Subject: Cooling design for a Renesis in a Glass Goose
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 10/11/2008, 4:37 PM
To: AAA Put this in the To box


> Paul and Group,
>
> Thank you very much for you book, /"How to Cool Your Wankel". /It was > invaluable to me with my cooling design. You will certainly see that I > tried to apply the concepts shown in the book.
>
> I'm writing to solicit critiques on my cooling design. I'm building a > Glass Goose...a composite, two place, pusher, seaplane (see Glass > Goose (Small).jpg). I'm installing a Mazda Renesis four port rotary.
> I'm locating the stock RX8 oil cooler five inches in front of the > engine directly behind the intake (see Oil cooler location (Small).jpg).
>
> Water cooling will be accomplished via two 16" x 12" x 2" heat > exchangers located inside the pylon below the engine. I've built same > dimension cardboard boxes and place them outside of the pylons just to > show you where they will be located when installed on the inside on > the pylon (see Heat exchanger location (Small).jpg, Heat exchanger > location rear view (Small).jpg, and Heat exchanger located inside the > pylon (Small).jpg).
>
> Here is my cooling design using the principles of your book (Engine > Cooling Glass Goose.jpg). I'll be flying in Texas so since my main > objective is to not overheat I tended to design toward the more > generous side of any envelopes....intake sizes (30% of core face), > core sizes (600 to 800 ci. My design has 768 ci), etc.
>
> And, here are my questions:
>
> 1. Have I done it right? Too much? Not enough? I'm hoping you'll be > able to tell me I can use less (the intake area (see Intake area.jpg) > is about 4 inches too wide for my cowling. However, proper cooling in > all operations in the most important issue.
>
> 2. Seems like I've read on the site that if two heat exchangers are > used they should be in series rather than parallel. Is that correct?
>
> 3. If parallel is the answer, I would like to route water hoses to the > top of the right heat exchanger, out the bottom of the right heat > exchanger, to the bottom of the left heat exchanger, then out the top > of the left heat exchanger back to the engine. Will that work? Does a > heat exchanger care which way water runs through it?
>
> 4. One of the aerodynamic issues the Glass Goose has is maintaining > air flow down the side of the pylon. Current airplanes use VGs and/or > turning vanes to control the air down the side of pylon. As a > byproduct or advantage of this cooling design, I'm hoping that the > turbulent air coming out of the cores along the pylon may help hold > the air to the pylon. What do you think?
>
> 5. Do you think the prop may pull some air through the heat exchangers > to help cooling on the ground? Do I need a fan in this design? Where > would it go?
>
> Do you know where I can get custom louvered grills?
>
> Thank you very much for your consideration and comments,
>
> Sandy McNabb
>
>
> I like your drawings Sandy. Very well done.
>
> Q2 should be in parallel.
>
> Q4 since the top speed is  low the best idea IMHO is to position two > 19 by 16 by 3/4 inch thick cores on the outside of the pylon and tilt > them out to form scoops.  Real quick and easy to do. Use a boundary > layer splitter plate about 1 inch out from the pylon surface.
>
> I know this is a radical idea but it will work and has worked for > other people when mounted on the bottom of the fuselage.
> Check it out in my book.
>
> Your picture of the rads mounted on the outside triggered this idea in > my feeble brain :) We have gone around and around on cooling the Goose > and this is the best idea anybody has come up with so far IMHO.
> The drag on the aft pylon is high anyway so this will not add much more.
>
> Q5 yes the prop will help.
>
> I'll send some more ideas in the next message as there is no room in > this one left.
>
> We will discuss plumbing details when we come up with an acceptable > solution for you.
>
> Paul Lamar
>
> Sorry. I made a word error in my previous posting. In question #3, it > should be "If series is the answer,....."
>
> Sandy.
>
> No problem Sandy. Here are the best of the old ideas.
> The main objection was loss of cargo room.
>
> I'll do a 3D of the latest idea I mentioned in the message above.
>
>
> Paul Lamar


Sandy, The problem using the front cowl scoop is there is not enough room
along side the engine when the exhaust system, motor mounts and alternator
are mounted to get the cooling air down and back to the internally mounted
rads. Make sure you mock up the exhaust system, motor mounts and alternator
before you cast the installation in concrete.

I am still working on the new Goose 3D.

Paul Lamar

Here are the 3D's.
IMHO this is the easiest and most likely to work.
You can tilt the rads in and out to increase or decrease cooling.

BTW the area behind the engine in the pylon is ideal for an exhaust ejector
(AKA augmenter). Given the prop will chop up the noise I think you can get
away without a muffler. You will have to line the pylon with fiber frax and
thin SS.

Paul Lamar

Paul,

I've had a serious discussion with Tom Scott, our Glass Goose kit
manufacturer, about the rads on the outside of the pylon. He is somewhat
encouraging about the radiators on the outside of the pylon and sees the
simplicity of installation and effectiveness in cooling. However, as you
would suspect, the pylon and prop areas are known to be very, very sensitive
to air flow. Tom spent ten years refining the pylon to get to the point that
it has satisfactory aerodynamic performance. He is very concerned about the
affects of the externally mounted rads on the pylon air flow. He points out
that I'm starting out with an aircraft with known aerodynamic
characteristics. Then, because I'm installing a Renesis (which he likes),
I'll be building a smaller, different shaped cowling, and if I put the rads
on the outside of the pylon wall and incorporated turning vanes, I will have
made three significant aerodynamic changes to the aircraft. If it all works
out well, then great! If I get some adverse aerodynamics, then were do I
start to correct the problem? His point is....one change at a time to see
the affects on the airplane. So, with your patience, I would like to pursue
my original cooling design and ask for your critique. I'm disappointed that
I won't be mounting the rads on the outside of the pylon at this time, but
what Tom says makes sense to me.

New question #6: I think I've read that you don't think louvered grills on
the rads would be necessary....true?

Thank you very much for your consideration and comments,


Sandy McNabb
Glass Goose with a Renesis


The fundamental problem with internal rads is there is not enough room
around the engine, the wing and wing spar to get the required
ducting down through there to feed the internal mounted rads on the
inside walls of the aft fuselage. That will become apparent once you get the side mounted alternator and exhaust system on the engine. The ONLY choice it to feed them with some sort of scoops mounted between the wings on the outside
sides of the fuselage. You can make them tall and skinny or you
can make them large and round. If you make them large and round
you will intrude on the cargo space with the internal ducting
required.

Kit builders never want you to change anything :) The original problem
goes back to the basic concept of the airplane. People are too  wide
and the distance from the back of the cockpit to the prop is too short.
That means the sides of the fuselage go back at too sharp of an angle.
Separation will occur. Turbulators or vortex generators mounted
on the sides of the fuselage will help mitigate but not eliminate
the problem. The entire fuselage might work better if totally redesigned
to the pollywog shape but that was never done. The bi plane configuration
aggravates the situation as it constrains the flow to 2D. IMHO I will go
out on a limb and say the only effect of the out side mounted rads
will be an increase in frontal area and any devices now on the sides
of the fuselage will not be necessary.

The air coming out of the proposed louvered grills will affect the flow as well.

Perhaps you can make a half mock up and check it on the back of a pick up
truck. I suggested that to Scott Gettings when I saw his airplane and he may have built the full scale test  mock up all ready.

Another option is increase the length of the cowl and put the rads
up in front of the engine. I think Rino flew his airplane with that configuration. I don't know if it cooled or not.

This airplane holds the worlds record for ACRE volume of cooling discussion :)

Paul Lamar


Yes I have the mockup built, with water pressure measurement ports, etc.  I haven't built the radiator/vanes or "flown" the whole thing on top of my truck yet.  I'll see if I can dig up a picture.

This delay is because my regular job has just taken all of my time.  Maybe Sandy can come down for a weekend and we'll do the whole thing!

Scott  Gettings


-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2008 All world wide rights reserved.