Paul,
I hate it when people start talking about global warming, since opinions
are generally based on political prejudice, not deep knowledge of the
subject and of the methods used to evaluate the available evidence
(which I believe is is very complicated and ambiguous). But I think that
for the sake of clarity it would be helpful
/always/ to append a word
like "anthropogenic" or "human-caused" or what have you, because what is
usually in dispute is not whether the polar ice cap is melting, but what
human activity has to do with it. It would also be helpful, when
characterizing as a "hoax" the opinion that some part of warming is
human-caused, to clarify the motive(s) of the purported hoaxers. The
word "hoax" implies an ulterior motive which, as far as I know, has not
been explained. In fact, the whole anti-anthropogenic-warming case would
be much more strongly argued in terms of the nefarious motives of the
proponents rather than with
/ad hominem/ characterizations of their
scientific credentials, which the average person is no better equipped
to judge than he is to judge the plausibility of anthropogenic warming.
It is possible that a vast number of scientists (even excluding
environmental thinkers without, say, PhD-level scientific training)
might be caught up in a sort of apocalyptic hysteria (there is a certain
seductiveness in apocalyptic predictions, as we saw in the run-up to
Y2K), or even in some sort of group think, but it is at least as likely
that they are not, and that a reasonable and informed analysis of the
evidence allows of different, and contradictory, conclusions. What is so
annoying about these discussions is that they are usually conducted on
about the intellectual level of Intelligent Design vs. The Democrats.
Harumph.
Peter Garrison
--
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2008 All world wide rights reserved.