Subject: Aluminum rotors in charge cooled engines and the NTSB.
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 10/21/2008, 1:47 PM
To: AAA Put this in the To box

   OK. So for the sake of discussion, what happens if you take one of
   those single rotor 55 hp wankels from Renntech and go with the BE/AL
   rotor. They already run at about 10-5 or 11 grand. What kind of
   output are we looking at? 110 hp? Can you cool it? How about
   bearings? I agree that you can create a light-weight powerplant
   with high power density. What I worry about are cooling and
   silencing issues. The 65 hp Rotamax Wankels require a 32-36 inch
   stainless exhaust pipe before you get to the muffler. You're going
   to have to gear it. How much does the expense of the reduction unit
   go up with the increase in rotor rpm? What is the cheapest way to
   do a technology demonstrator? They already use Wankels for drone
   engines. I wonder if DARPA would be interested in a techology
   demonstrator engine(s)? They might also be interested in a compound
   version - high output and lower fuel consumption.

   best,

   george W.

   I think you mean AIXRO rotary kart engines. Renntech is just the U.S.
   distributor for those kart engines. All bets are off as that is a
   charged cooled
   engine. Charged cooled rotors typically run 650 F or higher. I don't
   have any
   specific data on the AIXRO rotor temperature but I am willing to bet
   they have
   not measured it yet. It is a real instrumentation challenge to
   measure the rotor
   temperature with slip rings and all that stuff.

   IMHO you need an oil cooled rotor to make Be/Al rotors work.
   I am not a fan of charged cooled rotors. If it were me I would copy
   Mazda's oil
   cooled rotors for all rotary engines except for the cheapest low
   duty versions.

   Where did you hear that about the Rotamax muffler? Rotamax engines
   have run with
   much shorter exhaust pipes. Come to think of it I have not heard
   from them since
   they crashed the Sadler. Also a charged cooled rotor design.

   Paul Lamar

   ------------------------------------------------------------------------
   NTSB Identification: CHI08LA274
   14 CFR Part 91: General Aviation
   Accident occurred Wednesday, September 03, 2008 in Findlay, OH
   Aircraft: Sadler Vampire, registration: N333SV
   Injuries: 1 Minor.

   This is preliminary information, subject to change, and may contain
   errors. Any
   errors in this report will be corrected when the final report has
   been completed.

   On September 3, 2008, at 1257 eastern daylight time, a Sadler
   Vampire, N333SV,
   received substantial damage on impact with terrain during a forced
   landing. The
   airplane experienced a total loss of engine power after takeoff from
   Findlay
   Airport, Findlay, Ohio. Visual meteorological conditions prevailed
   at the time
   of the accident. The 14 CFR Part 91 test flight was not operating on
   a flight
   plan. The pilot sustained minor injuries. The local flight was
   originating at
   the time of the accident.

   ------------------------------------------------------------------

   I found some correspondence between Rotamax and a European firm.
   Rotamax indicated the 32-36 inch exhaust length before the muffler.
   They implied that thicker stainless wall was preferable and that
   using insulating tape near the exhaust manifold was useful. Also
   found a preliminary report from a college engineering project using
   the single rotor rotamax intended for an aircraft application.
   Rotamax donated the engine to the school and also supplied two of
   the Hushpower II mufflers as a starting point. The entire system
   was assembled on a test rig and run. Unfortunately, we won't see
   any results until a new class takes over and continues the project.
   I've been in direct contact with Rotamax since the Findlay incident
   and they are waiting until they see the results of the NTSB report.
   I don't blame them for waiting before making comments. This is the
   only Rotamax incident of this type I'm aware of. On the other hand,
   the Sadler prototype probably had more hours on it than any of the
   other test vehicles. Sadler hasn't made any public acknowledgement
   of the incident either. They do have a backup position, having
   originally flown with the Rotamax 4-stroke. You're quite right
   about the Aixro being charge cooled. Perhaps the Mazda mill with
   lightened rotors is the way to go for testing. To the best of my
   knowledge Phantom has dropped their X-40 development using the Aixro
   engine. There was an Asian mini-helicopter company working on
   something similar and I haven't hear of any further developments
   from them either.

   best,

   George W

   I think you mean Rotax 4-stroke. The final NTSB report could take years.
   I doubt the NTSB will spend much money figuring out what happen as
   those types
   of non fatal crashes have super low priority.

   One NTSB rotary powered Coot fatal crash report was totally
   erroneous. They took
   the engine to a Mazda dealer and he reported the reason the engine
   stopped was
   the apex seal oil metering pump was removed :) I and others tried to
   get the
   NTSB to correct the report and they stone walled us on it. Robin
   even knew the
   NTSB board member John Goglia and I contacted him directly. No
   response. The
   NTSB report in this case is pure fiction. Notice the apex seal oil
   metering pump
   has absolutely nothing whatsoever to do to do with the rotor or main
   bearings.
   If indeed the engine seized the pilot probably took off with no oil
   in the
   crankcase as as the flight was only 1 minuted or so. The report
   implies the
   missing metering pump was the cause of the engine seizer. One guy
   flew his
   rotary powered airplane from Tennessee to NY without adding oil to
   the fuel
   tank. I am sure Ken Welter has some comments on this accident.

   Paul Lamar

   -------------------------------------------------------------------
   SEA02LA072

   HISTORY OF FLIGHT

   On April 21, 2002, approximately 1305 Pacific daylight time, a
   Gallagher Taylor
   "Coot" experimental amateur-built airplane, N41RG, was destroyed by
   impact
   forces and a post-crash fire in a collision with terrain following a
   loss of
   engine power and subsequent loss of control near Creswell, Oregon.
   The private
   pilot-in-command, who was the airplane's sole occupant, was fatally
   injured in
   the crash. Visual meteorological conditions were reported at Mahlon
   Sweet Field,
   Eugene, Oregon, at 1254, and no flight plan had been filed for the
   14 CFR 91 flight.

   Witnesses at the airport who were observing the pilot's first flight
   in the
   accident aircraft reported that shortly after takeoff, the engine
   began to run
   rough and subsequently quit. The aircraft then nosed down and
   collided with the
   terrain in an open field about one mile west of the airport and
   caught fire. The
   flight duration prior to the accident was approximately 1 minute and
   15 seconds.

   PERSONNEL INFORMATION

   At the time of the accident, the pilot held a private pilot
   certificate for
   single-engine land aircraft. The pilot's flight logbook was not made
   available
   for review, however, during the pilot's last Federal Aviation
   Administration
   medical examination, he reported a total flight time of 250 hours,
   with zero
   hours in the preceding six months.

   The pilot was issued a third class medical certificate on June 14,
   2000, with a
   restriction that he must wear corrective lenses.

   AIRCRAFT INFORMATION

   The accident pilot, who did not hold a mechanic or
   repairman/experimental
   aircraft builder certificate (according to the FAA airman registry),
   had bought
   the aircraft from a previous owner. The engine installed at the time
   the
   accident pilot bought the aircraft, an IO-360 series aircraft
   engine, was
   subsequently replaced with a Mazda 13B rotary automobile engine. An
   airworthiness inspector from the FAA's Portland, Oregon, Flight
   Standards
   District Office (FSDO) had approved the automotive engine installation.

   According to the FAA aircraft registry, the aircraft was issued an
   experimental/amateur-built airworthiness certificate on June 7,
   2001, and an
   airworthiness update was accomplished on September 24, 2001. An FAA
   inspector
   reported that the accident flight was the pilot's first flight in
   the accident
   aircraft.

   Prior to the maiden flight, witnesses at the airport reported that
   the pilot had
   accomplished several high speed taxi tests. During one of these taxi
   runs, the
   aircraft was observed to have inadvertently lifted off the taxiway.
   The aircraft
   then landed hard and ran off the taxiway damaging one of the
   airplane's main
   landing gears. The pilot also reported that the airplane had been
   pulling to the
   right during these taxi tests.

   The pilot's wife and several people at the airport reported that during
   conversations with the pilot, he had been trying different fuel/oil
   mixtures for
   the engine. Each time the pilot ran the engine, the spark plugs
   would get fouled.

   METEOROLOGICAL INFORMATION

   The 1254 Eugene, Oregon, airport hourly METAR weather observation
   reported
   conditions there as: wind from 350 degrees true at 9 knots;
   visibility 10
   statute miles; overcast at 3,200 feet; temperature 13 degrees C; dew
   point 8
   degrees C; and altimeter setting 30.19 inches Hg.

   WRECKAGE AND IMPACT INFORMATION

   The accident site was located in a level open field covered with
   short grass
   approximately one mile west of the Creswell Airport. The fuselage
   was completely
   consumed and destroyed by the post-crash fire. Both the left and
   right wings
   were laying flat on the ground and oriented in place to the
   fuselage. Fire had
   consumed the majority of both wings out to the tips.

   The engine was positioned at the nose of the airplane. The nose of
   the engine
   was pointing straight up. The propeller remained attached to the
   crankshaft.

   FAA inspectors who responded to the accident site and performed an
   on-site
   examination of the aircraft wreckage reported that they found no
   evidence of
   malfunctions in the aircraft's airframe or flight controls.

   MEDICAL AND PATHOLOGICAL INFORMATION

   The Chief Deputy Medical Examiner from the Lane County Health and
   Human Services
   Medical Examiner's Office reported that the pilot's cause of death
   was due to
   blunt force injuries in chest and abdomen.

   Samples for toxicology were sent to the Federal Aviation
   Administration Civil
   Aeromedical Institute, Oklahoma City, Oklahoma, for analysis. The
   results of the
   analysis were negative.

   ADDITIONAL DATA/INFORMATION

   Following the FAA inspectors' on-site wreckage examination, the
   aircraft's
   engine was moved to the service facility of Kiefer's Eugene Mazda in
   Eugene,
   Oregon, where a disassembly examination of the engine was conducted
   by a Mazda
   service technician under the supervision of the FAA inspectors on
   April 23,
   2002. The disassembly examination disclosed that the engine was
   seized, with
   both rotors, an oil pump, and the rotor bearing surfaces exhibiting
   galling and
   burn damage consistent with oil starvation. The inspectors reported
   that a
   metering oil pump, which supplies oil to the combustion chambers,
   was noted to
   be missing from the engine installation, with its drive absent. The
   Mazda
   service technician reported that further examination disclosed that
   the oil
   injection nozzles associated with the missing metering oil pump were
   also
   missing from the combustion chambers, and that the nozzle holes were
   plugged
   with a non-metallic substance.
   --------------------------------------------------------------------------

   you're right, Paul.   I did mean that the backup  engine for the
   Sadler is a Rotax.  Fluctuations in currency  rates have made the
   cost of imported engines go up.  The theoretical  lower cost of U.S.
   produced engines in such an environment is a plus.  the problem is
   getting the engines certified for LSA  use,  a problem for which I
   don't claim to have any expertise.  You noted some time back that
   because of the nature of the loss of the prototype (fire), we may
   never be able to determine the actual cause of the engine failure.
   This is why I threw out a few questions about the incident.  If they
   don't have documented reasons, then you try to determine failure
   modes consistant with the report of the pilot.  Since we haven't
   seen a statement from the pilot, we don't have much to go on.  I'm
   assuming that your aversion to charge-cooled rotors relates to VE?
   and heating of the intake charge?  Is there any reason to believe
   that with a lighter rotor and higher revs that the ability of the
   charge to take on internal heat is not linear with the revs?  What
   I'm really asking is whether there is any  reason that a lightened
   charge-cooled engine  would not also benefit from the lighter rotor?

   best,

   George W

My aversion is one of durability. Mainly the rotor bearing. It MUST be cooled or it will fail. Charge cooled rotors run 650 F. Even an oil cooled rotor runs 500 F. Wankel Gmbh Germany came up with a scheme to water cool the E-shaft which they claimed solved the problem.

http://www.rotaryeng.net/Wankel-CC-paper.pdf

They failed financially before they could implement this.

Charge cooled engines use rollers for the critical rotor bearing and these too are susceptible to failure at over 500 F. To my knowledge nobody has tried silicon nitride roller bearings that are good to about 1000 F. The last time I looked at a Rotamax rotor steel roller bearing the cage was made from composite. No way is that going to work.

The low VE is also a definite negative.

The success of the light weight, all aluminum Rotamax, does not hinge on LSA certification. The displacement of the engine is the same as the Mazda. Therefore if properly designed it could easily compete in the experimental market for much faster airplanes than LSA. This would give Rotamax valuable R&D at no direct cost to them. Once the successful hours are accumulated then try to certify for LSA. Also don't try to go off in all directions at once such as EFI and computer IGNs. Keep it simple. Use proven carburetters and perhaps a proven mag or two.

Wankel rotary engines look simple but designing a successful version is far from simple. Many large corporations with tons of money have failed. My advice is copy the Mazda down to the last detail. Then try to improve it AFTER you have a substantial cash flow.

Paul Lamar
-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2008 All world wide rights reserved.