Subject: Everett Hatch and Steve Beckham rubber couplings and rotary engines
From: Rotary Engine
Date: 2/25/2009, 3:42 PM
To: AAA Put this in the To box

Paul, thanks so much for distributing to folks the references regarding the
use of pendulous dampers to control torsional vibration in rotary engine
installations.  Your email references include my photo of our last planetary
reduction gear with pendulous dampers as installed in the RV-3  with
SuperLight engine circa 1994 a few hours following Alrlington fly-in. In
this email you are correct about costs being one of the major factors why we
switched from penduous dampers/absorbers to a torsionally stiff reduction
gear design with no dampers/absorbers/isolators.  Our tests and subsequently
those of others conducted on the production version of our reduction gear
show it eliminated the need for any type of dampers/absorbers or isololating
material such as rubber and at a fraction of the cost of dampers/absorbers.

Your inclusion of the Pratt &Whitney/ Curtiss-Wright work is great.  We used
their calculations, which began with E.S. Taylor's ground-breaking work in
the 1930's, and later Chilton, Hartog and others to design our dampers.
Mark Hatch ran most of these numbers for us in those calculations.  Another
good resource for anyone serious about this issue from a design standpoint
should get "Handbook On Torsional Vibration."  by the British Internal
Combustion Engine Research Association (BICERA).  Hard to find but it is the
bible and invaluable.  Everett always maintained the work of Taylor, Chilton
and the others was one of the key engineering accomplishments that won WWII.
The BICERA book also includes the subsequent work of Chilton, Hartog and
others addressing torsional vibration control for reciprocating engines. I
found our copy, a used 1958 edition, at Powell's books in Portland  in the
1980's and a nice touch  inside the front cover is a stamped "Property of
Republic Aviation Corporation".

Based on our experience, it is highly recommended that any aircraft builder
planning to fly behind a rotary engine do his or her homework to at least
understand the basics of what is going on in order to make the best informed
decision.  This is critical in order to promote long term flight safety.  We
won't know what we've really got on any of these units until we have
thousands of hours documented high power setting/high output service on
individual units.

In case it might be helpful or of interest, below is a brief summary of our
work and conclusions regarding planetary reduction gears and torsional
vibration alternatives (including rubber)
based on our findings 1985-1997.
-------------------------------------------
We found that properly designed and built pendulous absorbers really do
"absorb".  Based on the dyno and flight test program, the
pendulous/absorbers dampers designed for our last-gen planetary reduction
gear we made in the early 1990's worked very well. Our experience was that
true pendulous absorbers engineered for a rotary engine-specific application
(and direct drive engines with longer, more flexible crankshafts) put them
in a different league than rubber isolators.  From 1986-1995 our reduction
gears were all planetary.  We designed, built, dyno and flight tested
various planetary units using standard rotation


Early models used different
designs and types of rubber isolators.  This included various materials and
durometers.  We found that all of these "rubber" materials  deteriorate with
age and temperature and required too much range of motion.  The conclusion
was that they were not suitable for our design goal of an infinite life gear
set for a two rotor engine.  We also designed and built subsequent units
using the automotive and truck-based production gearsets available at the
time (Ford C-6 and several GM).

The only planets available then that solved
the problems were the straight-cut gears produced by Allison for their high
torque/hp automatic transmissions.  They completely eliminated the end
thrust bearing problems inherent with helical cut gears run at high
sustained output.  When we developed the lower cost Mazda conversion engine,
we had to come up with a more cost efficient approach, so therefore our
design goal was to make a reduction gear which had no rubber isolators or
pendulous dampers/absorbers--using only the gears, prop shaft and flange to
provide torsional control.

Although we found that pendulous dampers/absorbers are indeed the "gold
standard" in terms of torsional control with planetary reduction gears, they
are very expensive to design and produce despite the fact we did both these
functions in-house with the exception of heat treating.  In addition to the
cost factor, we found that even a very well designed planetary reduction
gear  you still have a large amount of backlash at the prop. It is simply a
function of the configuration and all those gears.  In addition to the added
costs, the planetary has a larger number of failure modes, and the factors
make for a potential detuning problem due to misfires, throttle operation,
etc.  Of course pendulous dampers and the cage all add weight and complexity
as well and will, as the checkbooks of Lycoming and Continental drivers can
attest, wear out and require replacement.  We dealt with this with the
Lycoming side of the engine business.

It was the combined factors noted above why we originally designed our first
torsionally stiff internal gear unit to eliminate the need for pendulus
dampers or rubber isolators.  The first was designed in late 1994 and built
in early1995 with flight tests subsequently in the RV-4.  Folllowing the
necessary refinements, we found the design hell-for-stout.  After Everett
died, it was this refined second-gen gear set design that I sold to the
"new" Powersport/RayTech machine for production.  Steve Weinzeral, the
consulting engineer to Ray Richardson, made a few changes to it which made
it stronger yet.

He also added another roller bearing, replacing the
Lycoming-type plain bearing in the nose.  But it remains the same basic
configuration.  I obtained that original second gen protype from them as
well as a "new" Powersport reduction production reduction gear recently so
have them both for evaluation and use with the new RV-3.  I know that as is
the case with many businesses, they have struggled with the economy but it
is my understanding the production reduction gear was still available. Sure
hope that is the case.

From what I've seen in recent years, this is the strongest, safest reduction
gear in production.  Their production version is just a little heavier than
our prototype unit from which it evolved.  Steve Wienzeral did some nice
other nice touches in the refined production unit, such as incorporating
what we did on the SuperLight all-aluminum engine with the starter ring gear
and engine counterweight all machined in one piece from billet.  When
properly serviced, our design was intended to be an infinite life piece
without the degradation inherent in components such as rubber.  This
reduction gear is not the cheapest (I think was selling for approx. $6500),
but the best is never the cheapest.

The design of the reduction gear was to mimmick and reinforce the basic
rotary design feature of "less is more".    Therefore, it has no torsional
dampers/absorbers or rubber isolators to wear out.  It used an internal gear
just as does the rotor, and the WWII Allison reduction gears.  Our design
was the simplest possible in terms of parts count--basically just a
torsionally stiff gearset, propeller shaft and flange doing their thing.
The pinion gear has its own steel support with bearing which bolts to the
power section/reduction gear casting adaptor.  Our original unit was even
simpler...with the pinion gear cantilevered off the eccentric shaft.  This
worked.  We flew it for almost two years.  But it tended  to tullip the ring
gear over time due to the inevitable runout from the eccentric bearing
clearance.  It is the one we toasted coming across the line to win class at
the Sun'n Fun 100 race in 1997. So we added the pinion support bearing.  It
was a major step in durability and strength.  It was incorporated in the
second-gen redesign on which the production unit is based.  Because the
complete unit is torsionally stiff, the engine thinks the propeller is the
"flywheel" and eliminates the addition/weight of a flywheel.  We had a
below-the-radar skunk works tie with the then engineering head of  a section
within the power transmission unit of Ford Motor Corp. who contacted us and
consulted with Everett to refine this design in the mid-1990's.  As you can
appreciate, it was just a coincidence that Mazda was a part of Ford.

Our torsional vibration calculations were later confirmed when the unit was
instrumented and tested by Dr. Ronald L. Eshelman following the sale of
Powersport to Ray Richardson/RayTech.  The results of Dr. Eshelman's work,
and that of consulting engineer Steve Weinzeral, was subsequently published.
It reportedly confirmed our calculations regarding the different torsional
equation, the fact it did indeed address completely the torsional needs of
the two rotor engine and could be used with the three rotor engine.  The
longer shaft has a different frequency that puts it within the operating
range.  Thus the need for the additional absorber that I understand they
specify  for use of the design for three rotor engines.  I have not seen one
of these.

Our flight tests showed, as did Dr. Eshelman's tests, that the combination
of the torsionally stiff, short shaft for the two rotor, and the torsionally
stiff  reduction gear, successfully put the frequency of this combination
outside the operating range.

These notes are not meant in any way to speak negatively regarding Tracy's
work with planetary units.  I admire Tracy for the work he continues to do
to promote the use of rotary aircraft engines.
-----------------------------------------------

Paul PS:  the use of required components to provide more than one function
to simplify a design (in the case of our design using the stiff reduction
gear to address the torsional equation of the engine/and propeller without
the need for torsional absorbers/dampers or isolators) seems not unlike what
you were able to do with race car wings.  Your recent email reviewing your
high race car wings of the 1970's, showed a similar approach and I was
struck once again by the absolute brilliance of your design.  That passive
change in wing incidence feature you designed into these using weight shift
of acceleration and braking is flat out outstanding engineering and the most
unappreciated and unheralded work of an era.  And it appears to eliminate
the complexity and driver work load of the earlier Chapparal actuation to
change wing incidence on braking and accelleration.  I watched your
"passive" change wing work during lots of races during those years and never
understood what was actually going on.  Obviously, neither did the
"brightest race car designers of the day" such as Colin Chapman and others
who never figured it out, leading to the unfair and inaccurate conclusion
that these high wings were unsafe.  Your wing design, together with
tranferring the loads to the hub carriers rather than the spaceframe or
monocoque, are among if not the most significant major chassis/aero
developments for race cars in our lifetime.  The body/frame mounted "high
tech" wings stuck on suppossedly state-of-the art race cars today are
positively retrograde by comparison to what you did almost 40 years ago.
Kudos Paul.  That was amazing work.

Steve Beckham



-- 
The Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://www.rotaryeng.net
Youtube key word UTUBPLEASE
Copyright 1998-2008 All world wide rights reserved.