Subject: Cowl flaps and exit air
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 12/21/2008, 4:47 PM
To: AAA Put this in the To box




    Hi Paul and all

    I'm working on the exit air strategy on our Glasair SII RG. Renesis
    4 port

    I'm comfortable that a good cowl flap/s can increase exit area
    substantially
    from the minimum required at cruise so I'm not worried about maximum
    cooling
    etc. it's the minimum area to reduce drag that I am considering here.

    Is there an agreed ratio of inlet area to minimum outlet area?

    I measured a Glasair 3 and the minimum outlet  (Cowl flap closed)
    appear to
    be approx 130cm^2 and the inlet approx 180cm^2 (There are two of each).
    So Outlet = ~0.75 x Inlet (again with cowl flap closed)

    Now I understand Boyles law would dictate that volume is going to
    increase
    with temperature, and this could be calculated, however I'm not sure
    as to
    the relationship between inlet velocity to outlet velocity.

    Is there a rule of thumb for inlet to outlet?

    Thanks

    Steve Izett
    Perth Western Australia

    Yes there is. I think it is something like .8. The idea here is to
    recover
    some of the waste energy in the cooling air and squirt it out the back
    to provide thrust. Hopefully this will off set the cooling drag.
    I discussed this a bit in my book "How to Cool Your Wankel".
    Here is a graphic of a P51 system so designed. This is why it is widely
    thought that a liquid cooled system with a dedicated exit duct can
    be lower drag than an air cooled engine cooling system.

    Here is a bit of theory from Hoerner's book "Fluid Dynamic Drag".
    "V" is the flight speed of the aircraft.
    "w" is the speed of the exit air.
    In order to get thrust and reduce drag this ratio must be in the
    range of zero to .15. If V is 200 MPH then the exit speed
    of the cooling air should be .15 = w/V or w should be less
    than 30 MPH. To me this is counter intuitive. I would think
    the exit speed of the cooling air should be greater than the
    forward speed of the aircraft. Here are the first two pages and
    definitions of Chapter IX  from Hoerner's book.

    However the exact optimum exit area is highly dependent  on many things.
    That is the reason airplanes use adjustable cowl flaps.
    You close the flaps until the engine is still running at an acceptable
    temperature. Only one rotary installation I know about uses
    thermocouples
    located near the combustion chamber and that is Mark Steitle's
    3 rotor powered Lancair ES. It is probably possible that the coolant
    will boil before the metal temperature in this area reaches the 500 F
    limit so coolant temperature alone could be the real limit. One reason
    to use as high a pressure cap setting as possible as this will raise
    the boiling temperature. In an air cooled engine of course metal
    temperature
    is the only limit.

    The exit duct itself is probably the primary factor. If you
    are dumping hot air out of the heat exchanger into the engine
    compartment
    it must make its way out past the engine and gather it self together
    just before the exit slot. There is an efficiency associated with this
    process.  There could also be leaks in the cowling which is highly
    likely. The area around the exit slot in the cowling should have
    a large radii to enhance the flow.

    -------------------------------------------------

    This is a really interesting graph from Hoerner that sums up the entire
    cooling drag situation. It is obvious from the graph why a thin heat
    exchanger
    is desirable as long as it does not increase the aircraft total frontal
    area. In other words getting the heat exchanger basically mounted inside
    the existing cowl. The thinner the H.E. the lower the drag.

    The other very very interesting part of it is the shape of the
    diffuser itself
    shown in the lower diagram. That old fashioned shape of diffuser has
    been
    discredited by Kuchemann & Weber in their book Aerodynamics of
    Propulsion
    published in 1955 and discussed in my book. For some strange reason
    Hoerner did
    not talk to K & W during WW II. Apparently Hoerner did not have a
    need to know :)

    The other thing missing in the lower diagram is the boundary layer
    air bleed.
    Don't copy it.

    Paul Lamar

Thanks Paul

I’ll work on a minimum exit area of approx 0.8 inlet area and stream
line the flow as much as is possible.
I take it that the exit duct should also approximate a trumpet to
re-accelerate the air prior to exit.
On your thoughts in relation to Hoerner -
“In order to get thrust and reduce drag this ratio must be in the range
of zero to .15. If V is 200 MPH then the exit speed of the cooling air
should be .15 = w/V or w should be less
than 30 MPH.”
His 0.15 = w/V makes sense since ‘w’ relates to the inlet side of the
heat exchanger, my question is - should w(out)/V = 1 for lowest drag?


PS
Paul, as we approach the end of another year, I’d like to thank you
sincerely for this forum which has aided me significantly over the past
couple of years with my project.
I appreciate the thinking and the what must be significant time that you
give to it and your web site.
My hope is that your labor and energy will pay off in the form of a
Rotary Turbo Compound breakthrough “in practice” in the not to distant
future.
Thanks again.

Steve Izett

Your welcome Steve. Merry Christmas.
See you in January. It may be three of us as an airline lady pilot
friend of ours may be coming along.

Paul Lamar

The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2008 All world wide rights reserved.