I believe the green :(ethylene glycol) is superior to propylene
glycol. When Dave ? (memory laps) had to land on the freeway near
Bishop, CA a couple of years ago, we had a good discussion on
coolants. As I recall the major problem I found with propylene
glycol is that its viscosity increases drastically at low
temperatures which can essentially block coolant in the radiator and
stop or restrict circulation.
Joel
Over the Hill Materials Engr.
Well, there is ethylene glycol/water
propylene glycol/water (like sierra brand and others)
and the nearly pure propylene glycol like Evans.
Each has advantages and disadvantages. IMHO, EG/H2O performs the best
of the 3 in most aspects (best balance of specific heat, viscosity,
boiling temp and freezing protection).
PG/water is pretty close in all those aspects and has the sole advantage
of being much less toxic. This is what I currently use. The slight
loss of performance is not a factor and I always seem to be doing
something that involves coolant and spill some. Also, I don't know how
to get rid of the old stuff other than pour it down the drain, so I use
PG/water for environmental reasons.
Straight PG, a.k.a. Evans, has the advantage of an ultra high boiling
point which allows for a lower pressure system and some protection from
boil-over. It probably also has superior corrosion protection but the
disadvantage of making field repairs more difficult It probably also
eliminates nucleate boiling which the company claims is an advantage but
Paul and others including me believe it to be a disadvantage. The
viscosity is significantly higher than the other coolants which is
probably the most significant issue.
While it is true that I was using Evans at the time of my engine-out,
that had nothing to do with the root cause (other than I believed I
could use a 7 psi cap with it, but that turned out to be insufficient).
Evans would probably work just fine in my current set-up.