section housings that was sealed with
o rings. I provided a photo of this engine earlier.  It went with the
company assets as part of the sale.  If you don't have a copy let me know
and will see if I can get you some including the engine installed in the
RV-3. That engine was indexed 90 degrees with the spark plugs facing upward.
The cooling injector manifold/inlet  was a truss-like component that
provided some stability to the engine as well.  If my memory serves
correctly, the LeMans Mazda engine used a similar approach with a carbon
piece bolted to the assembled housings to provide added rigidity the the
engine while providing a place to bolt on various electrical components.
Our approach appeared to work but introduced excessive complexity and cost.
The pieces and machining were simply too costly, and together with the
torsional absorbers on the eccentric shaft, added excessive costs to the
engine that were simply too great to be passed on in a production version.
We went to all this trouble because based on our work up to that point that
indicated the limiting sustained power output of the engines was due in
large part to the heat flux in the region of the spark plug bosses. Another
factor was the lack of stability of our aluminum side housings.

The kind of power you are talking probably will undoubtedly be a learning
experience and a resource-burner on many levels.  The closest we came to
your projected output was using nitrous for the 1997 Sun'n Fun time-to-climb
competition in the unlimited class using our first Mazda two rotor
conversion engine prototype installed in Allan Tolle's RV-3.  The engine was
rated at 200 horsepower normally aspirated and with the nitrous system we
produced approx. 350 h.p.    The qualifying was from a standing start to
2000 feet.  We qualified #1, ahead of Dave Morss in the Thunder Mustang,
Jeff Ackland in the Legend and Tom Hann in the Steward S-51.  We toasted a
reduction gear bearing in that qualifying session.  The bearing worked when
the engine was normally aspirated and 200 h.p.  Although we managed to win
our class in the Sun 100 cross country race the next day, the damaged
bearing precluded competing in the finals for the time-to-climb.  We should
have been very competitive. For more background about this refer to Jack
Cox's report in Sport Aviaion, August 1997 beginning on page 43. I mention
this because our 350 horsepower output was for seconds rather than minutes
or hours. Based on our experience, it will be a challenge to reliably
sustain 300 h.p. in an aircraft application with the basic two rotor for
sustained periods.

For reference regarding alternative coolant routing, it is interesting to
look a the work of Curtiss-Wright, Mercedes and also the work on
circumferential rotor housing cooling by NSU and Citroen with cool water
introduced  first into the rotor housings.  And Ford's stillborn rotary
program was seriously looking at this approach as well.  Somewhere we have
an internal engineering report given to us by one of the folks involved with
the rotary project there.  I think the date was cica 1970.

Paul--regarding oils, from the very start we always used oil pre-mixed in
the fuel; never did use sump oil.  We tested a panopoly of different oils
mixed with the fuel, including Unocal AirKool and many other two stroke
motorcycle race oils.  Like you, found synthetic oil superior in every
respect except cost.  We were using Torco MPZ Synthetic at the end because
it worked and they were a sponsor when I raced cars.  But Mobil 1 is indeed
very good.  Idemitsu was not available at the time, or at least we were not
aware of it if it were.  Thanks again for the amazing resources you are
providing rotary folks.  I have been working on induction projects the last
several days and your nicely consolidated references are terrific.

Steve Beckham.

Steve do you have any metal temperature data within one mm or so near the combustion chamber of the area just below the lower spark plug?


Paul Lamar
-- 




Paul, the only numbers information I have regarding throchoid temperatures
in that region are from various technical papers and other published
references.  We would simply bone up on those available at that time and any
other information we could get our hands on, then discuss and plan different
approaches by order of priority we would test, and go from there with dyno
and flight tests and repeated disassembly, inspection, etc..  We never
attempted any instrumentation in that regard...just all empirical.

Unrelated:  have been studying further your home-grown slide throttle.
Something like that appears to have great advantage and really like how you
have positioned it right up next to the ports.  Also appealing is us not
having to go to all the trouble of machining and installing our throttle
shafts and plates in the throchoids where we've always placed them ...and
your location keeps everything as close as possible to the port and
hopefully minimizes any degradation we would experience with idle speed and
transitional part-throttle power setting responses.  Could not remember if
you told me whether your unit or other slide throttles have yet been dyno
and/or flight tested on the peripheral port Mazda-based aircraft engines?

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2008 All world wide rights reserved.