You are paying big bucks $195 for that BMW water pump cartridge Doug.
At that price it should be 6 times better than the stock 2nd gen
Mazda cartridge at $30 :)
"Stewart Stage 1 water pumps, which cost only $69.95 mail order, also out
perform our leading competitor. The same laboratory tests proved the
Stewart
Stage 1 Chevrolet Small Block water pump compared to the pump our leading
competitor offers:
* 67% more pressure @ 6,000 RPM
* 29% more flow @ 6,000 RPM
* 47% less horsepower loss @ 100 GPM"
Why did you not buy a Chevy cartridge at $69.95 since you are building
your own housing anyway?
"Flow in GPM (Gallons Per Minute)
RPM Competitors Stewart Stage 1
1000 17..............18
1500 25 .............32
2000 34 .............42
2500 42 .............55
3000 51 .............65
3500 59 .............77
4000 68 .............90
4500 76 ............101
5000 85 ............112
5500 93 ............122
6000 102 ...........132
6500 110 ...........138
7000 119 ...........148
7500 127 ...........157
8000 139 ...........158"
Looks like you can run the Chevy pump at 3000 RPM
and double the stock Mazda flow. Pump HP consumption should
be way down If Stewart is not lying :)
Mount the pump down low on the side of the
engine as severe damage is done to the pump if
the water level is low.
Paul Lamar
Paul,
Why did I buy the BMW design?
1. Design and size. Data from a company that has a stellar reputation in
cooling large horsepower engines has reliable test data at those power
settings.
2. I am very familiar with this type of pump impeller and its cavitation
characteristics. Expect to see more of this type of pump in the near
future. Yes the impeller is stainless and it is pricey to machine.
Machining the housing however is dirt simple compared to milling out a
concave shape and shaping a water course out of a billet or casting an
housing.
3. The BWM design fits into my configuration more elegantly. Down low and
compact. The airplane cowling then becomes more streamline and hose runs
less convoluted.
4. If possible I don't like to chop and weld an existing casing. Sure
it can work but it involves a lot of testing and confirmation time.
5. Other alternates including Chevy, KSE, and Ford are WAY overkill and
are designed for casings with dual tangential outlets to handle the huge
flows. Choking a water pump flow can cause cavitation as surely as
having a sharp bend right near the inlet. Only so much coolant can be
crammed through our engine passages. Bigger is not necessarily better.
Bypassing the extra flow would work but why waste needless HP pumping
water in a pipe to nowhere and heating it up at the same time? I think
we can agree the flow balance and proper flow curve over the whole range
is important.
6. I like products in hand to study. If I don't like what I see I can
always sell it on E-Bay.
7. Cost is always time multiplied by resources. I have said this many
many times. If you look at a project from concept to finish, part cost
pales in significance compared to time in research, sourcing, test
confirmation and tool investment or out sourcing. I do this kind of
stuff for a living and if the engine didn't come under the category of
'hobby' I would have fired me long ago for wasting so much time:)
Doug in Japan
I am in Catalina Doug on the EeePC
that is just a cartridge and not a complete pump.
the water comes in between the impeller and the pulley so it is not
easy to make a housing.
The Mazda pump is easier to make a housing for as the water comes
in from the front side of the impeller.
I suspect the cheaper Chevy pump uses the same technology but I
don't know if it has an SS impeller.
Paul Lamar
Paul,
Lucky you. Are you uplinking through a satelite or cell phone?
I saw some EEE PC today in Tokyo but it is loaded with Windows XP. home
version. They don't offer Linux here. This computer is a perfect
size for the technical school in Nepal.
Cheers
Doug
The Linux GUI is designed for students. Very easy to learn with no
instructions.
Also I don't think the windows version comes with out the hard disk and
the 40G solid state memory. windows is apparently too large.
Paul Lamar
Paul
About the bimmer pump. The casing is fairly cylindical and as you
correctly stated the water comes in at a tangent and as shown in the
first picture it is a rectangular opening almost straight down. The
water exits straight out the back 180 degrees indexed from the outlet
which could be a good thing depending on where the pump is mounted. I
originally thought the pump housing was an intergal part of the engine
block but while looking at these pictures it appears it may be a bolt
on. Anyone know?
Doug in Japan
Doug,
Housing is part of the front timing cover. This is the same pump we will be
using as well. Makes packaging a custom pump very compact.
Larry
Larry,
Thanks. Sorry I couldn't stop by and see you last week. Next time.
Is it possible you could direct me to someplace where I can buy a scrap
front bimmer timing cover? This would save me some design time if I
could measure it directly. The water pump housing area looks like it has
a radial cut from the back side to direct the water out so for our use
that would result in the need of a backing plate. I am thinking of
making that backing plate and outlet pipe such so that the flow is
directed to where the freeze plug currently is. The stock water block
inlet is then covered with a plate.
Doug
--
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2008 All world wide rights reserved.